Are clicky switches bad for typing?

Im currently looking for switches for my mechanical keybaord, i really want clicky switches because i think just hearing the sound per click will make me crazy in a good way. (i’ve tried before).

Posted Mar 28, 2021, 2:10 PM UTC

312
Markus-simig•

There are no good or bad switches. I have used blues, reds, and browns. They really just feel different and it is all a matter of what you prefer. Chances are you will like the feel of your first switches regardless, as the experience with mechanical keyboards is significantly better than any membrane. So go with your gut at first and if you feel like you need a change a few months down the line than switch it up and see how you feel about the new switch. No reason to base your claims off of a thought.

TLDR: try the one you think you will like the best, and return it if you do not. Then try the other switches if you returned it, and make a “final” choice from there.

4
ep1939•

I would disagree that mk are better than membrane ones. Some of the fastest typers in the world use their notebook rubber kbs.

This is just to say that it is really personal after all. (I say it as a mk user btw).

2
CharmingSpinach•

If you have co-workers in a shared office: yes, they are bad! ;)

If you already tried them and liked the feel: definitely use them for typing!

3
Moderators-OP•

Ty man

1
crazyates88•

I actually really like the feel of clicky switches, but the noise can be bothersome esp if you are in any sort of shared space (office, bedroom, etc). Tactile switches are my second favorite, but tactile usually offer a bump more than a snap. I don’t know if it’s possible to get a snap like a clicky without the noise, but they are actually good for typing.

2
Moderators-OP•

WOW tyyyp

1
XenAlpha2020•

depends. in my opinion, just don't go for linear because it's not good for typing due to misclicks. click or no click doesn't make a difference, just go for an actuation force that is high, but not so high that your fingers get tired.

2
Moderators-OP•

Ty

1
raydatasci•

Initially, when I peek and seek typing, I preferred the clicky switch (kaihl box white). I cannot feel the bump of tactility on my gateron brown keyboard during that time. When I started touch typing and gliding my fingers to type, I started feeling the tactility of my gateron brown keyboard and start disliking my clicky switch. I think if you are raising your fingers more to type and you are more of a keyboard banger then clicky will be your preferred switch. If you are a finger glider like a pianist, the tactile or linear switch will be your preferred switch. (This is my experience typing for 1hr + daily at monkeytype.com)

1
ClickandThock•

Love clicky switches for typing!!

1
jaybird787•

Bad‽ IMO I think clicky switches are the best for typing. Though, in my experience, I tend to type best with both audible and tangible feedback.

MX Blues (or equivalents) are a good choice if you want the clicky feedback.

0
Moderators-OP•

THANKS

1
Determinant•

They're nice for typing but please don't bring it to work because it's too distracting

0