r/HealthInsurance•
hamingo

Health insurance denied claims as "not medically necessary" for the time that I was under the care of a clinical student

Claims/Providers

I received 6 weeks of physical therapy for a long term issue (adhesive capsulitis). My insurer determined that my care was "not medically necessary" after 6 weeks, but only started processing my claims 12 weeks after the treatment began, so I received another 6 weeks of treatment that was deemed "not medically necessary".

My provider appealed the decision and submitted records from the beginning of treatment through the date when I received the claim denials en masse. The appeal was denied because my medical records demonstrate a slow but steady improvement during the first 6 weeks, followed by a period of plateauing (eg. minimal to no improvement) over the next 6 weeks.

My provider is a licensed DPT (Doctor of Physical Therapy) at a clinic attached to a university DPT program. My provider is a clinical faculty member at the university, and the clinic is intended to allow DPT students to gain clinical experience treating patients under the supervision of a licensed DPT.

My provider, the professor/DPT, treated me by herself during the first 6 weeks of treatment. The following 6 weeks (the plateau period that United used to determine that treatment was "not medically necessary"), I was treated by a DPT clinical student under my provider's supervision. The claims were submitted under my provider's name. After the student's clinical rotation ended, I returned to the sole care of my original DPT, and my injury started to improve again.

I am currently writing a second appeal by myself, as my provider and I both agree that the physical therapy I have been receiving is in fact medically necessary for me to be able to complete everyday tasks like bathing and dressing myself (both are very hard to do with frozen shoulder, I require assistance from my partner to dress/undress). The fact that the plateau in progress ended and was followed by more improvement to my injury demonstrates that the treatment is in fact medically necessary, and that it is working!

​

My question is: should I mention the clinical student in my appeal letter? I can't say for certain whether the plateau in my recovery progress was due to being under the student's care or due to something else. My provider told me that it's pretty common for people with my injury to see steady progress punctuated by periods of plateauing/no progress. I'm not sure whether mentioning that I was being cared for by the student (who was under my provider's supervision - again, the claims were under my provider's name) will help or hurt my appeal. I could see United denying this because the submitted claims are under my normal provider's name, but the student she was officially supervising was the one actually providing care.

I also definitely welcome any other tips or advice people might have for crafting an appeal for a "treatment not medically necessary" denial or appeals related to treatment by clinical students.

tl;dr: Health insurance says that records show that treatment was ineffective and therefore not medically necessary. But the time period when treatment was ineffective was when I was being care for by a supervised clinical student! Do I mention that in my appeal?

​

edit: I'm not sure if location matters, but I am in Florida and my insurer is United Healthcare Student Resources.

Posted Mar 31, 2021, 6:01 PM UTC

1113
zebra-stampede•

Student clinicians / interns don't bill. They're supervised by a practicing physician and typically bill under that doctors NPI.

The issue is the insurance thinks the care wasn't medically necessary not so much who administered the care (from my reading).

Google and find your carriers medical necessity criteria for PT. See where you do or don't meet them and either provide additional evidence or appeal around it.

Also it's not that the insurance didn't process it until later it's that your provider likely didn't file claims until later. INN providers typically have 90-180 days to file claims. Insurance processes claims as soon as they're received.

for me to be able to complete everyday tasks like bathing and dressing myself (both are very hard to do with frozen shoulder, I require assistance from my partner to dress/undress).

I wonder if this type of rehab should've been done under the care of OT instead of PT actually as well.

9
hamingoOP•

The issue is the insurance thinks the care wasn't medically necessary not so much who administered the care (from my reading).

The issue - as explicated in the insurer's denial letter - is that the treatment didn't result in any improvement in my condition during a particular period of time, as evidenced by measurements in my PT records.

That period of time coincides exactly with when I was being treated by the student. My recovery improved at a steady rate both before and after the period of time when I was treated by the student.

What I'm asking is whether I should include the info about the no-progress period perfectly coinciding with the student treatment period in my appeal, or if that will result in more trouble.

2
zebra-stampede•

I think you're going to find it difficult to prove that this student, who is operating under the supervision of the DPT, was the proximate cause for no improvement. Could just a strange coincidence, so goes the phrase about correlation and causation anyway. If you have any evidence to the former, by all means include it. Did the student practitioner actually deviate from the standard set by the DPT?

5
ktappe•

That period of time coincides exactly with when I was being treated by the student

You were the one being treated; do you recall the treatment by the student to have differed significantly from that which you received from the professor? I'm not talking about results, but the treatment itself.

1
hamingoOP•

Yes, actually, I do recall that his treatment differed somewhat from the DPT. One (small, lasting maybe 5 minutes, but very important to my pain & mobility) component was omitted completely, and another was not as "aggressive" as the DPT's treatment. The student stated that he was afraid of hurting me, despite my verbally reassuring him otherwise each time he treated me.

1
ktappe•

Wow. Then I propose one solution is to ask the treatment facility to forgive those six weeks of treatment. Your insurance has a point; you received inadequate care. Use what you've told us to ask for those weeks of bills be nullified.

0
positivelycat•

Insurance processes claims as soon as they're received.

Hahaha sorry this made me chuckle. Some insurance sure others will drag their feet, poorly staffed or a claim gets lost or stuck who knows. But I habe plenty of claims that we wait months for insurance to process!

1
zebra-stampede•

Hahaha I was almost waiting for someone to mention that I definitely phrased it poorly. I more meant that the insurance wouldn't be intentionally not processing claims until the end for the purposes of screwing over the OP. They're too busy to play that kind of game 😅

2
[deleted]•

I feel like United would be setting a precedent that would lead into "student-directed care is not medically necessary" if they chose to deny based on the level of education of the medical professional.

1
zebra-stampede•

Yeah I definitely don't think there's much merit to that train of thought. Especially with something like PT where you're usually all working in the same room, so much more actually under supervision of the DPT (as compared to someone like a therapist intern where the overseeing provider isn't actually in the room).

1
Minnesotamad12•

I’m not sure the student is something to necessarily mention in the appeal. It’s not really relevant to medical necessity for the effectiveness. they would note if the issue was related to the student rendering care (assuming they didn’t). With the provider supervising the care it’s essentially effective as them doing it themselves, they would intervene if the student was doing something poorly. Getting input from the provider is the most essential step in getting the appeal approved. Get some kind of documentation from them, a detailed narrative on your progress and why the doc feels the therapy is necessary to regain function is best, to include in the appeal. The doctors statement on how common periods of plateau are throughout the process, which I feel is common knowledge in this field. Best of luck on it, physical therapy is stressful enough without the insurance refusing to pay.

2
hamingoOP•

Thanks for answering my questions and providing some helpful advice. It sounds like doing this second appeal and focusing on the post-plateau resumption of improvement is the best course of action. I'll ask my provider to write a new letter with more information on how common it is to plateau in between periods of steady improvement. I'm confident that she will be able to cite some scholarly sources to back up her plan.

I am actually quite enjoying my PT appointments! Well, the exercises aren't my favorite, but the manual stretching my provider does feels great. My insurance provider has been a colossal pain in the butt the whole time I have had them. They love to deny any and all claims, but this is the first time I've had to write the appeal letter myself.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thank you for your submission, u/hamingo.

View our Wiki here: Health Insurance 101

Please pick the most appropriate flair for your post. Include your age, zipcode, and income to help the community better serve you.

Reminder that solicitation/spamming is grounds for a permanent ban. Please report solicitation to the modteam and let us know if you receive solicitation via PM.

Be kind to one another!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1