The differences in the metrics between "large" counties and "small" counties is really poorly thought out

Analysis

Some of you have seen me as the case updater for Chelan-Douglas counties. I talked a little in my post today about the new metrics. Here is a bit of a deeper dive.

First, here are the metrics to stay in Phase 3:

SizeMetricGoal
>50,000New cases per 100,000 over 14 days200
New hospitalization per 100,000 over 7 days5
<50,000New cases over 14 days30
New hospitalizations over 7 days3​

I am going to come right out and say I can't make heads or tails of why they choose to split these metrics out the way they did. For one, there is a huge change right at the 50k mark. At 49,999, the new case metric amounts to 30 cases. At 50,001, the metric amounts to 100 cases. But then, a county like Garfield County, with a total population of 2,200 has the same metric in absolute terms as Douglas County, with a population of 43,000. Shear madness. For another, the hospitalization metric is both too small a number and too short a period to be statistically significant. Five hospitalizations for a small county is all it takes for a county under 100k to be downgraded. That could easily just be a particularly at-risk family all getting COVID and going to the hospital. More madness.

But let's do some math to further analyze the metrics. I'll use Chelan and Douglas counties for example from now on, since I can speak to them.

Chelan County has a total population of about 77,000 people, which places it in the "larger" category. Its largest city, Wenatchee (population 34,000), lies on the Columbia River, which represents the border between Chelan County and Douglas County, and is directly across the river from East Wenatchee.

Douglas County has a total population of about 43,000 people, which places it in the "smaller" category. Its largest city, East Wenatchee (which including its unincorporated population is about 26,000 people) also lies on the Columbia River, right across the bridge from Wenatchee.

Along with Wenatchee and East Wenatchee, Cashmere, Monitor, Sunnyslope, and Rock Island all lie within 10-15 miles the urban center. That amounts to about 70,000 all together in the main population center of the two county area.

Now here is where the ridiculous part comes in. Chelan and Douglas Counties, despite having around 60% of their total population residing with 15 miles of a single point, comply with completely different standards. Here is the breakdown:

SizeMetricGoal (absolute)Goal (per 100k)
ChelanNew cases over14 days154200
77,000New hospitalization over 7 days35
DouglasNew cases over 14 days3069.77
43,000New hospitalizations over 7 days36​

As far as new cases go, Chelan County's per 100k metric is more than twice as large as Douglas County's metric. On top of that, the 69 per 100k 14 day case county that Douglas needs to meet? It hasn't met that metric since at least June of last year. Meanwhile, Chelan County can coast along with more than double the rate and meet its metric.

But that isn't all! Now lets consider the hospitalization metric. Notice anything strange there? That's right, Douglas actually has an easier metric than Chelan on this one! So for one metric, it is more than twice as difficult, the other metric is 20% easier. That makes great sense.

Two big problems with this. First, its makes no sense for the same population center to be held to two vastly different standards. Laxer standards in Chelan County are going to have a negative impact on Douglas County's ability to meet it's harsher metrics. Second, when April 12 rolls around and Douglas inevitably fails to meet its metric (which would require it to reduce its incidence rate by half... not likely, especially since vaccine rollout has been slower there), East Wenatchee will be forced to move to phase 2 while Wenatchee may remain in phase 3. What side of the river you are on will determine how open you can be.

This is quite frankly ridiculous. What do you all think?

Posted Mar 16, 2021, 6:50 AM UTC · edited

86

Do both counties have hospitals that are able to care for in-patient Covid?

2
mastapsiOP•

No. There aren't any in-patient facilities in Douglas County AFAIK. The hospital for the area is in Wenatchee. Even more reason why is crazy that the two counties are considered separately and with different standards.

3
barefootozark•

First, thanks for detailing it out and showing how the plan shows no logic.

Is there even a website to show where your county is by the new metrics. The Roadmap to Recovery site still shows 8 regions... they're not even trying help people figure out the current status of covid in their area. Nothing I've found has current 14 day cases/ 100K by county. I've tracked things pretty closely up until a month ago but not sure why track it... the state doesn't. I think the state just changed criteria to make it appear that they're really looking closely and trying to figure it out. I'm not convinced. It's just change to keep everyone guessing what is going on.

If you don't like the weather current recovery plan, wait 10 minutes 3 weeks... it'll change.

1

Thanks for sharing your analysis. At face value the requirements between large vs small struck me as “off”. I’d be surprised if they actually followed through and pushed the smaller county back to phase 2. It seems like they set these goals and then change the rules rather than move counties back. They’ve changed these roadmap rules so much since the first announced I’d take any goals they set with a grain of salt. But yes, this is a ridiculous scenario you laid out.

1
Senno_Ecto_Gammat•

Are you telling me Jay Inslee and all his interns who wrote all this scientifically bankrupt nonsense are pushing scientifically bankrupt nonsense?

Say it ain't so!

-2†
mastapsiOP•

I really don't agree with your views, I mostly think Inslee has done a fair job at managing the pandemic given the lack of federal support and lack of good information in the beginning. Look at places like Texas, where more double the number people have died on a per capita basis (and Texas is a moderate example, there are states with death rates 4 times higher than Washington). Our hospitals never filled beyond capacity, unlike many other states, though it was close. In terms of deaths per capita, Washington ranks 45th, incredibly low compared to the rest of the country. Based on other states, not having mask mandates or restrictions could have lead to 3 or 4 times as many deaths, amounting to up to 18,000 more deaths in the state.

Do I wish we could have had easier restrictions? Yes. If people had just put the damn mask on and worked from home if able, maybe we wouldn't need long term shutdowns. But people wouldn't wear the damn mask and we got what we got. They turned it into a political statement and hundreds of thousands of people in this country died. We know from other countries we could have done better. And the economy has suffered yes, but unemployment is nearly back to where it was at the beginning of the pandemic.

But I do think this latest set of metrics is harebrained at best. It isn't even that they are too restrictive. They just don't make logical sense. Some metrics are easier and some are harder for different sized states counties. There's a huge step in the metrics at 50k. And they don't account for counties that have shared population centers.

4