Pro vs. All Star difficulty

Anyone else struggling to move from Pro to All Star in NHL21? I'm in this awkward space where i win basically all games on Pro, with a very high goals for average - but on All Star i just can't seem to find my footing yet. I barely manage to score and lost all games on all star so far.

Are there any pointers? I feel my defence isn't too bad and i can keep up with the ai on that front, but my scoring is just non existent on all star.

I think I'm overall focusing too much on the good old wing pass to centre one timer... Which gets intercepted 95%of the time.

Any pointers for offence against all star AI? I'm very bad at deking and fancy shenanigans with the right stick, is that something i should practice more?

Thanks in advance!

Posted Apr 10, 2021, 7:50 PM UTC

511
hnglmkrnglbrry•

I play on Superstar because once you figure out All Star you just can't lose. I know you're asking for offensive advice, but you need a good defensive strategy to open up your offense.

First: never go for the hit on defense. This is how the AI kills you. You will get the hit 99% of the time but they will have a support attacker that picks up the puck and creates an odd man rush, or you being out of position opens a passing lane that they take advantage of. When they get control of the puck just wait for them at the red line and control the gap and attack with a poke check at the blue line, not a hit. That will stifle them a bit, but they'll probably maintain possession. Just focus on preventing that pass to the middle now by staying in the lane or...

Let the AI take the puck carrier. You park your ass on the forward that is clearly in the slot to get a juicy one timer. This is how they score 99% of the time on All Star unless you give up a breakaway or 2 on 0. Just stay between him and the puck and wait to intercept that pass or for your AI teammates to take the puck. Now onto offense.

Set all your offensive sliders to the 2nd highest position and your lines to crash the net. Feed the puck to your wingers on the breakout and have them try to beat the defenseman by going wide. Most times you can just beat them outright. With a crash the net and aggressive forecheck strategy you should have another forward driving hard. If possible hit em with a cross crease, or shoot low and center or farside for a rebound opportunity. If not, slam on the brakes at the hash marks on the boards and wait for your trailing forward for that one timer or to have him dish it back to you for a one timer or the other forward for a shot.

I also have all my defenseman and wingers play their weak side (righties on the left, lefties on the right) so that they are better set up for one timers that, if aimed low and with forwards are crowding the net, can be redirected more easily. Another tip is to set your faceoff stategy to aggressive so that these weak side defenseman are in a really good position to take a one timer, a wound up wrist shot aimed short side high, or (better yet) feed the winger for a one timer the second he drifts out wide. This last one works like 30% of the time you win the draw and have even a moderately skilled shooter at wing.

Also going behind the net and circling around and trying to feed it to the other forward parked backside works decent too.

As for dekes I almost never use them. I'm just not that good at them, and I'm able to win 10-2 consistently without them so I don't know how much they help.

Best of luck!

5
PriestLizardOP•

Awesome, thanks! Will try these out!

2
Hebroin•

There are a lot of posts about the steep difficulty curve between Pro and All-Star.

I myself play on Pro and I easily win every game by 7-8 goals. If I play All-Star, I managed to survive the first period, but get crushed in second and third, losing 4-5 to 1. I rarely win games.

Weirdly, I do better in superstar, where games are a lot closer in goals and shots, but still ridiculously hard.

I found the best balance to be to keep playing on Pro, but adjusting the gameplay sliders in the settings. You only need to adjust the AI portion where the CPU adjust to gameplay based on context and it changes everything. At Pro, that slider was at zero for me, bump it up to 6/6 and you get a real challenge where the CPU doesn't always steal you the puck doing nothing, or score 4 straight goals in 2 minutes.

2
PriestLizardOP•

Interesting. I was wondering if it's better to learn more while getting wrecked on all star, or try to stick with Pro, improve my play, and then move to all star later.

I will try to fiddle with some of the sliders you mentioned.

1
mrSeven3Two•

In the same boat.

1

The difficulty is a huge jump this year, honestly I find that I love all star and find it very fair. I’m like 9-14-2 so far in franchise it’s challenging but not over the top. Superstar feels horrible and broken lol. I think it takes a lot of practice, mess with strategies, players, practice lots of shooting! You’ll get it! My biggest issue are the Swiss cheese goalies

1
PriestLizardOP•

Can you give me a few pointers for the offence? The typical wing rush with pass to centre for 1timer certainly doesn't work on all star, so what's your typical go to strategy and scoring method?

I managed to get to a point where i can actually control the puck somewhat in the enemy zone, but there just never is an opening.

Also enemy goalies seem to be a clear level up in skill compared to Pro. Pretty sure i had a few chances that would have been goals on Pro...

2

I play on conservative offense, I tend to rush down the wing and score in the slot a lot. Sometimes I cut back and pass around, look for a one timer maybe from the point or top of a circle. I try to overwhelm the defense anytime I attack. Breakouts are definitely my main scoring points. Cross creases are ugly but effective, also, be sure to keep an eye on the goalie anytime you’re trying to score. Watch his movement, wait for him to leave a gap then strike

1
PriestLizardOP•

Yea being able to monitor the other players, goalies included, is really vital... But hard to do since all star AI puts a lot of pressure on you. Need to practice that more!

2

For sure, try to take it slow honestly at first, and it doesn’t hurt to go slow to time your passes and put pressure on the ai for good shots. All out attack doesn’t work in this game imo. Also when defending I highly suggest taking it slow as well, don’t get caught out of position, wait for them to come to you, go for precise poke checks and checks.

1
esky86•

It's been like that for most of the NHL games on this gen. I play on pro for that reason. I play on all star for nhl 14 and it's way easier.

1