The Xinjiang Atrocity Propaganda Blitz
redsails.org/the-xinjiang-atrocity-propaganda...Posted Mar 25, 2021, 3:23 AM UTC
Posted Mar 25, 2021, 3:23 AM UTC
We are a safe space for leftist discussion. Reminder: Liberals aren't left and neolibs will be dunked on.
#####FEATURED LEFTIST: thecanadafiles.com The Canada Files is a news organization covering Canadian imperialism, left-wing activism, and key world issues. Please check them out and support independent Canadian media.
#####Be Aware: List of Left Canadian Media #####Be Organized: Join the canadaleft Facebook or Discord to talk all things Canada.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
okie dokie atrocity supporter
Found the western chauvinist.
You support slavery. How can you accuse anyone of being a chauvinist when you support one people subjugating another?
But I don't support the USA?
Sarcasm in order to avoid the point. Typical deflection. The USA doesn't have slavery. China does.
You know this is transparent, right? Your use of sarcasm implies that you know you are wrong. Fortunately, the west is a little bit smarter than the east and doesn't fall for these low brow tricks.
"Yes, I hate Muslims. How could you tell?" -NoMansLight
Have to make up fake quotes just like you make up fake genocides. Sad!
OK genocide supporter
be sure to print out your comment, maybe it'll help you get a lighter sentence in the laogai when you get sentenced for being slightly off the party line
It took less than a minute in your post history to find you supporting the fucking British monarchy, a racist institution responsible for the death of billions and the theft of trillions. Your post history reads like an anti Asian hate crime waiting to happen.
Excellent article. Darren Byler, the Kissinger Institute Fellow, and AKA Adam Hunerven in his article for Chuâng, was who Briarpatch had cited almost exclusively for their section on Xinjiang in their recent article in defense of the atrocity propaganda blitz. "Anti authoritarian" "leftists" have sure made some odd bedfellows with a bunch of national security state and military industrial complex propagandists here.
Incredible parallels to the western anti-Semitic and anti-communist propaganda campaigns of the early twentieth century. Surely radlibs will reflect on the massive increase in hate crimes against Asians that this campaign they've been so vocal in supporting has contributed to, and learn to take a more measured tone in their critiques of the PRC going forward...
I find this whole thing deeply frustrating, in that none of the information on what's going on comes from a source I trust, but China - as best I can tell, anyway - has done nothing to reassure me, either. It seems apparent that something questionable is probably going on there, given the few somewhat objective findings (primary sources and area photography mainly) and the total lack of effort to make a reasonable refutation on the part of China. It also is abundantly apparent that the neolib propaganda machine has dug in its heels and flooded out any kind of actual information.
It reminds me a lot of the second iraq war in that sense, except that everyone is buying what the US is selling.
It is frustrating. Finding anything that doesn't toe the US imperialist line of just bleating and repeating the most far fetched allegations anywhere in the mainstream (or even alternative) english language press is rather difficult.
I'm not sure about how young you might have been in the lead up to Afghanistan and Iraq Part II (I wasn't that old myself, but can still remember the tone of the media in the aftermath of 9/11/01), but I would emphasize that practically everyone (in the mainstream, at least) was buying every single nugget of the horseshit that US was selling. Everyone took it as undeniable fact that the Taliban was hiding OBL (they weren't) and that Saddam was building nuclear weapons (he wasn't). The media worked overtime to revise all records of their positions once public sentiment turned against the wars, but every major english language outlet was totally behind GW Bush until several years in - and anyone who expressed any degree of skepticism was called a "terrorist loving secret islamist" (sounds familiar to the "CCP shill" and "genocide denier" lines, doesn't it..).
However, like I'd said, the article OP posted is extremely well cited and sourced - especially with recent historical examples to highlight the difference in tones of coverage from when Oceania went from being at war with Eurasia to being at war with East Asia (but remember, we've always been at war with East Asia). If you haven't already taken a read through it, I'd strongly suggest it. Best of all, the author fully admits what they don't know, and is transparent in their rationale for arriving at the conclusions they reach - admissions that are increasingly rare these days, and most especially when it has to do with the matter at hand.
IMO, what provides the clearest lens to view this issue through is looking at the US's own stated rationale for arming and training the Mujahideen and ETIM (TIP) during the eighties. The region of Afghanistan that's still under control by the US and the warlords they support is the northern region where the Wakhan corridor provides a direct border crossing into Xinjiang. Take all of this into consideration alongside the fact that ETIM/TIP were removed from the US's own international terrorist organization list at the exact moment the Trump regime began ratcheting up these tensions with China way beyond the Obama era Pivot to Asia policy (which bears investigation in its own right) - right at the moment this atrocity propaganda blitz began. Mike Pompeo, who switch hit for both the State Department and CIA during the Trump regime, has admitted that they're using Xinjiang to help build public support for more aggressive foreign policy against China.
Lastly, consider the dual purpose this campaign has: the US has verifiably proven concentration camps which we've seen the insides of, they have sterilization programs that are forced upon black and other minority populations, and forced prison labour is widely used. They're running Goebbels' propaganda playbook of accusing their enemy of the crimes which they're guilty of. This stategy ensures that they can always deploy their "whataboutism" line any time their own crimes are called into question, and allows them to redirect justifiable public anger at those crimes towards their enemy.
I was in my 20s, and not in the US. Outside the American media bubble, the US pretense for war was widely variable in the media; it was one of the first times I really started comparing international reporting on biased topics and realized how semi-useless the news is. Certainly there were news outlets toeing the American line, but it was easy to find counterpoints as well, even in mainstream sources. For example, the BBC was quite loudly against the WMD arguments.
I need no convincing to believe that the primary thing we're experiencing here is another US saber-rattling buildup to violence, nor that they're guilty of the same things inevitably that they accuse their opposition of. What I'm frustrated by here is that, unlike in 2003, this time I cannot find any major media that doesn't report pure propaganda. There is no mainstream source that has anything but the same pap from the same two primary sources, or utterly ridiculous stuff like BBC's invited tour and its blatant alarmism. Despite what you remember, that is profoundly different from twenty years ago.
This is revisionism of the worst kind. They claimed the September Dossier was "sexed up," which is the same kind of tripe you hear today about Zenz claims (he may have exaggerated a tad...)
There was no loud opposition, and suddenly you appear to be more actively fostering a sense of unknowability than actually being uncertain yourself.
I don't understand what you're talking about.
They literally let the BBC into the vocational centers, and this is what the BBC did with it:
https://medium.com/@sunfeiyang/e284934a7aab
They let Olsi Jazexhi in, and this is what he did:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D81oggm8DB8
What exactly do you want China to do when your entire journalist base is worthless?
We saw what "the free press" did to Bolivia during the November 2019 coup. We saw what they did in Hong Kong.
You can literally go to Xinjiang yourself and check it out. Nobody's stopping you. Many people already have. Additionally, most countries in the planet support China on this:
https://twitter.com/CaoYi_MFA/status/1374276827737391105
The lack of visibility is deliberate. You're behind a self-imposed information curtain.
Yes, that's my point. It's very difficult to get any kind of useful information, short of learning Mandarin and traveling to Xinjiang myself. That is why I am frustrated. Anything available about what is going on there is caught in a sandwich of juggernaut propaganda machines.
And, edit to clarify, that includes (especially) government invitations to view facilities. Unless there is some wealth of English language material I'm lacking, what we have is entirely one propaganda machine faced off against another.
Well, if you read the essay I shared, it's precisely about what you can do when faced with this impotence.
[deleted]
I think one thing that keeps getting missed is that there is a terrorism problem and all states are bad at fighting terrorism. China is trying a lot of the same stuff that other countries, like France, have attempting unsuccessfully for years. Mass surveillance and incarceration wasn't exactly invented in China.
While also remembering that the terrorism problem is absolutely being funded by the CIA in their psychotic, relentless need to be the worst organization on the planet. So if you want to stop "East Turkestan" terrorists maybe look in Virginia not Xinjiang.
China's rehabilitation program is closer to Finland than France. A big emphasis on training and education. China obviously sees Americas legal system is an incredible failure and human rights disaster and sees no need to follow that. It's easier and faster to train and educate the people that need it than to lock them up in terrible conditions and not improve their ability to prosper like America does. America's punishment system harms society, China sees Finlands rehabilitation just works, seems silly to think China wouldn't just follow the path of least resistance and do the thing that actually works.
You are absolutely correct, it is incredibly frustrating, wading through information sources, wondering just what can be trusted. Here is one ongoing project to break down just what is happening in Xinjiang. It's certainly changed my opinion on the situation; perhaps you may find it helpful as well.
The third academic in the "list of experts" is Darren Byler.
Such a joke.
The cherry on top is the preface to their "critical reading" of Zenz's first propaganda piece on Xinjiang (which ends with them essentially agreeing with every assertion) where the author of this blog (@BadChinaTakes) describes their "warm" twitter DM correspondences with... Drumroll... Senior Fellow in China Studies at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation Adrian Zenz.
Thanks, this looks really good.
Say...Have you ever considered the possibility that if the entire fecking world, save the government of China and a few Contrarian dumbasses in the West who support it for some reason, are on the same page on this issue, then maybe, just maybe, you guys are the ones who are wrong?
What exactly am I supporting? I've been pretty clear throughout this thread that I'm not on China's side here either.
There are around 80 countries on China's side. That sort of news omission is what I'm talking about.
Funny how you can only qualify "the national security state and military industrial complex propagandists" as if this is somehow a bad thing. Yes a country that enslaves people, wrongfully imprisons canadians, and actively manipulates and poses a direct threat to everyone they trade with is a national security threat.
Name one. China is literally enslaving and killing people. A few hurt feelings are not equal to human lives.
Never. China is an old world tyranny. Their problem is that they can't face criticism. And western societies are entitled to give it. We don't watch our tones. Its better to just piss them off and force them to show their true colors, like China repeatedly has. All their sensitivity proves is how weak and inferior their government and national identity is.
It's beneath anybody to engage with screeching fact-free tirades like these.
Yelling doesn't make your accusations any less false. And all this talk of "inferiority" sounds quite Nazi tbh.
You mean the nazi government and national identify? You're not trying to make sense. You're trying to use a trigger word to sway public opinion. Thats literally what China does and what the nazis did. Two ethno-fascist soviet communist states. Nice try playing your game of opposites. Christians conflate qualifiers with facts too. How else would you posture complete bullshit?
Yes their national identity is fueled by a cultural identity of inadequacy. THATS what inferior means. THEY are the ones that need to pretend they are superior because THEY are the ones that struggle with subjective inferiority.
Completely unsurprised that a communist just stated the opposite of reality based on a buzz term. Completely unsurprised. You wouldn't be a communist without this. And that applies to any other kind of snake oil, too.
🥱
I hope this isn't representative of this sub. Pretty typical cryptofascist.
Anyone who tries to conflate the nazis and the communist cant even be called a crypto fascist. You're just a full out fascist