Amazon decides to fuck with Elizabeth Warren. Finds out that is a bad idea.
Posted Mar 26, 2021, 4:02 AM UTC
Posted Mar 26, 2021, 4:02 AM UTC
Stone Cold Liz Warren
Elizabeth Warren’s pronouns are fuck around/find out.
As if they weren't already at the top of her shit list.
Actually, I'd love to see her shit list - that would be as fun as it would be informative.
edit: sometimes I don't spell real good.
It comes on stationary with “1- Mitch McConnell” printed at the top.
I imagine it's not so much written down as something she recites to herself every night before bed, Arya Stark-style.
Anyone screen shot? Tweet is gone
It is strange. I can't find it on her feed but the link works.
It's a reply to a reply, so unless you're scrolling in replies you wouldn't see it. The root tweet is here: https://twitter.com/SenWarren/status/1375189145476288513
The tweet is still up as far as I can tell, but here's a screenshot: https://imgur.com/a/RWBxvKW
😍
Damn, she put the hammer down on that one. Go LIZ!!! She'll snap those fingers...mm hmmm.
[removed]
So Warren admits to wanting to punish Amazon for engaging in constitutionally protected speech. This is no less frightening than when Trump did it.
Just as important, Amazon is right and Warren is wrong. It's the politicians who pass the laws that Amazon and other companies respond to. The laws that Amazon allegedly "exploits" are purposely designed to encourage re-investment. Warren should feud with her fellow senators about tax policy instead, but that wouldn't fire up her supporters, would it?
Does Amazon pay "close to nothing in taxes" as Warren claims? Nope. It paid about $162m in federal income taxes in 2019. It pays even more than that in state and local taxes. What is Amazon's "fair share" of taxes anyway?
I think it's obvious Warren is grandstanding as all politicians do, and unfairly treating companies she doesn't like. Perhaps this is why only the military is an institution that inspires more confidence than Amazon. Last place? The institution Warren has long inhabited: Congress.
No where does Sen Warren talks about punishing "Amazon for engaging in constitutionally protected speech". This post is inane.
Direct quote from Warren's tweet: "And fight to break up Big Tech so you’re not powerful enough to heckle senators with snotty tweets."
I recommend you read this article from the Columbia Journalism Review: "Trump's Threats Amount to a First Amendment Violation"
Ahh interesting. Thanks for sharing.
This is not a first amendment violation since it's literally a part of her agenda is to break up big tech and get corporations to pay more of their fair share.
The actual cited case focuses on a local sheriff using their political clout to get a company to stop accepting payments for a website that was allegedly engage in illegally activity.
Those are fundamentally different governmental activities and speech acts.
The bit about the local sheriff is only another example of how threatening someone for unfavorable speech is likely a first amendment violation. The first half of the article cites multiple examples of Trump doing the same.
I understand Warren's agenda. However, it doesn't give her license to make punitive threats based on speech she doesn't like. Trump was heavily criticized for doing this, regardless of his agenda to "take on" the MSM. Warren should be too. What's more, Amazon was simply pointing out a truth, something Warren takes as heckling?
There's another highly worrying aspect of Warren's tweet. She's essentially accusing our democratic institutions of being mere pawns of big corporations. Amazon wrote the loopholes they exploit, she accuses. And...somehow got Congress to pass them, and the President to sign them. Wow! No wonder confidence in Congress so low. Now that her party controls Congress and the Presidency, you'd think she'd focus on reversing those loopholes.
Does Amazon pay "close to nothing in taxes" as Warren claims? Nope. It
paid about $162m
in federal income taxes in 2019. It pays even more than that in state and local taxes. What is Amazon's "fair share" of taxes anyway?
That link is about how Amazon skirts taxes, maybe you meant to link something else? But to answer your question - their fair share of taxes is at least 35% of profits/income, like the rest of us pay.
From the article:
"But according to regulatory filings reviewed by GeekWire, Amazon plans to pay $162 million in federal income tax now, and another $900 sometime later on, taking deferrals to which it is legally entitled."
The rest of us pay "at least 35% of profits/income" on taxes? Who's this "us" who earn over $200k?
That link is just federal. But yeah, by that link Amazon would be in the top bracket of earners and should be paying at least 37% federal taxes. Great point!
Then why doesn't Warren propose it instead of the nebulous "fair share"? Last I heard, she only wants to tax every dollar of profit above $100 million at 7%.
Sounds like you should contact your Congressperson about changing the tax code. Exactly Amazon's point!
The laws that Amazon allegedly "exploits" are purposely designed to encourage re-investment.
LOL no they're not. You can tell because they don't do that. Corporate tax breaks never result in "re-investment," higher wages for lower-rung employees or better prices for consumers. They always result in stagnated wages, mass layoffs, price hikes and obscenely fat executive bonuses.
From the Inc.com article posted earlier:
"In 2018, Amazon made $11 billion in profits before taxes, paid no taxes, and received a $129 million tax rebate. This was due to a combination of carryforward losses from its unprofitable years, tax credits for investments in R&D and the fact that it pays people in stock options, which often create deductions for employers when employees exercise those options." (emphasis added)
From the WSJ:
"Let’s start with investing. Amazon said it has spent more than $160 billion since 2011 on investments, including its distribution network, cloud-computing centers and wind and solar farms.
When a company buys depreciable property—such as warehouse equipment—it treats the costs differently for tax and financial purposes.
For the financial statement, the company records expenses over the asset’s useful life, not subtracting from current profits. For tax purposes, companies can now deduct the full amount immediately for many capital expenses, reducing upfront taxable income and thus taxes." (emphasis added)
No shit they're gonna SAY that's what it's for, but the fact remains it doesn't actually pan out that way. You yourself quoted the part where they made $11 BILLION in profits and paid NO taxes, despite their insistence they paid "billions and billions" in taxes.
Bottom line is Warren didn't write those tax loopholes because she knows damn well corporations will exploit them to avoid paying any taxes on their billions in profit. And you know damn well if she could single-handedly rewrite tax laws to close those loopholes and hike their corporate tax rate to WW2 levels, she would, but she can't because Amazon has used their tax rebates not for re-investment or R&D but to bust unions, poach popular products from 3rd party sellers and buy politicians to protect their assets.
R&D investment is reported to the IRS. If Amazon didn't in fact make those investments, and instead used its income to "bust unions, poach popular products from 3rd party sellers and buy politicians to protect their assets", it has broken multiple tax laws. Even worse, bribery is a major crime. I assure you, the FBI and IRS would be highly interested in any evidence you can provide to them to support your claims.
I know what Warren would single-handedly do. Fortunately, we live in a democracy where politicians don't have the power to single-handedly enforce their will. Instead, they have to work with others of like mind to pass reforms. Perhaps Warren should focus more of her energies there.
This line has absolutely made my week. 😆
Amazon should have known better than to start something with Warren. When it comes to Twitter wars, she tends to win.
I’m trying to remember exactly what she said in her book where she discusses how she decided to start a Twitter war with Donald Trump back in 2016. Even while other Democrats were dismissing and laughing at him, she was worried about him succeeding because he sounded “Like Regean without the charm.” One of her friends asked her if it was worth giving attention to a person like that, and shouldn’t she just take the high ground instead of rolling around in the mud? But Warren wanted people to think about the issues, and she knew a lot of people were paying attention to Trump’s Twitter, so she decided it was worth it. And it worked to get people engaged. Millions of people read and re-tweeted her pointing out that Trump was racist and had no actual plans for things like student loans.