Is gender dysphoria different from being transgender

Question

Ok, first let me say that I am not trying to insult or mock transgender people. I'm cool with people doing whatever they want to their body. So I am not trying to say transgender individuals are mentally ill.

My question is really does mental health consider anyone with gender dysphoria (https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/gender-dysphoria/what-is-gender-dysphoria) to be transgender, or are there people who are not transgender who could be considered to have legitimate mental illness due to feeling they are the wrong sex.

For example, maybe a person has a brain injury and begins to experience gender dysphoria due, but they never had any feelings of being the wrong sex in the past.

I am honestly just curious if there are people out there who feel like are in the wrong body, sexually, but do not consider themselves transgender and would not be considered transgender by the LGBT community. Can a person experience (intense) gender dysphoria but not be a transgender person?

I guess this is a matter of defining what it means to be transgender, which is probably beyond the scope of my question.

TLDR: Can gender dysphoria be considered a mental illness, separate from a person being transgender ?

Posted Apr 11, 2021, 1:29 AM UTC

13
stairphobe•

Gender dysphoria is a label assigned to people who are trans and want to transition, used to make it possible for trans people to have access to counseling service and medical transition. The DSM requires both that someone is uncomfortable with their sex traits and that they want to alter them to align with their identified gender. So it’s unlikely that someone who isn’t trans (doesn’t identify as the gender that they were not assigned at birth) would be diagnosed with gender dysphoria but I guess it’s possible.

GD isn’t the only DSM diagnosis that’s not exactly a mental illness- adjustment disorder is a DSM diagnosis that’s used when someone has an issue that they might need therapy for but it’s not accurate to say it’s an illness. Like I was diagnosed with adjustment disorder when I was 16 because I was kind of down after becoming a quadriplegic. It’s normal to be depressed after something like that, so it wasn’t that I was sick. I just got that label so I could get therapy to help me out. GD is more like that.

I’ve never heard of someone developing dysphoria after a TBI. Gender dysphoria isn’t caused by a specific difference in a specific part of the brain, so idk how a TBI would cause it. Anything is possible but it seems unlikely. I’m sure that there are people who are dysphoric but don’t identify as trans. Trans is a label used to describe a social identity and experience while gender dysphoria is a diagnosis, so it’s possible for someone to have dysphoria while rejecting the trans label. But for the most part they occur together.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thank you for for sharing. A reminder: if you are seeking resources in your local area, please provide that in the post so that users can share appropriate links and phone numbers. If you are in distress, please call 9-1-1 or your local emergency number. You are not alone. Help is available. If you are having suicidal thoughts, please click here for a list of crisis support services., If you are seeking therapy online, please click here for a list of counselling services. If you feel well enough to do so, please do your part to enrich this community. Now that you have posted, please leave a constructive, helpful comment on someone else's post. Filter by new to find posts with zero comments. Together, we make this community great. Thank you for being here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
BloodWolf2436•

The problem is, why else would you transition? It’s a lot of work, it takes years. Also, sometimes it takes decades for people to discover this within themselves. I can’t think of any logical reason to call yourself transgender or transition if not. So, yes, I think gender dysphoria comes with it. Dysphoria can be in different amounts though, sometimes it’s not clear what it is. Someone transitioning without dysphoria would be like taking antidepressants without depression. It’s unnecessary.

1