Starting Strength with a calorie deficit diet?

Howdy!

31 / M / 210lbs / 5' 10"

I'm trying to lose about 30 pounds. Until now I've been biking about 4 times a week (about 100 miles). This week I started SS.

I am still eating a restricted diet, targeting 2200 calories per day (in a 1:1:1 protein-fats-carbs balance). This means I'm running a deficit of around 750 cal per day when biking, and a deficit of however many calories I'm burning while working out on SS days.

I realize muscle helps burn fat, but I'm concerned that I'm not going to see any gains, and may actually hurt myself, with this routine.

My question is this: is what I'm doing ok? Should I postpone SS? Should I give up on the diet? Should I run a greater deficit on cardio days, and eat more protein on SS days?

Thanks in advance.

Posted Nov 17, 2011, 12:08 AM UTC

711
Boutros-Boutros•

The worst thing would be to put off lifting until after you lose the weight. This will make you lose muscle that will take a lot of effort to get back. Don't give up on the diet either.

Lifting on a deficit most of your strength gainz will be a result of improved CNS activation rather than hypertrophy, but as a a new lifter that is still a lot of strength to gain. You will retain your muscle better than if you lost the weight without lifting and are less likely to end up skinnyfat. Basically you will be stronger and have more muscle when you finish your cut than you would have if you didn't lift while cutting.

11
addmoreice•

not to mention your tendons will get stronger, which is something you will need as you go heavier, why not get it now aye?

1
Dialaninja•

So, this is purely anecbrotal, but I've been on a 1000 calorie or so deficit for the last 3 odd months, and all my lifts have gone up (obviously not as much as they could if I were eating a surplus) and I've lost ~32 pounds so far. (from ~218 to ~186)

Make sure you get enough protein on lifting as well as resting days.

I don't follow SS, but I do lift things up and put them down. (squats, deadlift, bench etc.)

6
jakeman81•

Well I'm not sure what your workouts consist of, but sure, it's possible to make gains on a caloric deficit.

Are you adding 5lbs to every exercise and 10 to deadlifts every time you workout? I'm mid-SL and I not only have a voracious appetite, but if I slack on nutrition one day then my performance is very notable. This is even more apparent now that I am lifting a lot heavier weights, whereas early on I could've ate at a deficit and still improved.

I'd suggest reading around, there's tons of threads with information like this already answered as well as the author of SS stating clearly what your nutrition needs should be if you're interested in starting.

Good luck!

1
2ndLaw•

Keep lifting and keep your protein high (I can't link to the study right now because I'm mobile, but it was something like 2.3g of protein per kg body weight to reduce/eliminate muscle catabolism while eating deficit).

Essentially, you have to give your body a reason to keep the muscle (lifting) and provide it the adequate tools to allow those muscles to remain (protein).

3
moronometerOP•

Does it matter when I eat?

Should I eat the extra protein right after I work out? That evening? The day before?

1
coalWater•

You might want to take a look at this. It's a really simple (and effective) diet.

3

This threat screams leangains. Surprised to find it way down here.

4
tkliteWeightlifting•

A calorie deficit will just cause you to recover slower, which means you won't progress as quickly when the weight gets heavier. Not a bad thing, just expect your linear gains to end sooner than guys who pack in 3k+ cals per day.

3
stewsky•

I've been doing SS for almost 3 months now and have been running about a 1k calorie deficit daily. I began stalling about a month ago on bench around 190 and OHP around 115 and had to deload to work on squat(240) and DL(275) form about 2 weeks ago. Definitely not making linear gains anymore and I doubt I will again unless I started eating at a surplus.

However lifting is great exercise and makes me feel amazing afterwards and also helps preserve my muscle mass. If anything it's great practice for form work and getting a feel for heavy weights.

3
CoachSeven•

If you've read Starting Strength, it is based largely on the premises that you need calories to build muscle. It also states that the program is specifically designed towards the exclusion of all other exercises that could potentially hinder strength gains.

It's obvious you want to lose weight while gaining strength. The problem is, these are conflicting and mutually exclusive objectives.

My personal recommendation is that you focus on one first and, if it is an option, the one you focus on first would be strength, thus postponing your weight loss objectives... this of course will depend on why you're trying to lose weight in the first place (preparing for competition, etc).

Once you do undergo a diet targeted towards weight loss, you will be better off with a regime that requires higher reps at lower weights than SS. That's how bodybuilders have been doing it for decades, and they are, after all, the pros.

2