We are carnivores at heart.

Please don't spread misinformation.

"That's why beef gives us heart disease"

Ah yes, the given thou must taketh. "Give" it's not a case of 'Eat me and I will give you this!'.

My statement is not incorrect:

  1. We ARE carnivores at heart, lets assume for 1 second that eating meat does in fact give you heart disease. From the very start us humans existed do you really think we would have sat down and had a nice scientific conversation about the apparent adverse side effects from eating meat? Tens of thousands of years ago our ancestors would live to eat meat and whatever they could feast upon.
  2. In this case, you are wrong. According to the British Heart Foundation (A notable source of my conclusion) found here references a publication from JAMA Internal Medicine. They essentially explained in that publication that processed meats, unprocessed red meats and/or poultry was the reason for small increased risks in coronary heart disease, strokes, heart failure and/or death related to heart and/or circulatory diseases. Sounds scary right? Reading through the article gives me a good sense of how much effort JAMA Internal Medicine did not put into their research. Like the BHF have stated, a 3-7% increase is still incredibly small as a risk. It is not a certainty, it is a risk that could happen. Healthy people can suffer from heart disease. But lets look into it further. The researchers according to the BHF "analysed six existing studies from America, which included the data of 30,000 people that was collected between 1985 and 2002." Continuing they state "Out of 30,000 people there were 6,963 heart and circulatory events and 8,875 total deaths during the average 19 year follow up." The BHF have stated that the research is broadly representative of the general public (at least in the US). Why is this important? Well, on some reliable websites when you enter in information to check your BMI for example, some (such as the NHS [National Health Service here in the UK] ask for your ethnicity, you do not have to give your ethnicity, it is optional just like your gender. But you do have to enter your age and other vital info to calculate your BMI. This research does not take into account the general broad diverse population all across the globe, only broad populations in the US. Lets be real here, the US is known for its crazy food additives and insane processed meats (Not that this doesn't occur anywhere else but it's a starting point). According to the British Heart Foundation "A weakness of this study is that it defined a portion of red meat as 4oz (or 120g), and this is more than the average daily intake that the UK government has based its guidelines on (around 70g per day)." Here is an important excerpt from their page that highlights some issues with the study: "The people in the study who ate meat most often likely to be younger, male, current smokers and more likely to have diabetes, higher body mass index, higher cholesterol levels and lower diet quality. Because this type of study can only show an observation rather than cause and effect, it could be these or other differences that caused the results. The researchers adjusted their findings to account for many possible differences, but this process isn’t perfect. Also, the research was based on self-reported data like questionnaires, and what people say they eat and what they actually eat could be different. Also, these people were only asked about their diet once when they entered the study, and their diets may have changed during the average 19 years of follow-up after that. The study also didn’t consider how the meat was prepared. This could explain the findings that linked poultry (such as chicken) with heart and circulatory diseases, because it could have been eaten as fried or processed chicken, with the added fat and salt that comes with it."

Overall for point number 2, I wouldn't really be listening to research that doesn't go incredibly in-depth when it comes to food and our bodies along with relation to diseases we can obtain. Our bodies are incredibly complex machines that we still don't know too much about to be confident in research studies. There are over 8 billion people on Earth, a research study with questionnaires that has around 30,000 participents means absolutely nothing to me to draw a conclusion on adverse effects of eating meats.

Last but not least, point number 3. I said we are carnivores at heart. We have evolved over tens of thousands of years, our bodies are not the same as our ancestors once were, they could definitely devour flesh and pieces of meat on a daily with seemingly no side effects because they were accustomed to that life. We are not, our ancestors essentially exercised daily, they chased their food and rewarded themselves with it. They were strong, muscular and full of energy to fight their way through each day. That study has one flaw. It does NOT take into account exercising or habits of people participating within their questionnaire. Who am I kidding, it's a questionnaire. Not all data is going to be exact, this isn't an individual study on each of the 30,000 participents. Most probably had small lies as talked about here, here and here

I think I've covered pretty much what has needed to be covered.

Posted Mar 29, 2021, 2:49 AM UTC

16
Thefundamentaltask•

If limp dick could be expressed through a wall of words it would be this post

12
haikusbot•

If limp dick could be

Expressed through a wall of words

It would be this post

- Thefundamentaltask


^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^Learn more about me.

^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")

7
plaidalertabsolutely NO mushrooms•

As a Certified Murderer I actually don't have a heart, czechmate vagines.

8
Jerry_the_Goatscared of bEaNS?•

Anti-vegan once argued with me that British Heart Foundation cannot be trusted since all cardiologists want more patients and they’re misguiding us purposefully.

7
DisturbingDegenerateToddlers are under donuts in the food chain•

Don't care. Didn't ask.

Go be caveman or something

3
AutoModeratorMOD•

VCJ is for vegans only. It is not a primer on Veganism 101. Help us keep the sub protected by reporting omnis, apologists, babysteps, and support of plant based capitalism. VCJ is not a discussion sub and lengthy comment chain debates will be removed when spotted. Go to r/VeganForCircleJerkers if you want to unjerk. --- Join Our Official Discord - Must be 21+. I'm vegan.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1