Is it fine to play a necromancer?
My GM is making a grimdark game, and a friend of ours, a self-aware munchkin, said he wants to make an animated dead necromancer build. The next day he actually approached me and asked if it's fine to play a character like that because I have more experience in DnD than him, but I haven't actually had a necromancer in the party before, so I wasn't able to help.
From what I'm seeing it's very questionable. There's only three ways I can see this play out:
- He floods the board with his troupe of skeleton archers, breaking the action economy,
- Every fight is balanced directly for his character, so that the number of enemies accounts of the player team having all these skellys in them,
- Every major fight starts with a fireball aimed at his little harem, making him just a dude with no good spell slots ever available.
How do you balance that? Is it a dick move towards the GM or other players? We really aren't sure, and our GM tends to let everything slide, even if he suffers for it later, so I'd like to see someone comment on the issue first.
Posted Apr 2, 2021, 10:15 AM UTC
Your friend having a few skeletons on his side won't significantly change encounter balance. They're a use for spell slots just like any other. I would assume they asked you for moral advise, since some players aren't comfortable with desecrating the dead? Clarify with them.
It's a situational ability. Sometimes they'll all get fireballed, sometimes they'll be effective troops. That's the nature of virtually every ability in this game. Use the mass combat rules and time shouldn't be much of a problem either.
The rule of the action economy is "the side with more turns wins unless there is a significant power gap." CR 1/4 enemies as compared to lvl 5+ players is a significant gap. These sorts of sayings are mere rules of thumb, it helps to think through them case by case.
The problem with mass combat rules is that they inevitably stop working in the middle of the encounter, unless I don't understand them.
If by the DMG standards the player needs 5 minions for one of them to hit, what do you do once one minion dies?
Option 1 is to extend the rules directly and say that in this case, they literally cannot land a hit, making them useless. At that point, you're severely lowering the amount of hit points the skeletons have.
To fix that you could treat them like a swarm, saying that their actual hp is the total hp of all the skeletons in that group, and they all die at once when it hits zero. That's extremely awkward from the storytelling perspective, and it impacts the mechanics of keeping them alive, unless you recalculate the size of the swarm after each encounter or something? It also screws with healing, buffs, and debuffs.
Or you can just stop using the mass combat rules when the party doesn't qualify, and then you're back to rolling buckets of dice every turn.
You...treat them as 4 individuals?
And that's why mob battle rules aren't useful, they stop wroking after two or three turns.
But by the time you're down to the last, in this example, 4 skeletons, they're not really slowing the game down that much. The necromancer makes 4 attack+damage rolls on the skellies' behalf at the end of their turn (if we say the skellies have their owner's init, to keep it simple) and then you move on.
In my experience most 5e fights only last 3-4 turns anyway, so if the mob battle rules save you rolling a dozen attack rolls at the start of the fight, then that's plenty useful.
Especially if your GM keeps morale in mind and allows monsters to try and flee once they realize they've lost the battle, so halfway through the fight there's a chance the remaining monsters will either flee or surrender because they don't want to face the unflinching undead hordes coming after them.
Three to four rounds is about the average length of combat from what I've seen. Seems like a good enough option to me.
You arent the dm. Thats not for you to worry about.
If time is the constraint, use this tool: https://oganm.com/shiny/swarm/
It's the seriously the most convenient thing I've ever found.