r/bmpcc•
Carson369

BRAW Workflow Question

Hey guys so I’ve been in the sub for a little bit but now I’m finally going to own my first BMPCC. The 6k specifically.

Something that’s been unclear is how you go about coloring the footage after you’ve transcoded the raw to ProRes. Say I were to shoot in Raw but edit a film in Final Cut, how would I then get it back to a colorist after it’s been made ProRes? Do you just lose out on the raw capabilities or is there a way to connect back to your original files once it’s been cut? If you do lose out on that then is there still any benefit to shooting in raw or would I be better off just doing the 4K ProRes?

Any insight would be helpful, thank you!

Edit: Thank you for bearing with my newbie questions guys, I really appreciate it.

Posted Mar 27, 2021, 8:02 PM UTC · edited

618
w1ll1am4815162342•

What have you guys been smoking? Of course you can connect back to the raw files. But not in final cut I believe.

Send the source (braw) and a xml to the colorist and you should be good.

First step - export a offline refference, a mixdown video as it should look

Step two - Try to clean your timeline to as few tracks as possible and then export the xml.

Step three - put these on a hard drive with the source and send to the colorist.

8
Carson369OP•

Thank you I appreciate this! Would I be able to still change the file names of the original raw files for organization? I would worry about accidentally disconnecting things.

1
CastorTroyMcClure•

No you should never change the source file names. That will prevent proper relinking.

Only ever change the name in your NLE, which should never change the source file.

3
Carson369OP•

Ah okay, that’s what I suspected. Thank you.

1
w1ll1am4815162342•

I honestly do not know how the organization works in fcp but as long as you can get the real source names in the tape name metadata you should be fine. Do a test is always the best answer

1
Carson369OP•

Fair enough, it seems like it’s going to be a completely different workflow then what I’m used to but I’m excited to try it out.

1
filmismymedium•

You can go to prores but it doesn’t make much sense if you don’t have to. I’m not sure if FCPX handles BRAW but if not then I guess you could try transcoding to PR proxy or something small and then reconnect. In that case you would ideally send the XML of the finished cut to Resolve and reconnect to the BRAW files to do the color pass.

My 2 cents would be to edit it in something that handles BRAW files directly though, like Resolve or Premiere.

1
Carson369OP•

I appreciate it, hopefully Final Cut does incorporate the support at some point! I prefer working in it over any other NLE by a lot.

1
zakfenning•

You would lose out on raw benefits, and the files are bigger as prores. Keep it raw.

0
Carson369OP•

I wasn’t super clear in my post, but keeping it raw throughout the whole process isn’t an option within my editor. It’s a bummer that there’s not a more streamlined way to do this yet.

2
CastorTroyMcClure•

Transcode the braw to proxies, cut with those in the NLE of your choice, then go back to the braw for finishing.

This is typical workflow, known as offline (creative editing with proxies) to online (finishing at highest quality for delivery). It's how every movie/tv show is made

7
Carson369OP•

Awesome, I really appreciate your help! I’ve only had a vague understanding of this stuff.

1
CastorTroyMcClure•

NP- good luck and have fun!

1
zakfenning•

Yeah go with this if the editor is pro or cutting on a potato

1
holdstillplease16BMMCC•

You can’t reconnect prores back to braw. I have this same workflow, but I do all of my raw metadata work before I export the prores. I color correct in FCPX.

0
Carson369OP•

What exactly is that raw metadata step if you don’t mind me asking? I’ve never touched raw in any camera so it definitely all seems a little overwhelming.

1
holdstillplease16BMMCC•

ISO adjustment is probably the biggest benefit. DaVinci also has a very good Highlight Recovery option if anything gets clipped. Works especially well for exterior shots with bright sunlight. I know some editors who prefer to make all of their contrast and white balance adjustments in RAW, but it’s a matter of preference. I usually just look over the ISO options to see if anything looks better, and I always click the Use Video Black Level option. The highlight and shadow rolloff features are also cool on certain shots.

2
Carson369OP•

Awesome, I’ll definitely have to play around with different options.

1