Need to replace Subaru Outback, wondering if there are alternatives worth looking into.

My Subaru Outback was just totaled (drunk driver). So I should be getting some money from insurance and I have a decent savings now. The current best plan is to just get another Outback but also curious about alternatives. (Price point is I suppose around $30k or less, open to either new/used, potentially willing to go up for the perfect car but ideally not.)

My wishlist is a bit of a unicorn but just to give a sense of things I'm looking for:

  • 4x4/AWD mandatory. Many trips to the snow in winter. Ideally stocked with good tires for that too but if not I'll swap as one of first things.
  • Decent clearance and front skid plate either as option or easy to find aftermarket part. I do lots of summer climbing/camping trips that go over forest roads. I'm not actually an off-roader, these roads are generally fine, just bumpy, but once in awhile you go over a rough or washed-out section with exposed rocks and I'd like some peace of mind for those sections.
  • Decent for sleeping in. Nothing like camper conversion. But with rear seats folded down it should be decent for sleeping in with my sleeping pad and bag.
  • Not overly bulky in size. Unfortunately I still do live in the city and realistically most of the driving is in that, so being at least okay-ish for parking in the city is helpful and decent city/highway handling (e.g., probably not a Wrangler).

So some other brands/models I looked at, with potential negatives.

  • 4Runner. My dream car. Love the off-road performance, reliability, fanbase that raves about it, ease of mods, can get optional skid-plate and full-sized spare. Big downsides are it's pricey (would have to be used model, but even then, resale values tend to be high) and it's just too big for me until I move out of the city.
  • RAV4 TRD. This trim has better clearance and skid plates and other stuff. Got Toyota's reputation for reliability. But pretty pricey for this trim (near impossible to find used here), and RAV4 seems a bit smaller in size and maybe not great for sleeping in.
  • Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk. Love the look and off-road capabilities of this trim. Have found some local dealers with used models (2019 and 2020) well within price range. However have heard rumblings about reliability issues with Jeep and funky transmission.
  • Subaru Outback. Loved the Subies I've owned. Now comes with dealer option for skid plates. Will have to factor in another grand-ish to slap on good tires. Again, right now this seems like winner, but just researching other options.

Posted Mar 22, 2021, 4:34 PM UTC · edited

46
nlspitfire•

Id take the outback but its your choice.

1
jawnstownmassacre•

Really the only drawback to the outback is the CVT. If you can live with that, subie all the way.

1
rtechnixOP•

I have had no major issue with CVT on my last (I mean I miss the feel of gears and using the shifter [don't like shifting in CVT, rather let computer control it], but it wasn't really necessary).

I like that other models have solid AT tires on straight-away (though have to research, some AT tire models are surprisingly terrible on snow/ice). Default Subie tires tend to be pretty mediocre all-seasons. But I'll ask dealer if they can do that for me and slap on a discount since it's replacing brand new tires.

And the Trailhawk is really tempting for the offroad capabilities. Like I said, I don't often, but once in awhile you do find yourself before a gnarly section. I'm talking Eastern Sierra roads like Upper Buttermilk, Laurel Lakes, Tinemaha Creek -- which ideally is just a simple 4x4 road but you never know after the winter melt if there's a washed out section of ditches and exposed boulders. That said, after a particularly white-knuckle drive on Upper Buttermilk awhile back, I've decided to pack a shovel and some sandbags and planks just in case for next time.

1
autotrader_addict•

My wife has an Outback, so I've pondered the 'what's next?' thought quite a bit. Overall for cargo space, reliability, comfort, and gas mileage (2.5 non-turbo), it's pretty hard to beat. The only gripe I have is it is not fun to toss around a twisty road, but it's not trying to be that anyway. I've got my own cars for that. RAV4 is a decent choice, though the AWD system isn't the most handy on a trail. The Trailhawk might be the most capable CUV out there right now, but I've shied away too due to reliability. I'm sure it's not terrible, but I'm not willing to put up with much trouble in a daily driver.

That being said, I would throw a couple wildcards into the discussion:

Honda Passport - Does most everything an Outback can do off road. More power, better handling prowess, and normal automatic are pluses. But gas mileage isn't quite there and it is a couple inches wider so it might feel a little big to you.

Ford Bronco Sport - surprisingly capable off road (watch some YouTube videos on it), and not too big either. I'm not sure if it's quite big enough inside if you're trying to car camp though. You'll have to see one in person to make that decision.

1
rtechnixOP•

The Bronco Sport is definitely real interesting. Being a new model though (well kinda not really but long hiatus) always hesitant to see how first generation pans out in terms of kinks and issues not known yet. But Ford generally has a pretty good rep I think for a US brand.

Also looks like skid plates don't come until Badlands trim which is getting pricey (and no optional add to lower trims). But I'm sure won't take long for aftermarket to start making parts for that.

1
vulcan583Volvo S60 IP•

You could get an XC70. Volvo stopped making them in 2016, but they run forever.

1