r/dndnext•
Freeform_

Is it fine to play a necromancer?

Question

My GM is making a grimdark game, and a friend of ours, a self-aware munchkin, said he wants to make an animated dead necromancer build. The next day he actually approached me and asked if it's fine to play a character like that because I have more experience in DnD than him, but I haven't actually had a necromancer in the party before, so I wasn't able to help.

From what I'm seeing it's very questionable. There's only three ways I can see this play out:

  1. He floods the board with his troupe of skeleton archers, breaking the action economy,
  2. Every fight is balanced directly for his character, so that the number of enemies accounts of the player team having all these skellys in them,
  3. Every major fight starts with a fireball aimed at his little harem, making him just a dude with no good spell slots ever available.

How do you balance that? Is it a dick move towards the GM or other players? We really aren't sure, and our GM tends to let everything slide, even if he suffers for it later, so I'd like to see someone comment on the issue first.

Posted Apr 2, 2021, 10:15 AM UTC

2648
LordeBlep•

Your friend having a few skeletons on his side won't significantly change encounter balance. They're a use for spell slots just like any other. I would assume they asked you for moral advise, since some players aren't comfortable with desecrating the dead? Clarify with them.

It's a situational ability. Sometimes they'll all get fireballed, sometimes they'll be effective troops. That's the nature of virtually every ability in this game. Use the mass combat rules and time shouldn't be much of a problem either.

The rule of the action economy is "the side with more turns wins unless there is a significant power gap." CR 1/4 enemies as compared to lvl 5+ players is a significant gap. These sorts of sayings are mere rules of thumb, it helps to think through them case by case.

40
Freeform_OP•

The problem with mass combat rules is that they inevitably stop working in the middle of the encounter, unless I don't understand them.

If by the DMG standards the player needs 5 minions for one of them to hit, what do you do once one minion dies?

Option 1 is to extend the rules directly and say that in this case, they literally cannot land a hit, making them useless. At that point, you're severely lowering the amount of hit points the skeletons have.

To fix that you could treat them like a swarm, saying that their actual hp is the total hp of all the skeletons in that group, and they all die at once when it hits zero. That's extremely awkward from the storytelling perspective, and it impacts the mechanics of keeping them alive, unless you recalculate the size of the swarm after each encounter or something? It also screws with healing, buffs, and debuffs.

Or you can just stop using the mass combat rules when the party doesn't qualify, and then you're back to rolling buckets of dice every turn.

2†
OnslaughtSix•

If by the DMG standards the player needs 5 minions for one of them to hit, what do you do once one minion dies?

You...treat them as 4 individuals?

20
Freeform_OP•

And that's why mob battle rules aren't useful, they stop wroking after two or three turns.

1†
TheBoundFenrir•

But by the time you're down to the last, in this example, 4 skeletons, they're not really slowing the game down that much. The necromancer makes 4 attack+damage rolls on the skellies' behalf at the end of their turn (if we say the skellies have their owner's init, to keep it simple) and then you move on.

In my experience most 5e fights only last 3-4 turns anyway, so if the mob battle rules save you rolling a dozen attack rolls at the start of the fight, then that's plenty useful.

Especially if your GM keeps morale in mind and allows monsters to try and flee once they realize they've lost the battle, so halfway through the fight there's a chance the remaining monsters will either flee or surrender because they don't want to face the unflinching undead hordes coming after them.

10
flyflystuff•

after two or three turns

Three to four rounds is about the average length of combat from what I've seen. Seems like a good enough option to me.

7
kelik1337•

You arent the dm. Thats not for you to worry about.

-20
LordeBlep•

If time is the constraint, use this tool: https://oganm.com/shiny/swarm/
It's the seriously the most convenient thing I've ever found.

2
Ambitious_Duck6044•

There's really nothing broken about the Necromancer build (or at least not in comparison to all other Wizard builds, especially when you reach the higher levels). What level are you starting at? It's only really at 6th Level when you can Animate Dead and they'll actually not collapse from their own weight. And then 14th when they can be sneaky and steal other undead.

I haven't played a Grimdark game before, but is it very much centred around undead and necrotic damage?

24
Freeform_OP•

We call it gorepunk. Basically it's going to be set in a nightmare plane, but our characters will be "normal" people from that world, making it this abstract adventure where pretty things are the ones out of place. This makes it so that if he wants to have an army of undead at his side at all times, he's not going to stand out.

We're starting at level 5, since this kind of universe will be inherently more dangerous than living in Faerun.

13
PastryFlapsArtificer•

Having DM'd for a Death cleric, I can tell you that it gets very tedious for all involved if they have a lot of minions. Moving all of them and rolling for all of their attacks makes their turn 2 or 3 times longer than the other players. They can also get in the way of other PC's movement.

If they limit the number of minions it will be far more manageable, and they will have slots free for things other than "I command my skellies/zombies and cast a cantrip". It also makes it less likely that the DM will get fed up and start throwing fireballs at them.

If everyone is fine with the undead army, there are ways to streamline it, such as treating them as a mob rather than individual creatures. Many people have come up with different methods, one being see on average how many attacks will hit the target AC then just rolling damage. There are also a few different mass roll calculators online.

http://maxwilson.github.io/RollWeb/Roll/index.html

https://slyflourish.com/mob_calculator.html

https://dice.clockworkmod.com/#

14
NizbeltheRhino•

As a general comment on summoning builds, I highly recommend checking out the new "summon ..." spells in Tasha's. They seem to really streamline some of the mechanical issues with summoning (including undead) while still providing meaningful choices to the caster.

11
_Wraith•

I was going to make a similar recommendation. On top of that, I prefer the idea of one stronger minion rather than a horde of weaker ones. Could just be my MMO experience coming through there though.

2
OgataiKhan•

The only answer here is "ask your DM". If they are fine with it, why not.

There's a Necromancer Wizard in my current party who usually has around 4-8 skeletons out and we still have a ton of fun. Later on he will straggle with resistance and immunity to nonmagical B/P/S, and even now the skeletons are very fragile so he has to be very careful keeping them alive. They've died to AoE multiple times.

I'll add a disclaimer though: all this is valid for VVTs which let you use macros for attacks. I wouldn't recommend minionmancy with physical dice.

9
TheCrystalRose•

Assuming the DM uses fairly standardized rolling tables, the party should eventually start getting more magic items than the PCs can reliably use at one time, at which point it's time to start outfitting the Skelly-friends! You just have to remember to recollect the magic items when the hoard starts dying, so you can reequip the new hoard.

2
flyflystuff•

Having a lot of undead requires spending your spell slots of level 3 and higher. Usually Animate Dead is not worth it because it will cost you in not being able to, say, throw Fireball. Unless that PC is very smart about how he uses them usually it would actually be weaker than going for more straightforward spells. At level 5 this will get you 8 skelebros at the cost of 2 Fireballs. Unless you are a party that has like, 1 encounter per long rest, they'll get chewed through, as they don't have a lot of AC or hp, while wizard will be out of powerful spells. So balance-wise it's honestly not an issue.

However, there is a bit of suffering involved in the fact that they would take up a noticeable amount of time to resolve. This can be lame for GM and for PCs.

6
GuidanceLivid•

Depending on your party size, any summoning based character can really turn into a drag. It takes so long just to *move* the creatures around. It can stretch combat encounters out by quite a lot, and its mostly just with moving and missing. It can dramatically increase the time between other players turns, which can really suck.

Our table had a summoner briefly, and it was a fine experiment but no thank you longer than a few sessions. Going forward, as a DM, I will probably be upfront in session 0 that summoning based PCs are a no-go.

6
Ether_Cartographer•

Im not sure about an animated dead build, but if he uses the summon undead spell from tashas it should he fine.

3
Mayby0•

I would say the most important thing is to be fast at doing your turns, have a lot of d20, roll all the attacks and the damage at the same time and don't think too much about your course of action.

2
TheBoundFenrir•

Mod rules or dicebots help with this.

There are online tools for handling dice macros, but if you know a little bit of programming, it only takes an evening to build a custom dicebot to roll a specific attack X number of times against Y AC and return the damage. (my group had a homebrew "repeat until you miss" weapon, so I built a bot to run it. Fun fact: "repeat until you miss" is OP AF, definitely put a cap on total attacks with it or pay the price of hubris)

1
PrimeInsanityWizard school dropout•

Yup and do archers if you can so you don't clog up melee combat.

1
Decrit•

On a vaacuum, it's fine.

But if you play it in a setting full of monsters and undead the necromancer will be incredibly uneffective, unless very late into the levels, if you play for example the necromancy school.

This because unnatural spectral entities, aberrations and other undead effectively get into the way of proper undeadness. You get some features and spells to handle that but they are nothing compared to how much it can be uneffective - enemies immune or resistant to poison or necrotic, nonhumanoid bodies and so on.

I had a similar scenario in the past, it did not work out well. If your player wants to do so tell him/her to avoid being too much focused on that and rely on other concepts, like a transmutation wizard with a penchant for animate dead or a grave cleric.

2
crashfrog•

"Necromancer" can mean a lot of things and not always "army of the undead." I think you can make a pretty good necromancer as a warlock, for instance, as a Hexblade/Pact of the Tome warlock, especially now that there's an invocation for occasionally summoning the undead. Weird body transformations, sapping and debuffing enemies, taking advantage of their souls, that kind of thing. And, of course, beating the shit out of someone standing next to you with a flail (as the necromancers of old!)

In fact I think it works better than Wizard; since fireball is on the Wizard spell list, everybody expects you'll know and prepare it. So every wizard plays the same no matter what their specialization is. Not so with warlocks - it's expected you'll have weird utility, so when you lean into it as an eldritch master of the secrets and lore of death, nobody's like "...ok, but why not fireball?"

2
lollipop_king•

A random rules tidbit to keep in mind is that Animate Dead specifies Humanoid corpses/bone piles. Once a creature has been raised, it is an undead rather than a humanoid, and thus, once a body has been animated once and then killed it can't be animated again. Something important to keep in mind thats helped me out a lot, balance-wise, with Necromancers at my table.

2
Ishigami-the-KamiSorcerer•

Just use Tasha’s Summon Undead and you will be fine!

Only one, big and fucking strong summon! Can be respawned mid battle after the fireball! Will do more damage than your small army (not a joke).

Have more than a +4 to hit and won’t die after a single AOE.

2
Richybabes•

Summon undead won't match the damage of a bunch of skeletons at the same levels, takes concentration, and requires you to cast it in battle. This is especially true if you outfit your skeletons with heavy crossbows.

More chance to survive some AoE, but a horde of skeletons from a necromancer is the single largest source of damage in the entire game if allowed to do its thing. They'll also survive more single target damage, which is more common in my experience.

At 9th level you get danse macabre too, which is just as accurate and higher damage than even an 8th level summon undead.

All that said, it's not a case of one or the other. You can use both! That's the beauty of animate dead. You are a still a full blown wizard on top of your army (albeit down a couple spell slots).

-1
Bantregu•

Hi, Delicate topic as it is about enjoyment vs mechanics

It is something they can happen disregarding what edition you are playing (and 5e makes it easier than others)

I would recommend the rule of minion common sense:

  • agreement between DM and ALL players on how "long" summon turn can be. Is not fun to see the extra minute/minutes of the summoning player. DM can decide all summons use the result of a single roll per turn (dirty and actually consistent/similar to other rules in 5e where if you have multiple die to roll, you just roll one and multiply. As magic missile) = save time

  • skeleton archers? Fun and strange but also remember that low grade undead might only accomplish ONE SIMPLE task at the time. Ergo in a turn the necromancer doesn't have the time to instruct each one of them on how to hit different targets and can either give a generic order to all of them ("throw at the orcs") and prey or can give a specific order to one of them ("you go and grapple him") while tho others will continue to do what they were doing. Cmando g to move is a one and simple task. Ergo a group of undead isn't as good as it might seems.

  • I don't comment on other DM and, in general, you don't need to nuke the bone army, how many might they be? 8? 12? 16? They can't enter in any normal city/town without the party losing reputation, must be maintained, transported, are stupid as hell, you won't really have them that often in your fight and when they will be there the fight might just be unbalanced . Small army+PCs vs easy encounter, fine We have an army let's kick the crazy deadly situation, fine I love it Either case I personally weight the encounters to the situation and don't give xp if there is no challenge (yep, no challenge no xp)

Imho

2
Richybabes•

A small note, skeletons actually have 6 intelligence. That matches a lot of player characters that rolled for their stats, or Orcs before they removed the -2 int penalty

They're more akin to an Orc (pre-buff) than a zombie, intelligence wise. They can follow basic tactics, and even operate siege equipment.

Still, commands should be singular for sure. "Kill that guy", resulting in focus fire, rather than micromanaging each unit. I agree on that front.

1
jas61292•

Animate Dead, like all "minion" spells, breaks action economy. Things that let you summon 8 creatures are already totally busted and typically make combat unfun for everyone else, but Animate Dead takes things to the next level, because it is not concentration, and can let you stack up an absurd number of creatures.

Yes, it can be countered, but much of the time, you either end up AoEing the horde to death before it does much, fight something immune to nonmagical weapons so they do nothing, or the horde destroys the enemy with no effort.

Regardless of which one happens, either you have a player who spent a ton of resources to do absolutely nothing, or you have one player taking up 90% of the play time, and having fun at the expense of other players and the DM. And in either case it often narratively ends up being a massive letdown.

Undead hordes are a classic trope, but like most classic magic user tropes, it is best left to the villains.

2
MacaroniBobaFett•

It's not broken but it'll sort of suck for everyone at the table when you all, DM included, have to wait for 1 person to miss 6 attacks with shitty skeletons.

2
kuroninjaofshadows•

I think what people don't consider is it is very player dependent. Consider these things.

Are they fast at math? All but one of my 5e players would do just fine with the build, but I have had one player that I wouldn't trust to roll these attacks within a ten minute time frame. A normal - fast player, you'll never notice an issue.

Are they going to be a good fit for the group rp wise? Maybe it'd be too evil a build?

Last point, summoners aren't unbalanced in 5e. Fireball and other damaging spells do tons more than the level appropriate summoning spells. If anything, I find summoning weak unless the player finds some niche summon that greatly outshines the rest for its cr. And I would only tentatively call it good and slightly above average.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
robot_wranglerKobold Scout-Ranger•

Ask your player to get enough d20's and damage dice to roll them together. You don't want to sit through four separate attack and maybe damage rolls. Color-matching the d20's to the d6's is also good, if you want to roll them together.

Compared to the approximately 20 d6's of damage from a fireball on 3 targets, it will take a while for the skeletons to catch up, with only a +4 hit bonus. It could be ~10 rounds for 4 skeletons to land 20 hits on AC 14. That's about 3 entire combats.

Sometimes they will get hit with a fireball or something, but only when everyone else is getting hit too.

1
GmanF88•

Animate dead can control 4 creatures per slot. I don't think those 4 would be a problem. If your friend started using multiple slots just for an army of minions, yes, that can be obnoxious.

If you are very concerned about action economy/slowing the flow of play down you could always ask your DM to homebrew it a little and control 1 stronger creature, like ghoul or something completely unique.

1