Chess would be more fun without needing to declare check/checkmate

I learned how to play chess in 3rd grade, my friend Ben taught me. On our second game I beat him, and he said "no you cant do that"

Cant do what? Take his king and win. Because on my previous move I didn't warn him that I was going to. I thought he was making up rules, but no. This is how chess works. Even though the whole point is to set up a situation where you can take your opponent's king, once you are in a position to do so you need to warn them first so they can escape. Stupid.

Imagine if connect 4 worked like that. Pretty sneaky sis. Oh wait. Not sneaky at all because you warned me you could win on your last move and I blocked it.

Some people are going to tell me that the point isnt to take the king, the point is to set up a situation where the king has no escape. Ya ya ya whatever. That would be like needing to set up 3 pieces in connect 4 where you could get 4 on either end, the connect 4 checkmate.

In connect 4 you can just win because your opponent didn't realize they were in peril. Wouldn't it be more fun if you could just win a game of chess the same way?

Posted Mar 30, 2021, 12:43 PM UTC

86
albertnormandy•

At the level of chess where people don’t realize their king is about to be captured I say play however you want.

5
7788445511220011•

You don't have to tell people they're in check. That isn't a rule.

You can't take the enemy king, though, because ending your own turn in check is an illegal move. I believe even if there is some situation where no one notices that an illegal move has been made and therefore its apparently possible to take the king, it is illegal to do so anyway.

But sure, it would add a little bit of flex to actually take the king, assuming the opponent doesn't resign beforehand. Personally I find the checkmate more aesthetic than playing it out all the way to capturing the king.

I'll also add that this rule is probably geared towards beginners, it's bad enough blundering your queen and effectively losing, and would probably just ruin people's fun if they were allowed to give away the game by exposing their own king unknowingly. The checkmate requires the winner to at least think one move ahead, and thinking moves ahead is pretty much the whole point of chess.

With that said, it's not very unpopular among chess players to want to allow people to make illegal moves like this, particularly online where the game will not allow an illegal move (whereas over the board even in a tournament, you can physically do it and then face the consequences of that.) Particularly in blitz and bullet it's not that uncommon even for high level players to try to move a piece pinned to the king and expose the king.

4

I thought it was a stupid rule at first, but it's more fun to beat your opponent because they literally can't do anything, and not just because they didn't see your queen put him into check

3

I agree with this me and some friends play often and we don’t bother with Check or Checkmate. We figure if you don’t pay enough attention then it’s on you.

You are right we have way more fun playing this way

2
derek2446•

If you’re playing at that level then you don’t really need to follow all the rules. However, if you’re playing in tournaments or on any competitive level, it shouldn’t be hard to know.

2
Maerzgeborener•

It is about the respect to the king. The opponent has no right to even touch the king of the other side. It was a game for rulers nonetheless.

1