Books do not have content ratings like movies, tv shows, and video games. Would introducing a content system be good or bad for books?

Posted Apr 6, 2021, 11:11 PM UTC

228
Moho_braccatus•

Bad. It would make schools' access to books harder too.

3
menace-to-sobriety•

Yah i agree. Everything would be banned

2
acdigitalOP•

I'll admit this is my largest concern with proposing such a system.

I would hate for this to be the outcome, but at the same time it would be great to know what's in a book for both my personal reading interests as well as to understand more quickly understand what types of content my kids are reading (not to limit them, more to better understand them).

1
SerMercutio•

Bad.

Because fucking stupid assholes, idiots, cunts and morons will give bad ratings for things they don't understand due to their low IQ.

3
acdigitalOP•

I hear you and this is one of my concerns about abuse of a standard system. I do not advocate for any kind of censorship. However, the content rating system for movies allows for R rated movies. If people want adult content then they're guaranteed to see it in an R rated movie and so on down the chain.

Why would this hurt books if it doesn't hurt video media?

1
jekewa•

I would hate to see a judgement system, like "Rated R," based on someone's interpretation of the content.

Television's more contains warnings, like "adult language," seems plausible.

Mostly, though, books have ok age appropriateness kind of built into where they're sold or displayed. The genres are pretty revealing. The authors get known for their genres and style.

Stephen King tends to write easy-to-read horror tales with death and mayhem, but not a lot of strong language, and not often terribly descriptive gore; I could see "horror" being enough, but "death" or "paranormal" would help describe it better.

3
acdigitalOP•

All good comments. I agree that publishers and book store do have a certain order to their categorization of books.

However, once a book lands in one of the genre sections as "Mystery" or "Fiction" there really not much aside from reading the jacket or online research to know if one of these books are more or less grotesque (e.g. your excellent King example, which I agree totally with).

1
Scepter1987•

Stop trying to censor everything.

2
acdigitalOP•

My question isn't about censorship. It's about labeling the content so you know what you're getting.

People censor books without such a system, which I absolutely disagree with.

1
Scepter1987•

Why does one "Have" to always know what they are getting into. Doesn't that defeat the purpose of an adventure? Whats the point of going on a journey through a book or anything for that matter if you already know what your getting into...?

1
acdigitalOP•

I don't literally mean the system would give away anything about the story anymore than an R rating does for a movie.

2
belzbieta•

Might not be too bad an idea, as much as I don't like the idea of possibly restricting books in any way.. my mom gave me free reign of the library as a kid and I went through so many books so fast I started into the adult section when I was 9 and I probably didn't need to be reading Stephen king in 4th grade, because as cool as I thought I was reading adult books, I had nightmares from it. And that one scene in IT was definitely a bit mature for me.

Even some kids books could use warnings. Flowers in the attic can maybe just be labeled "NO" lol. Seriously though, I read that in third grade and was aware I had just read something weird and maybe bad but didn't really know how to ask my parents about it.

2
acdigitalOP•

You sound like me in that I read all kinds of adult stuff well before it was "appropriate". However, this was a privilege due to being mature enough to handle the content. I remember walking away from a couple of horror books because they were just too scary for me at the time, but never did an adult limit what I wanted to read.

I'm certainly not advocating for censorship here. Rather, a rating system would provide a standard way for me, both as a reader and as a parent, to more quickly understand what's in a given book.

1
belzbieta•

I agree with others that a rating system may misused and lead to banning certain categories of books, but maybe something like on imdb, I don't remember what it's called, but parents can submit comments for parts that may need additional explanation and discussion or that might be inappropriate under a certain age.

It's excessive to ask for parents to pre read every book their kids read for sure, so something like that might be helpful.

I think a blanket category like Stephen King's It being labeled mature/horror or nc17 or something like that wouldn't be as helpful as somebody saying hey there's a weird child sex scene in chapter such and such

2
acdigitalOP•

I'm I guess too much an optimist in this regard, given that I'm sure a system built for books would be more misused than beneficial.

I'd never want this type of system to prevent books in a school beyond what is already filtered. That being said, there probably aren't any horror novels on the elementary school library.

These systems of labeling content are probably already in place even if there doesn't seem to be any official standard maturity rating tagged on each book.

1
[deleted]•

I’d say by 8-10 years old, kids should be old enough to know not to copy what they see in entertainment in real life, and they should be able to have free reign over what they read.

1
acdigitalOP•

My question wasn't attempting to suggest we should control or limit content in any way. Rather, I'd like to know what content is in a given book both for my own use as well as to better understand what level of maturity my kids want to read.

I myself was reading Stephen King books before I was even a teen, played Mortal Kombat and watched rated R movies all the time. My mom really didn't care so long as I didn't confuse fiction with reality and so I read whatever I wanted. I plan on doing the same for my own kids, who may mature and respond differently than I did as a kid.

1

Even if such a system were to exist, many people would ignore it.

1
acdigitalOP•

I contend that parents would not and I personally would find it very valuable to know generally what kind of content was in books I'm looking at when shopping for myself.

1
[deleted]•

No it would be pointless. The main point of the content system is movies/tv/video games is to protect kids from objectionable content.

With books, I’d say the parents should be able to judge whether or not the content is appropriate. If you don’t want your kids to read certain books, tell them no like a grown up.

0
acdigitalOP•

I'm confused. You seem to think the content rating systems are good for other media, but pointless for books.

Do parents have to watch all G rated movies to make sure the movie doesn't contain any sex scenes? No, of course not...

How in the world would a parent have enough time to read every single book before they let their kids read them? Are you a parent and, if so, do you do this?

Without the content rating system for video parents would have to watch every movie and tv show first too. Currently there's no standard way of doing this for books, with the best being websites that do this using lots of different methods that are definitely not consistent.

It's not a matter of parenting that I'm talking about here, but a tool that parents and others could use to better consider the material on books just like we do with other media.

1
William84000•

pretty sure they do...

0
acdigitalOP•

Can you please provide a reference to point out a standard the applies to all books that are printed in the US?

1
William84000•

What what what??? Not sure what you mean... I'm not in the US, but I did write a book and when I published it online there had to be a content rating on it. I know the lines are very blurry when it comes to ratings on books. Most of the time it only comes in the form of the author stating to what age group the book will appeal more. There is no strict rating system though as with movies or games

2
acdigitalOP•

The blurry line you mentioned is because there isn't a standard like the US movie content ratings (G, PG, R, etc.). I don't know of any standard for classifying books that tells a reader if they can expect similar levels of maturity in the book like we have for movies.

Edit: Are you taking about how they classify books as "Children's", "Young Adult", "Horror", "Mystery", etc?

1
William84000•

True... In France it is a bit stricter though, but still blurry

2