Neverwinter Nights attention to detail appreciation

NWN1

​

https://reddit.com/link/md5902/video/dc5fpps3x7p61/player

Seriously, how cool are these "matched combat" animations with all the parrying and dodging? And it even works across all kinds of different shapes of creatures. The developers didn't have to do this, but they did, and to me it at least add a ton of enjoyment. It makes the fights so much more enjoyable to watch when you have this proper sense of interaction between the units.

Sure, it's still fundamentally turn-based, and it shows, but the animated parries, shield blocks, and dodges really add visual flavor to it all.

https://reddit.com/link/md5902/video/tttfj3xs08p61/player

Also, when an arrow misses in NWN, it actually lands somewhere in the terrain, or alternatively it's animated as hitting the shield of a character with a shield. In most similar games, the projectile will just vanish into thin air.

https://preview.redd.it/6ct30uclx7p61.png?width=1593&format=png&auto=webp&s=c6bfad30b4435b85c0e780a39263e24773609c1f

Another really cool detail is how reading a spell from a scroll actually has an animation of your character reading a scroll before casting the spell. They truly went the extra mile with this game.

Sadly, NWN 2 really dropped the ball when it comes to this visual detail. The animations are horrendous in general, parries and blocks aren't animated (even in parry mode!), projectiles vanish on miss, characters don't flinch properly when hit, no reading from scrolls animation. It's all gone.

But to me stuff like this definitely weighs more than having pretty environments and such. NWN1 may have blocky environments and meager graphics overall, but at least the animation work is superb. Having a shield equipped is significantly more satisfying when your character actually visually uses the shield, instead of the shield just being an abstract stat buff and an "idle" cosmetic thing.

Posted Mar 25, 2021, 6:43 PM UTC · edited

6218
2013jcwmini•

I thought the same thing in 2002 when it came out and then in 2020 I thought,”Damn, they did a damn good job in ‘02 with this game!”

12
MultihogOP•

I guess it might have to do with the fact that they took five years to develop the game. Certainly wasn't rushed.

3
JudgeHoltman•

NWN was clearly a passion project for several developers. Lots of extra details and flexibility built into the engine.

NWN2 was the one where they actually made some money by getting it out on-budget and by the deadline.

6
Valkhir•

On the positive side, in NWN2 sneaking characters actually crouch. As someone who spends more time sneaking that fighting, I wish they added that to NWNEE.

10
MultihogOP•

Ahh, yes, you're right. That's the one thing that's missing. So NWN2 does have something over 1 in the animations department after all. It's a bit jarring to be casually walking around when in stealth.

6
cloud3321•

Ehh.. Not all sneaking in in a crouching position. I do a lot of sneaking up and pickpocket in certain modules and crouching in the middle of a crowd breaks that immersion.

Even when sneaking around an enemy camp, it's more of skirting in areas where you can't be seen rather than crouching.

I bet Bioware did discuss this and decided to opt out of crouching due to the reasons above and personally I like this better too.

3
Nuukkis•

What i hate in Nwn 2 is that most of cleave attacks aren't animated. Npcs just fall to the floor like they gave up on life.

Nwn 2 felt either rushed or lazy compared to the first game. Am i the only person who thinks Nwn 1 also looked better in terms of graphics?

6
MultihogOP•

Absolutely. The game isn't some text-based dungeon crawler from the 80s, so why do I need to imagine half of the visuals?

That stuff makes it hard for me to enjoy NWN2, even if the game would have other merits.

4
Nuukkis•

Indeed. I still like it somewhat, but i just wish they had done things properly.

2
MultihogOP•

NWN2 feels half-baked in more than one way, yeah. They even recycled a lot of the music and spellcasting chants from NWN1. Corners were cut, to the detriment of the product.

2
Nuukkis•

Yeah the audio part of the game has to be one of its weaker points. Npc fighting sounds were also ripped from the first game. I love to go through the first chapter of the campaign where every single bandit has that same long scream of death which they just ripped from the prison district of the first game.

2
vapidchap•

Respectfully disagree. I think NWN2 is a remarkably beautiful game, even close on 15 years later. Sadly, the same can't be said of NWN1: Even contemporary Bioware games like KOTOR are much more visually appealing. But the primitive graphics are the price we users paid for the game's modularity and flexible toolkit, which has given NWN1 lots of longevity – as OP's second screenshot (from rogueknight333's spectacular Swordflight – Chapter One, built in 2008 and still being played today) proves.

1
Nuukkis•

Fair points. I don't really agree that after 15 years its that beautiful, but for a 2005 game it is not bad at all. And now that i think about it the graphics on the first game don't really seem that inviting.

2nd game is a step up on that aspect, but a step down gameplay wise. Animations (running, standing, battlestances, facial expressions) are in some cases really bad and especially first few hours the game feels really unresponsive and clunky. Also the 2nd game has a remarkable amount of different bugs that weren't officially patched.

I like both games though. They are a lot of fun to play with friends.

2
MultihogOP•

NWN2 is alright when it comes to static environments, yeah. Doesn't look bad at all. But when it comes to things moving, it's quite hideous.

The quality in this video sucks, but you can make out well enough what's happening: NWN2 combat video

At the very start, the character's running speed and animation are mismatched, hence it looking like they're on a treadmill. At 0:06 you can see the attack of opportunity "animation", which is just a yellow 2D sprite. 0:07, the enemy attacking the player character is standing *way* too far for it to actually make sense that they can hit them. 0:08 there's a hilariously bad blood splash effect on the character behind the player character and another 2D effect, plus the character being hit doesn't even flinch. 0:26 bear on a treadmill. 0:30 lol-worthy walking animation on the friendly character walking across, plus of course treadmill. 0:29 worst death animation ever? 0:34 the way the player character's attack animation stops abruptly at the end of their attack in a janky manner (common in all anims in this game).

This is just shoddy stuff all over. Wouldn't have been acceptable in a 90s game.

1
BowShatter•

Regarding the animations, I'd also like to add that creatures attacking significantly smaller ones will do a stomp move or swing their weapons downwards. Really nice detail that I didn't notice at first.

3
Reklawenalp•

Oh. That's something I have not notice... Since I only ever use gnomes and halfling nowadays

2
BowShatter•

No worries. It'll be your characters getting stomped on by dragons then.

2

Also, when an arrow misses in NWN, it actually lands somewhere in the terrain, or alternatively it's animated as hitting the shield of a character with a shield. In most similar games, the projectile will just vanish into thin air.

And when you hit, that arrow is stuck in the critter (for a while at least). Fun seeing a zombie approach you with several arrows stuck in it.

I usually play zoomed out, overhead. I noticed that sometimes, hitting TAB will light up a monster name in the distance but you can't actually see or target it with the cursor. Then I found out that if I zoomed all the way in and lowered the camera angle, I could then see the enemy and target it with bow. While in that mode, when you fire the bow, the arrows have a nice arc to the animation.

2