r/darknetplan•
will7

I made a simple graph for people who don't understand how this all works yet

I made a simple graph for people who don't understand how this all works yet

Posted Nov 19, 2011, 11:05 PM UTC

10941
Batcaptain•

I've got no technical experience so correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't constantly sending information that isn't intended for you through your wireless network make Darknet slow as shit? I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person who thinks this; if someone could please explain it in layman's terms I'd appreciate it.

29
will7OP•

You are correct. Technology, however, constantly improves as time goes on. When the internet first came out, it was extremely slow and low tech as well. As time progressed, we gradually found more and more useful ways of communicating between computers. We will adapt new and more powerful ways if we continue developing with this form of networking, just as we do with any invention we work on. I wouldn't be surprised if eventually it became just as fast or faster than today's internet.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
solistus•

Right, but A_TREEIST's point is that this particular implementation is by no means a better design. It's extraordinarily inefficient compared to what it's trying to replace, and it relies entirely on physical resources controlled by its 'enemies'. If you want to get 'the majority of the internet' working on a single plan, it needs to be a good plan.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
[deleted]•

Blimps. Blimps in constant move over the atlantic filled to the brim with wifi enabled laptops.

6
auxiliary-character•

Our need for bandwidth increases with the amount of bandwidth we have.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
nocontrol74•

But to the point, even BGP wouldn't reduce the number of hops a packet would take between source and destination when nodes in the network are so close physically.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
will7OP•

Obviously the guy who made a simple graph for people who don't know doesn't know very well himself.

I stripped it of all the technicalities that may prevent someone from not understanding the basic concept. If you have a problem with the way the (Opennet?) is set up, you'll have to talk to the people working on it. I don't take any part in it, this is just how I interpreted a simple mesh network but you're free to make your own graph.

1
sirgrinalot•

full duplex wireless is still in the research stages, which means your wireless network could only transmit or receive and not at the same time until full duplex wireless becomes a standard. that design would be slow as shit when daisy-chained like that and being half duplex

1
sirgrinalot•

and i run this setup at home b/c we haven't ran the cabling yet and our house is large, with each additional link in the mesh away from the gateway the bandwidth is halved. so if bob was the starting point, george would have half bob's bandwidth, nancy would have half of georges bandwidth, and barbara would have half of nancy's bandwidth. barbara ends up with 1/8th of bob's bandwidth

1
gsan•

And simply put, here are the problems we need to solve for this to work.

What if there are two people named Barbara?

What if George is not available all the time to pass messages?

How does Bob know George is the shortest path to Barbara?

When someone else wants to help, how do we introduce them to the rest of the group?

How do we keep Mr. Hackett from messing with all of this?

Just trying to break it down a little further. Let's hear your ideas people, lots of research goes into this but sometimes a comment from someone uninitiated asking, ""Why don't you just do x like people do when they talk?" can be an a-ha! moment for some of those working on actual protocols.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

I believe gsan knows these answers, as they are trivial in plain english. He is merely trying to point out that the methods used to solve them can be enormously complex, and it is worth pointing that out. For example, "How does Bob know George is the shortest path to Barbara" is pretty much the crux of all networking problems.

4
gsan•

Dude, you have no idea how much I wish I knew the answers to these already! ;)

2
gsan•

Shapedy is right, these are rhetoric to stimulate conversation. By #4, I don't mean the "they" government, I mean any malicious user. We all want your solution to #3 but security and reality force us to have to address #4 above all. There is no longer a "central authority" remember. It becomes about trust networks, just like in personal communications.

Good answers. Let's hear answers like, "Bob remembers Bill is great at passing messages, and writes it down." Or "Ted knows Bob is flaky, but Bob knows a lot of people and talks really fast so try him first." It helps to think of the problem in those terms. It is a relatively easy problem when you have that central authority (i.e. "Everyone is brother and sister and they just ask mom and dad when they don't know"), but a fully distributed system poses some unique challenges to solve or we would just end up with the same thing all over again, only slower and harder to use.

Think of that day your mom and dad dropped you off at school for the first day. That is what your router feels like. The room full of kids on their first day is a mesh network today. Somehow we all grow into a room full of adults that have relationships and trusts and talk to and know each other. Now do that without a teacher.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

As someone posted in a thread about I2P, using public keys as an addressing system prevents name collisions and interception.

1
kspacey•

you have more fundamental issues as well, the biggest one off the top of my head is handling unit queries in the limit of a large number of users (P2P has similar issues when you're querying from amongst too large a sample)

an operation like this is O( n^2 ) and I'm sure there are other ones like this - unless more effective algorithms are invented to tackle these issues the darknet strategy will not be capable of replacing the current internet.

1
druek•

Wasn't this kind of how the Internet worked in the reallllly early days?

5
[deleted]•
3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
seclifered•

From this very vague and general diagram, it seems like DarkNet is just a massive MANET. In general there are ton of connectivity, throughput, and other issues if you want to do MANETs on the scale of the internet.

2
woxy_lutz•

So does that mean websites have to be hosted on our own hard drives? Or does everyone have to buy a small server to make this work on any moderate scale?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gsan•

Ideally you would have an access point with a few antenna and yes, you would host all your own content. It's all yours. You could do it from your laptop. In a large peer-to-peer system you would probably have to keep some info about the network locally (maybe up to a gig or so), though everyone would have to do this. This would not exclude any hosting sites like we have today, those could still exist under this model. So Aunt Jane can still have her quilting website hosted someplace that takes care of everything so she can just focus on quilts, only minus the fear of her credit card company cancelling her contract because someone claimed a tile on her quilt was infringing on their copyright.

1
tortus•

Keep in mind this is not intended to be a full fledged replacement for the internet. It's intended for essential communication should the government become too oppressive. You wouldn't use DarkNet to surf r/lolcats, you'd use it to spread photos and accounts of police brutality at protests, for example.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HarryCrumb•

It's an interesting idea but what is the range of wireless? Wouldn't you basically be limited to your own city in many places due to the population density? Once your traffic reaches a rural area it would struggle to find a path I would have thought.

1
gsan•

This could never be fully blown wireless, though that is the ideal (the earth just isn't like that). There will be land lines in this, someone's microwave dish, a hobbyists can-tenna. The strength is in the mesh, so even if any of those go down there are 500 other ways to get somewhere.

I think once this gains more popularity you will be able to get a mesh router or these antenna more easily and it will be closer and closer to plug and play. Think about how the phone company sends people little pico cells for extending their 3G. Box comes in the mail, plug it in, make phone calls. I'm talking years though.

Bonus about this is it can sit on top of the internet while it is being fleshed out and expanded. For example you can get a good mesh going in your city but you are still using the internet to get to the mesh of the next city. Once someone puts a dish on their house and joins the two mesh networks directly, drop the line (or keep it as backup) and the mesh has grown.

5
noPENGSinALASKA•

Hell I don't even live in a rural area but I doubt my wifi can reach my neighbor.

1
LennyPalmer•

One thing I don't understand: This is to bypass the influence of government and corporations, right? I get my internet from a corporation; all of it. I really don't know anything about how the technology I use works, but isn't the internet I pay for from my service provider essential in this kind of communication, and if so, and if we are to bypass corporate or government influence, where would these "internets" come from?

Forgive me if this is a painfully stupid question (as I suspect it might be).

1
Calvin_the_Bold•

You wouldn't be connecting to the "Internet" you'd be connecting to this "Darknet" that we're trying to create. It's basically another separate network that is created using wifi meshes. (A bunch of wifi access points all sharing info with each other)

2
justthrowmeout•

Daisy chain all the wifi routers!

1
TapDatApp•

This makes it sound pretty awful however. The Outernet should be something we can all connect to freely. Otherwise, there'd be no point. Who would want to take three steps backwards in technological development? Not I.

1
throwawayyyyyy8•

This sounds very much like the infrastructure of TOR, which has a weakness of the possibility of individual nodes monitoring/tampering with private traffic. So what prevents George or Nancy from reading Bob's message?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MMOAddict•

I don't know a lot about this topic, so forgive my ignorance, but wouldn't this just be the exact same thing that we have now, only wireless? I was under the impression all ISPs/hubs/etc are all business/privately owned as it is. There would still have to be a standard (and central "corporation", like ICANN) for addresses and name resolution, so there would still have to be some sort of control like there is now, wouldn't there?

1
[deleted]•

So a little like distributed dns then?

1
Blaah_Blaah•

Looks to me like none of them are in range of each other, what a useless network.

1
dave_L•

...Looks similar to g+ or facebook.

1
brokenrevolver•

George appears to be leaching.

1
MMOAddict•

So... proxy?

0
lordbunson•

Somewhat similar yet different in it's own ways. A proxy is when you have one device send data to an address where the data is forwarded to another address, then sent back through the system. For example your computer wants to access a website through a proxy so it sends information to a proxy server which then sends information to the website which then sends it back to the proxy which then sends it back to the computer. However, all of the communications between devices takes place through the internet's current infrastructure.

The concept behind the DarkNet is that data wouldn't be sent through land lines and other infrastructures currently in place but instead be sent wirelessly through a mesh of routers and other wireless devices who's signals overlap each other. So for example if I wanted to access a website from my computer through the DarkNet I would send data wirelessly from my router to another DarkNet router which would send it to another DarkNet router until the data eventually found its way to the server which hosted the website I wanted to visit, the website would then proceed to send data back throughout DarkNet routers who's signals overlapped until it found my computer again.

Edit: To clarify the benefit of the DarkNet is that the wireless signal cannot be cut off or firewalled because if someone tries to it will just find another route to the target destination. However with the traditional internet infastructure (which proxies are a part of) parts of the internet can be firewalled and censored.

2
[deleted]•

That would be reeaaaly slow for non-super-local-connections.

1
lordbunson•

Yeah... I'd think even dial-up would have better latency - but I'm no network expert.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1