EmbracingHoffman•

Nobody starting a "psilocybin company" is helping people, they're just trying to get in on the ground floor of the "next CBD" type phenomenon. I would bet insane amounts of money on this. This is a substance that teenagers can grow in their closets.

He's a profiteer. Ironically, this article kinda hit on this: "Being an advocate is not the same as starting a company".

28
edubkendo•

Well I'm not exactly a fan of the medical/pharmaceutical industry, I do genuinely believe that the mainstreaming of psilocybin as a medication does have a lot of potential to help people.

I don't know a lot about Carcillo or his intentions here, but the fact that he's personally benefitted from psilocybin treatment is a good sign that he's at least partially motivated to help people.

6
EmbracingHoffman•

How is him throwing his hat into the already-oversaturated-ring of monetizing a substance that cannot be patented helping people?

All he's going to do is patent his proprietary product, which I'm sure will be a microdose product of X milligrams of psilocybin with cult-of-personality celebrity athlete branding. Same shit that Travis Barker does with CBD in a landscape of 6 billion CBD products- Carcillo is just earlier on the adoption curve of this particular phenom. He's just inserting himself as a useless middleman to turn a profit off of his social status. The veneer of medicine is just a convenient mask for this useless non-value-add.

4†
edubkendo•

If he's pulling together money to fund the science needed to prove the safety and efficacy of psilocybin as a treatment for TBI, that helps, both people with TBI as well as the legitimacy of psychedelic medicine.

If he makes that medication accessible to people that don't frequent theshroomery or r/unclebens, I'm ok with him making some profit off of it.

I'm a big advocate for growing mushrooms, it's become incredibly easy for pretty much anyone to grow themselves a personal stash for macro or microdosing. And that option will always be available to anyone so motivated. These companies can't take that away. You literally just need some spores and a bag of uncle ben's pre-cooked rice to go the simplest route.

But not everyone will do that for an infinite number of reasons. If there are standardized, science-backed products that someone like my conservative father would be comfortable taking, I don't see that as a terrible thing.

10
EmbracingHoffman•

Why start a for-profit company rather than a non-profit if this is true?

Private companies handling medicine has always been an objectively shitty thing. For example: pharmaceutical R&D is heavily subsidized by taxpayer money, but then the cost of that R&D is used to justify the exorbitant cost of things like insulin.

I agree that pushing psychedelic medicine forward is a good thing. But if that was the primary goal, then why this business model?

Not saying everyone should grow their own. I never have. But the very notion of for-profit psychedelic companies like Wesana, Compass, and whatever else is pretty disgusting and transparently a grift, as far as I can tell. I'm open to changing that stance, but I haven't heard a compelling argument.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
EmbracingHoffman•

Then why do it as a for-profit company rather than a non-profit organization? The latter would be much more effective at accomplishing his alleged goal.

3
[deleted]•

Cannot be patented? Monsanto would like a word.

1
EmbracingHoffman•

Psilocybe cubensis or any other psilocybin-producing fungi cannot be patented without genetic alteration, yes, though I believe you mean BASF as Monsanto was acquired by Bayer in 2018 and sold off most of its seed business to BASF.

Psilocybin itself cannot be patented, however.

1
_bass_head_•

Sure, teenagers can grow mushrooms. But teenagers can’t provide themselves a clinical setting with therapists trained in psychedelic assisted psychotherapy, which is what his company is doing.

1
EmbracingHoffman•

Sure, then why not do it as a non-profit considering he's been making millions as a celebrity athlete?

1
Reagalan•

Keep the doses low and it may not be necessary. There was a recent double-blind study on LSD dosing found under 50 mics caused no negative effects or anxiety whatsoever. There's obviously some threshold, under which, that stuff is safe as fuck. Psilocybin and LSD both work via the same mechanism so there's likely a threshold with shrooms too.

Plus, psytrance raves already exist.

(Insomniac Presents: Cyberdelia. A Guided Mushroom Experience!)

0
EmbracingHoffman•

There's actually a correlation between more intense experiences and higher therapeutic utility (I haven't had my coffee yet, so apologies for not linking.)

I think the higher the dose, the more useful/necessary a guide can be, especially for the inexperienced. Further, having someone with psychological training to help process any material that comes up is part of the utility, as well. That being said, this only strengthens my anti-for-profit-model stance: compare how you'd feel tripping with an underground psychedelic therapist currently who strongly believes in the work enough to put themselves at risk vs. some corporate therapist you found through a for-profit app that advertises on facebook.

1
Reagalan•

Anyone getting a job as a therapist like that is likely someone currently underground who will then be able to get paid for their guidance.

I fucking hate capitalism too (see my many comments in lefty subs) but it's what we have at the moment and we gotta live with it. And by that, I mean, therapists and guides should be paid for what they do.

Maybe the solution is an uber-style app. Advertise your service directly.

And the obvious solution is socialized medicine, which has been needed forty fucking years ago but the conservative Republican bloc and their dumbfuck voter base has stifled it at every turn.

Every issue you have with this has it's roots in the failures of right-wing medical policy and it sucks, and i hate it, but fuck sake any sort of legalized psychs will be of benefit to people, and i'd rather that than status quo.

-1