Predicting Lives Saved from Vaccine in MA
Since vaccinations have started, I have been trying to find a way to understand the number of deaths that have been prevented/lives saved. One rough way of estimating that I have found useful is by trying to estimate the % of future deaths that have been saved by the vaccine. In order to calculate that, we do the following:
For the age group 65-74
- In the US (115,381 / 526,028) = 21.9% of deaths have come from people in the age group 65-74
- According to the weekly report for MA, (482.4k / 682.8k) = 70.6% of 65-74 year olds have been given the first shot
Given the % of deaths from 65-74 year olds and the % of 65-75 year olds already vaccinated(1+ shots), we can estimate the percentage of lives saved in the future, if we did not have a vaccine. The formula looks like the following:
% of total US deaths from this age group x % of people in age group vaccinated = % of total deaths prevented
So for 65-74 year olds it would be the following:
.219 x .706 = 0.154 -> 15.4% of all future deaths prevented just from the vaccines for this age group
We can also do this for other age groups and sum them to get the total % of deaths prevented in MA(I only did 3 most vulnerable groups):
Was hoping to get some feedback on this and whether people find this to be a useful metric to use to gauge our progress. I know it is faaaar from a perfect metric. Here are some of my assumptions/things I am not considering in the calculation
- I am assuming that the moment you get 1 shot you will not die from COVID
- The people in the 50-64 and 65-74 groups that have already been vaccinated are likely a more vulnerable group than the groups on average because of the phased rollout of the vaccine, which may mean that the % future deaths prevented is being underestimated
- I am assuming the proportion of deaths in the US is the same as in MA. I know that is likely not the case but I couldn't find deaths by age group in MA so
- I am assuming the proportion of deaths by age would be the same going forward, which would likely be different because of changes in behavior
- I am not including the younger age groups which account for a small proportion of deaths
- I am ignoring immunity for previously having the virus
- I am ignoring the people in each age group that have already died and so no longer should be included in the calculations
Posted Mar 26, 2021, 3:51 PM UTC · edited
I appreciate that you tried to do this analysis, but this is not correct at all.
Just starting with this formula
That's just not right. You're multiplying a relative quantity with an absolute quantity and using that as a stand in for the % of total deaths prevented.
If you don't believe me, multiply all your absolute death values (e.g. 78.8, 115, 308) by some percentage (e.g. 1.1) and redo the calculations. This would be like giving vaccines later in the pandemic. You get the same end result despite clearly having saved fewer lives in that scenario.
You need to tie in estimates of the total vulnerable population left and the IFR.
I really like the concept, but the math is completely wrong, not just in the assumptions made, but in the actual calculations themselves.
I think there may be some confusion on how I am calculating things. The 78.8, 115,etc correspond to number of deaths in 1000s for each age group, it is not the percentage that is used in the formula you’re mentioning.
For example, the 21.8% in the 65-74 example is derived from 115k deaths for 65-74 / 526k total covid deaths. Meaning that the 65-74 year olds account for 21.8% of total US deaths.
Please let me know if there is any other confusion!
Yes. I know what they refer to, but you did not calculate it correctly.
Sorry, I’m a bit confused. Which calculations are incorrect?