r/VALORANT•
NihilHS

Idea: Selective / Optional Economic Handicaps in Unrated to Aid Match Making

Many of my friends play at about a silver level. While I don't play much comp, I placed into Plat in both act 1 and 2. When I 5 stack with 4 of my silver elo friends in unrated, two undesirable things happen. Firstly, the queue times are rather large. Secondly, the match maker does well to find a fair opponent for us, but it results in my teammates playing against players that are stronger than who they would otherwise face even in ranked.

This has made it so that many of my friends have to be in the "right mood" to queue with me. That is, they have to be ready to either try really hard or get absolutely demolished. Most of these games end up with 4 weaker players on each side and they boil down to which raid boss can carry harder. Even in unrated, my friends wind up getting punished for playing with me.

Now one option I have to circumvent this problem would be to smurf. Personally I think smurfing really sucks. It ruins competitive integrity which, even in unrated, I think is important. Consequently I have not and will not make an alt. I of course understand that Riot cannot and should not make policy changes based on what I want. But certainly I can't be the only player that experiences this sort of thing. I think that most players in my shoes wind up making a smurf and moving on. If we could address the underlying problem (punishing friends when queueing with them on our mains), it might help mitigate the amount of smurfs in Valorant.

Interesting workaround: what do you guys think about giving players that are higher elo but queued with lower elo teammates the option to take on economic handicaps to even the playing field? Note this conceptually would only be applied in unrated.

How it would look: If a minority of a queue has an outlier elo (like 3 silver 1 plat or 3 silver 2 plat), the high outlier elo can check an option to indicate that they're willing to be balanced with economic handicaps. The match maker treats people who opt into this as having an unrated MMR that is discounted by some amount due to the handicap. In other words, a queue of 4 silvers and 1 plat that opts for handicap will be treated as 4 silvers and 1 gold.

How does the handicap work? It could work like this:

○ If the match maker detects a moderate elo deviation:

• The handicapped player cannot pick up guns dropped by allies

• The handicapped player's allies cannot purchase guns for the handicapped player

- Result: the handicapped player must buy their own guns or pick up enemy weapons

○ If the match maker detects a large elo deviation:

• The same rules from above apply

• The handicapped player cannot pick up opponent's weapons

○ If the match maker detects a severe elo deviation:

• The same restrictions from above apply

• Weapons and utility must be bought at a static premium calculated before the match begins

- In other words, for the handicapped player a Vandal might cost $3900 instead of $2900

Again this is solely for unrated and solely for situations where there is a minority in a 4 or 5 queue that is substantially stronger than the rest of the players in their stack, and solely when those players opt into the economic handicaps for a game.

This would be nice, as it would allow my friends who happen to be lower elo to unwind and goof off in a - from their perspective - normal unrated game. It would also allow them to do so while playing with me without punishing them for doing so. And, to be quite honest, that's what I care more about. I would be more than happy to take on restrictions to make it easier for the match maker to find a fair and fun matchup.

Posted Mar 20, 2021, 1:32 PM UTC

20
Loading comments…