From a workers perspective, what is the argument against unionization?

Watching the employees at an Amazon facility in Alabama vote on whether they want to unionize, and watching the "no" votes take the lead, I realized I didn't understand the issue very well. I always assumed unionization was pretty much always better for employees, and worse for management/ownership - as it's primary purpose is collective bargaining (which puts employees/workers in a much stronger negotiating position). Why would the employees vote against unionization? Can someone help me understand the pros/cons of unionization from a workers perspective, and why these workers in Alabama would not want it?

Posted Apr 9, 2021, 2:50 PM UTC

318
-GreenSun-Likes science, hates fennel•

"Management told me if we unionize they'll just close the factory and we'll all be out of our jobs."

And various flavors of the above.

15
BoopingBurrito•

Unionization is always better for workers, however management will, in countries that don't have sensible and basic legal protections in place, punish workplaces or workers that unionize.

6
ItchyThunder•

Unionization is always better for workers

This is very much debatable. As a counterpoint you can look at France, where unions are extremely powerful and all the large companies are bound by union rules. This results in a very restrictive environment for workers, inhibits job creation because it is so hard for the companies to fire anybody, leads to very high youth unemployment, etc. In other words, the results of this are not all positive. Especially in a very competitive environment most companies operate now.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
pr0n-thr0waway•

Employers say that they cannot afford unions so they will have to fire people if employees unionize, so workers are afraid of their job. This rarely (if ever) actually occurs.

Employers say that employees will have to pay dues which will result in employees making LESS money with unions. This rarely (if ever) actually occurs.

Employers "promise" to add more benefits if they vote to not unionize and employees believe them. This rarely (if ever) actually occurs.

6
ItchyThunder•

Employers say that they cannot afford unions so they will have to fire people if employees unionize, so workers are afraid of their job. This rarely (if ever) actually occurs.

In my view, this would definitely occur here, because Amazon can open or expand any other warehouse center that is not bound by the union restriction. There is no specific value in this part of Alabama. In other words, it's one thing when the unionization happens in a particular plant that has a unique competitive advantage. This is not the case here. If this was a multi-billion chip plant or another huge capital investment that is hard to move, that would be a different story. Probably the main reason they opened it there in the first place were lower wages and expenses in Alabama. If that advantage was to disappear, they would likely stop investing and expanding there, at the very least.

3
paradoxicallylost•

That sounds like a really good point. Is there any reason why they can't unionise all workers across the country to prevent this?

1
ItchyThunder•

This is pretty hard in the US. Frankly, you need the federal action probably of sorts to make it happen, because if it's only Amazon (while Walmart, BestBuy, Target, etc. are not unionized), they will be penalized with the higher costs and will not be able to compete effectively.

1
paradoxicallylost•

In Sweden each profession have their own union. It's all metal workers or all retail workers, no matter where they work. It's an old system though, and easy to take for granted.

I can see it would be a monumental task to get a union that big in the US, and a small union is more of a nuisance than a power.

2
rewardiflostNot infected yet!•

A lot of it is propaganda, but there are some grains of truth.

If we think of Amazon's total economy as a fixed "pot of money" - and we know that Jeff Bezos and the investors are going to take their part, no matter what; then the rest of the money is what gets divided up between the business and the workers. Bringing a union in means there is now a new expense - they get paid out of our share of the money. The union doesn't typically add any value, or create any new profits for the company. So now there are more hands taking from the same supply of money.

If wages go up, that will get passed on to the consumers. Those higher prices might not have any effect at all. That would be great. But, those higher prices might mean fewer people buying from Amazon, and going to other suppliers. That could translate to job cuts or other negatives for the employees.
If those job cuts become serious enough (I'm reaching now) - that could harm the local economy, and put shops out of business, lower property values, drive up taxes, or close schools and hospitals.

The company doesn't want a union. So they will be sure to keep telling the employees that they could be voting themselves out of a job.

6
GrumpyMOP•

If we think of Amazon's total economy as a fixed "pot of money" - and we know that Jeff Bezos and the investors are going to take their part, no matter what; then the rest of the money is what gets divided up between the business and the workers. Bringing a union in means there is now a new expense - they get paid out of our share of the money. The union doesn't typically add any value, or create any new profits for the company. So now there are more hands taking from the same supply of money.

This is a very interesting take I hadn't thought of. Thank you for laying it out.

4
CommitteeOfOne•

I grew up in Mississippi, right next door to Alabama. There's never been a strong union "culture" in the southern U.S., but there's always been a strong "respect the hierarchy" culture. You are supposed to "know your place." So workers tend to believe mmanagement more than they may in other areas when management tells them a union will cost the workers their jobs.

And as I explained elsewhere about the culture of impoverished southern workers, most are too grateful to simply have a job--even if they have to pee in bottles rather than take a bathroom break--that they literally can't picture the benefits that may come from unionizing.

3
JennyB82•

Some workers don’t like the verbal or financial support given (by the union) to a party or candidate they oppose, particularly when dues are used toward political donations.

2
frizzykidI'm an expert and a rapid editor sry•

There is definitely a lot of propaganda, but the general reasonable arguments I see, is that people don't like paying union dues (even if they are getting raises so they still end up making more), and they don't like the idea of basically being forced to take time off work to strike if there is an issue.

That being said, its almost always propaganda arguments, like "if we unionize, the big wigs are just going to close this location down and open up somewhere else" or they just use intimidation like "Dont even talk about the union or your job will likely be on the line"

2
ChickunTendies•

Unions are only as strong as the number of employees and workplaces they represent. The more people in the union the stronger they get. Most pro-union employees will vote no if they know they don't have the numbers to successfully pass the vote. If a vote fails and you voted yes they fear that they'll be pushed out of the company of the employer finds out who voted yes.

2
conw4ywest•

Came to ask this question.

1
MeCJay12•

Union dues lowering their take home pay and lost work from union actions (strikes) or company retaliation. Most of the time these issues are worth it for the return or don't occur.

1
petrichor_unicorn•

I've been part of a construction laborer's union. This is from my perspective and experience with a decent union:

Pros: -Great benefits (seriously tho... they were awesome) -40 hr work weeks -Union finds work for you -Can't get fired -Everyone makes the same rate no matter how long they've worked at a certain job/company; raises are all at the same increments. I started at $19/hr with zero work experience -paid training (not the case for every union)

Cons: -Union dues (mine were $40/mo, insurance was automatically taken from my paycheck) -Mandatory monthly meetings -Must be in for a certain amount of time before retirement benefits would stick (5 years for mine) -If you ever left and were out longer than you were in you had to start over as an apprentice when you rejoined -high school diploma required for hire -only union members can be hired (so if you are hired, you have to join) -Union finds work for you (you were only allowed to turn down 2 opportunitiesin a row; you had to take the 3rd one) -Can't get fired -Everyone makes the same rate no matter how long they've worked at a certain job/company; raises are all at the same increments

That's what I can think of off the top of my head. What bothered me the most was that they weren't transparent about dues and other costs. Imo, overall unions can be good or bad, just like any job can be. If your union is on top of paperwork and communication then things can go very smoothly. However, they can also go to crap, like bad apartment management makes everything bad. I got really lucky with my union, the jobs I did, and the people I worked with. They were awesome (thank goodness). I left because it wasn't the career I wanted and I was becoming complacent. I needed to get uncomfortable to get some changes going in my life. :)

Edited to add: they tried to get people to support their political agendas (con)

1