r/thesims•
Maykeys

Played the Sims 4 for 24 Hours, After Playing the Sims 3 for 10 Years. Here Are My Thoughts.

Discussion

Hello everyone!

I just wanted to share my experience with The Sims 4, as I started recently just purchased it. The reason I put off buying it so long was because I was extremely dissatisfied with The Sims 4 upon release, and was not willing to spend the retail price on the product as I felt it simply wasn't worth it. I've played The Sims 3 for most of my life, 10 years to be exact, and the removal of Create-a-Style and the open worlds was something I didn't want to give up. However, due to Covid boredom, I ended up trying it... many years late.

So I'll start with the positives! One thing I love about The Sims 4 are the sims themselves. I think they're a HUGE upgrade, not just because they no longer look like creepy mannequins, but they're actually intelligent (i.e. Flirty sims no longer flirt with literally every other sim they come across). Their faces are well animated, although cartoony and stylized, but they look and behave much better. They still fail to take care of toddlers without my intervention though. Another thing I loved is how well the game runs. I can actually run it perfectly well on my laptop, with the only glitches being my sims randomly entering an A-pose, or getting stuck on fast speed.

So now for the negatives... which is pretty much everything else. Removing Create-a-Style was a bad choice, removal of open worlds was a huge downgrade. But what sucks the most about the neighborhoods is that nobody else progresses. Your neighbors will remain static aside from aging, never changing careers, entering relationships, having children, etc... it's really depressing. Everything is up to your imagination regarding the world, because they're are no rabbit holes. Why are there like only 8 hair colors, but 30+ or so skin tones? Why can't I add highlights? Why can't I personalize my clothes? Why can't I personalize my house?? WHY CAN'T I _____???? Obviously the release was rushed because toddlers, pools, and basements weren't in the game from the start if I remember.

I will likely go back to The Sims 3, but I may go back to The Sims 4 every now and then to mess around with Create-a-Sim. All in all, Sims 4 felt like a huge downgrade, and I'm glad I didn't buy the game at full price. The content packs are the same... they improved one feature they hyper-focused on, then took out a ton of other stuff (i.e. can't control the pets). I bought Seasons because it was the only one I heard good things about, and I'm glad I bought it at a discounted price, because although it adds nice things, like the well-designed holidays, but its not worth $40. If they make a Sims 5, hopefully they take the Sims from Sims 4, and combine them with everything else from Sims 3. That would be a perfect, well-designed game imo.

Thank you for reading! Just a reminder this is entirely my opinion, and I just wanted to share my thoughts. If there's a feature you love about Sims 4, such as something from the content packs, please tell me! I want to improve the game as much as I can.

Posted Apr 8, 2021, 5:21 PM UTC

368
Armando_Jones•

Yeah.

I was in the same boat as you and just picked up the sims 4 a few weeks ago, got it with all of the expansion packs even and I put in about 30-40 hours.

I even defended it early on...and now its impossible to look past the flaws.

It just feels hollow.

- Being stuck at home really sucks. I can never leave with a sim otherwise the other sims that live there are basically throwing away hours of their lives doing absolutely nothing productive during the time I'm gone

- The mood system is incredibly annoying. Do a bunch of prep to get my sim in a focused mood so he can practice his research and debate skills in front of the mirror...and now he's feeling confident from doing that action, which overrides the focused mood, and thus now earns skill slower. What the fuck?

-All my sims feel the same. The only personality anybody has is whatever I have in my head, beyond that they are all identical. Sure they look different thanks to the vastly improved CAS, but thats it.

-You run into the same sims regardless of what neighborhood you visit. I miss going to Sims-France and seeing all new NPCs and actually feeling like I was in a different place, instead of just seeing my same neighbors everyone I turn.

-The limited amount of lots in each neighborhood. Also theres way less I can do to make a neighborhood feel like *mine*

24
Nitro_Indigo•

Being stuck at home really sucks. I can never leave with a sim otherwise the other sims that live there are basically throwing away hours of their lives doing absolutely nothing productive during the time I'm gone

I knew something about the gameplay was dull, but I couldn't put it into words. Thanks!

9
MaykeysOP•

I don't like that sims from other Neighborhoods show up in others. In an attempt to make the neighborhood feel larger, it makes the entire game feel smaller by making each neighborhood essentially a retextured clone. It doesn't matter where you are, Bella Goth will find you lol.

8
Grimauldbird•

For me personally I don’t mind not have the mahooosive create a style. I would like more swatches for clothes or just a colour wheel. Sometimes in TS3 it was a bit much.

One of my biggest bug is the hair. I don’t have any mods or cc (yet) but the swatches are terrible. And some of them hairstyle, yeesh.

I don’t miss the open world terribly, I like being able to go from town to town and not loosing the family connection like in TS3.

Your neighbors will remain static aside from aging, never changing careers, entering relationships, having children, etc... it's really depressing.

To be fair that was the same in the pervious games if you didn’t have mods. But it would have been nice had they thought of it. But ts4 was a rush job.

What I miss the most. The lore. In the words of the great plumbella “I’m a whore for lore.” And I won’t ever forgive them for what they did to the Caliente sister. Seriously, WHO THE F**K is Katrina?

12
BlondieRants•

I agree with create a style. I recently started playing Sims 3 (I’ve had it for years but when I played it years ago, it would crash constantly and was unplayable for me) and I find create a style to be laggy and a lot of the textures are so ugly. Color wheel is nice but also laggy.

This will never happen but my ideal compromise would be a create a style light where you had separate swatches for different parts of an item. Imagine a wood framed couch with colorful cushions. You could choose a swatch for the frame and another swatch for the cushions. And I would want consistent swatches between all items, so for instance a black, white, light wood, medium wood, and dark wood swatch for everything.

7
IsthatRuby•

Regarding swatches, they did something like that back in Sims 2 and I though it was awesome. You can have the same beds in a room (say two for 2 siblings)and have matching frames but different colour linen on the bed. I miss that cohesion instead of having the same shape bed but either in identical or completely different colours

4
marinamarten•

In TS3 I played with the family of 2 sons of my original sim, who lived just couple of houses away so I'd see her here and there and whenever they had a family gathering. At some random point I noticed she married the father of her sons, he moved in and took her surname. I was very confused but my game did it for whatever reason. Story progression mod crashed my game so I didn't have it.

The other point is when a teenage daughter of one of the guys came home from school and had a crush on her classmate, who she barely knew. I was like.. okaaaaay. They had nothing in common and her crush found her pretty boring but would still happily flirt with her. And while yes, it happened in my active household I've never seen that happening in TS4.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
danishjuggler21•

After ten years of playing the Sims 3, it’s almost done loading.

4