White creature stealing

Posted Mar 25, 2021, 10:40 PM UTC

Posted Mar 25, 2021, 10:40 PM UTC
This was inspired by the r/EDH thread about whether white should be able to steal creatures. I say yes, but in a way that is easier to get back than when blue does it.
Looks like a color shift of those blue and black cards, but it's also notably similar to [[Debt of Loyalty]]. Another take on this could be [[Evangelize]] as suggested by Time Spiral block as sort of an "mind control edict."
One neat custom card I sawconcerning this was something along the lines of:
Creature — Human Peasant (U)
When ~ ETBs, gain control of target creature with power 1 or less until ~ leaves the battlefield.
2/2
I don't quite remember its name nor whether the gain control was actually permanent or until it left play. Anyways, I found it to be a nice design combining both the flavor and mechanics of white into a control magic effect.
So I do think there are several potential angles a designer could take approaching this. As for "whether white should be able to steal creatures"... Eh, dunno, that's harder to answer and I feel like it would need much more in-depth inspection of what would be the goals of altering the color pie in this manner. All I can say at this conjuncture is that I think it's feasible.
Debt of Loyalty - (G) (SF) (txt)
Evangelize - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
I like this from a balance perspective; it's a control effect that doesn't 2-for-1 the opponent.
With that in mind, I'd expect any white "steal" effect to be more about enforcing conformity in a "one of us! One of us!" kind of brainwash conscription. Like an effect that lets you gain control of a creature as long as you control another creature of the same type.
I like that idea from a flavor perspective, but from a mechanical one it is either useless 90% of the time or it is run alongside a bunch of changelings. Interesting, but not very useful.
Yeah, I could see it as a rare in another set that focused on the "party" mechanic, but not much else.