Yes No Yes technique - When a Q person shares a theory
I'm not a psychologist, just an idiot with an idea.
So we know that conspiratorial thinking is not about the theories themselves, it's just an unhealthy way to get emotional fulfillment through fantasy.
Therefore I think when a Q person is sharing a theory with you, the 3 things they are "really" saying are:
- I am hurting, this fantasy helps me feel better
- Will you believe it, or at least think it's interesting, thus affirming my fantasy?
- Will you still support me, even though you don't support my fantasy?
As caring people, I think our answer to these 3 questions should always be yes, no, yes.
When you react with frustration, anger, boredom, disinterest you are answering: fine, no, no
When you react with careful listening, and interest in the theory you are answering: yes, yes, yes
When you listen patiently, even asking questions (but not affirming!) and making time for them... Being careful not to respond positively to the theory - but the person with a positive emotional note like "i love you", "i will always be here for you" you are saying yes, no, yes.
It's kind of like a fine line to walk, might take some practice to not do it in a condescending or patronizing way.
Posted Mar 30, 2021, 3:22 PM UTC
I think this is a really good way to put it.
Having said that, while you understand that there is a "fine line to walk" between showing caring, provoking an insecure and therefore easily provoked Q adherent and enabling there are maybe some nuances that should be addressed.
As an example, I know with my sister I said "I am here for you" and I got blasted with a cussing tirade, which culminated in a series of personal attacks and abuse and "Don't bring your psychology shit in here" (I do have a Bachelor's degree in psychology) so... It should be noted that I approached her though instead of waiting for her to come to me with it.
Also, most Q folks intentionally provoke. It's part of that contrarian stance imbedded within the ideology that many of them find so appealing. They can unleash their inner hate and frustration and feel justified. They are looking for opportunities to do that and any challenge to the fantasy is usually justification enough in their minds.
I can see how this approach could be great in the right situation but... it would take a lot of finesse, which is frankly, asking a lot of from people that have been abused by this person they are now being asked to handle with kid gloves and be "loving".
that's a great point, I'm glad someone with some education responded.
I guess if someone is that antisocial the sane partner has to be incredibly strong and consistent, never wavering from their support, even in the face of constant abuse. Not fun, but is there any constructive alternative when you can't walk away?
To answer your question, no not really that I know of.
Most mental health professionals would advise making a plan to put some distance between yourself and this person if at all possible. But if you can't, and plenty can't, what you described is a very good way to outline the why's and how's of a constructive approach.
It's a hard sell certainly though.
This is my sister exactly. I think her hatred and shame of herself after a lifetime of mental illness and addiction has come out in rage towards the perceived “cabal”, and now towards me. I have tried every possible approach. My degree is psych is also being used against me. This is my gay, once democrat sister. Now she has a criminal record for stalking and criminal trespassing of an elderly neighbor she thought was torturing babies and harvesting adrenochrome... I’m at a total loss
Are you sure she doesn’t have paranoid schizophrenia or some other kind of very serious mental health disorder?
Because that last part sounds like someone who is EXTREMELY mentally ill and not just someone who has been reading a lot of conspiracy theories online