Ashwagandha and testosterone

Discussion

So I’m trying to get into nootropics, as an extension of some longevity supplementation I’ve been looking into.

Ashwagandha seems pretty great, and it clearly has a lot of fans on this subreddit. However, it appears to increase testosterone levels, at least in men.

Given the significant risks of testosterone (some cancers, cardiovascular disease, immune suppression, etc.) and the lack of any real effects from replacing it in people with alleged “low T,” I was wondering:

Has anyone seen any studies on whether prolonged ashwagandha use has negative health consequences because of the way it boosts testosterone?

I tried looking for it but couldn’t find anything. Any help appreciated!

Posted Apr 6, 2021, 1:52 AM UTC

611
Ninjalikestoast•

I don’t know. But I would highly doubt you have anything to worry about. This won’t raise your testosterone in any significant way that you would even notice. If it did, dudes would be eating it like candy.

11
subuculaOP•

Haha, good point!

1
Ninjalikestoast•

Besides, if anything worked THAT well.. it would be a prescription drug most likely.

5
Effing_Tired•

My understanding is that it reduces cortisol flooding and stress which allows you body to focus on other things like making testosterone. If you have low testosterone you might see some results (I have), but it will be more about getting to normal levels.

9
kuntaocrab•

If I were you I'd look into the benefits of higher testosterone though. I suppose it depends on what you're looking for, but in general elevating testosterone DOES have significant benefits. Reduced body fat and increased lean body mass, increased sex drive, and on the more nootropic side of things, better mood modulation (less depressive thoughts, irritability), better mental clarity and focus.

In general, higher testosterone correlates with higher drive, and this can be VERY beneficial in a nootropic context. Obviously, it also has its negatives. But from personal experience, getting my testosterone levels in check (as a man, your mileage may vary) has been one of the single most impactful changes in terms of my cognitive function.

But yeah, the impacts Ashwagandha has on testosterone is indirect. It helps reduce and control cortisol, and (depending on the study) elevated cortisol levels tends to lead to reduced circulating testosterone. It shouldn't lead to supraphysiologic levels of testosterone, just help control an inhibiting factor. But again, I HIGHLY recommend getting your testosterone levels in check.

8
subuculaOP•

Yeah, looking further into it, the cardiovascular risks are uncertain, and I'm hoping I won't get prostate cancer anyway so who cares :D .

Thanks for your reply - I'll do that!

2
whatevergotlaid•

But how do you increase testosterone in a significant way without a prescription?

1
kuntaocrab•

Weight training, proper nutrition (vitamin D, zinc, magnesium, boron are big ones), certain supplements (D-aspartic acid, tongkat ali, shilajit, aromatase inhibitors [nicotine is quite potent, cordyceps and lion's mane]). Lowering your general stress level should help to reduce cortisol as well, which should help keep testosterone levels in check.

It won't be as simple (or arguably cheap, if you go the supplement route) as injecting test, but in my opinion the majority of men can get their levels to average-high average reference range with lifestyle/diet changes alone. As a bonus, in the process you'll build good habits that will positively affect your life in other ways.

3
ArtificialBrain808•

I’d be more worried about liver damage than anything. KSM seems to be pretty safe but at least a few people have had confirmed liver issues from NOW brand ashwagandha: https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.reddit.com/r/Nootropics/comments/ic1dir/now_supplements_ashwagandha_a_cautionary_tale/

I appreciate this post though as I am also in the minority regarding concerns with cancer and testosterone supps(noots in general I suppose). People say nah no way nothing to worry about but how would they know? If you’re predisposed to prostate cancer, taking tongkat or ash is probably the last thing you want to do. I’m not saying that is the case for you or me, just saying it could be and most Redditors would still act like you’re the crazy one for expressing concerns. People sometimes seem personally offended when you bring up negative side effects.

I’ve ran 2 cycles of tongkat/tribulus with great results but as I grow older my goals are gravitating away from quick gainz to longevity. Granted that if my t levels weren’t decent to begin with I may feel differently, but until the drop in test is super apparent(I’m 29) I’m going to tell myself a quick boost isn’t worth the possible long term risks.

3
subuculaOP•

Couldn’t agree more!

2
KyriakosGrizz•
1