My draft guesses

Analysis

I’m sure everyone is already getting tired of draft speculation, but I wanted to write my thoughts out and figured this was as good a place as any.

I am trying to have some reasonable expectations with this draft “board”, your Jamar Chases and Jaylen Waddles will not be available. I am only listing players that I think will be available near where we will draft. Gute has moved up or down on day 1 or 2 every year so far, and so I expect him to be willing to move up or down for a player he likes on day 1-2. However he does not seem to be the type to mortgage the future by making a huge trade. Gute’s drafts so far have been more about best player available than they have been about immediate team need, but there has always been some eye for what the team needs within the next few years. I tried to replicate this. I am only doing the first 3 rounds because I am not expert enough to make even halfway accurate guesses past that.

I listed the positions I did because they reflect positions that will improve the team in the short term and will be long term needs. I admit I have not watched college ball in the last few years, so most of my opinions on individual players comes from combining PFF and Walter Football. I’ve listed their overall rank from PFFs big board and the round grade from Walter Football.

1st Pick - Gute has a mixed history of taking immediate starters (Jaire, Savage) and developmental prospects (Gary, Love). Fortunately this year I don’t think he has to choose between immediate help and future need.

OT- I think this is the preferred position to spend our first pick on. A starting caliber RT would improve the team noticeably(as Turner is a better OG than OT), and we will need a replacement for Bahk in another 2-3 years. Now is the time to find that player.

Trade up for Christian Darrisaw (PFF- #16, WF- round 1)

Trade down for Samuel Cosmi (PFF- #37, WF- round 1-2)

WR - In similar fashion, a talented rookie WR could benefit the team now, and Adams is not getting younger. In reality we probably only have 2-3 more years of elite play from him, now is a good time to find his heir.

Terrace Marshall (PFF- #26, WF- round 1-2)

Kadrius Toney (PFF- #38, WF- round 1-2)

CB - I think this is our backup plan. We will do this only if no players we like at the previous 2 positions are available, or there is a player we absolutely love available. However this is actually not a deep year for outside CBs, which is what we would be looking for.

Trade down for Caleb Farley (PFF- #27, WF- round 1-2)

2nd Pick

WR - This will be the preferred position if we do not take a WR with our 1st pick.

Dyami Brown (PFF- #46, WF- round 2-4)

ILB - While Martin and Barnes have greatly exceeded my expectations, this is still a position that needs help both in the short and long term.

Jabril Cox (PFF- #47, WF- round 2-3)

Jamin Davis (PFF- #63, WF- round 1-2)

S - I expect our “base” defense to once again have 5 DBs on the field. This means a rookie safety would be competing for playing time with Sullivan(who has been a bit of a disappointment). Further Amos is not young. Drafting someone to play a nickel DB for a few years and then try to take over for Amos is a solid idea.

Richie Grant (PFF- #51, WF- round 2-4)

OG - If we are unable to find an OT, then finding an OG or C helps in both the short and long term. I do not think it is a good idea to rely on both Patrick and Runyan.

Wyatt Davis (PFF- #62, WF- round 2-3)

C

Landon Dickerson (PFF- #45, WF- Round 2-3)

DL - I do not think this position is valued enough by our FO to spend their 1st pick on it. However it is a position of both immediate and future need. We do not have anyone good enough to put beside KC, and we don’t have anyone who looks like they will be in the next few years either.

Carlos Basham (PFF- #40, WF- round 2-3)

Trade down for Dayo Ogeyingbo (PFF- 118, WF- round 2-3)

3rd Pick

ILB Justin Hilliard (PFF- #94, WF- could not find)

S

Ar’Darius Washington (PFF #56, WF- round 3-5)

IDL

Levi Onwuzurike (PFF- #83, WF- round 1-2)

Marvin Wilson (PFF- #62, WF- round 2-4)

Daviyon Nixon (PFF#114, WF- round 2-3)

WR - Evaluation of WRs is all over the place by this point. I think there is a good chance we spend our 3rd pick on a WR, especially if we did not spend one of our first 2 here. However I am not confident enough to guess on any actual players.

Posted Apr 15, 2021, 3:40 PM UTC · edited

58
nootfloosh•

My best guess is that no matter how many simulations you run or how well you think you can predict what they will do, the actual draft will be perplexing. (And then it will make more sense down the road, maybe, hopefully.)

I have given up trying to get my hopes up for any particular player. Last year should be proof enough that no one besides Gute has a clue what he will do.

I do hope we draft Quinn Meinerz at #29 purely for the memes.

2
DoingMyJobNOT•

Leatherwood will be there at the first pick and would be perfectly fine as an addition. I would target a safety/interior lineman defense or offense. Third round I target a receiver.

1
vanweOP•

I could see him as a trade down target. But the evaluations I read about him were not appealing. WF said he is a "position-and-wall-off guy rather than a people mover" and PFF said he "gives up the edge too much to be considered a first-rounder". Without watching him play, he doesn't sound like the type of player we'd spend our first pick on.

2
Berryman_of_1795:36:•

Elijah Moore is the only WR i want

-1
nootfloosh•

Between Elijah Moore, Kadarius Toney, and Rondale Moore, I just have a hard time seeing the Packers take any of them. The Packers have very specific criteria they look for out of their receivers, and I just have a hard time seeing them want to take these guys at #29 who are all under 6'0 and will be primarily slot or gadget type guys in the NFL. A receiver that is primarily a smaller slot guy isn't a position you fill in round 1, and these three won't be around long enough in round 2 for us to take either.

D'Wayne Eskridge, Jaelon Darden, Tutu Atwell, and Amari Rodgers are rounds 2-4 possibilities if that's the sort of WR they're looking for. Ihmir Smith-Marsette is apparently high on their board as well and could be a 3rd round option as someone who can be used in a variety of roles and doesn't have the same size concerns as the other names I mentioned.

I do happen to think they will take at least one WR, possibly two, but they will take a stab at one of these other guys further down the draft board that fit their style better. Just my opinion of course. But these are the guys I would keep on your radar: Simi Fehoko, Michael Strachan, Josh Imatorbhebhe, Jonathan Adams, Jacob Harris, etc. Big, athletic, matchup nightmares who should all go between rounds 4-7.

2
vanweOP•

We would likely need to trade up for him and I don't think we would do that for any WR. If he's there at pick #29 then absolutely, but I didn't think that is likely enough to mention.

1
Berryman_of_1795:36:•

A lot of sites have him still ranked somewhere between 30-60....ranked around 8th WR or so.

Websites are different than team boards but he should be there at 29.

If he's not, that means 5 QBs were taken and anywhere from 5-8 WRs taken before us....so getting the 15th-19th highest rated prospect outside of those two positions at 29 is really great value.

I'm just wondering, to target him specifically, whether we would have to trade down from our 1st or trade up from our 2nd.

2
vanweOP•

I looked at him a bit more and there are a few sources that rate him worse than I was, so maybe you are right.

The draft is always hard to predict. Last year, in a "good WR year" there were 6 WRs taken in the first 25 picks. This is another "good WR year", so it's fairly likely we will have to trade up to get the 5th WR taken. Also I'm not certain we will be looking to take a slot guy, even if we take a WR. Remember if we spend our 1st pick on a WR we're looking for the heir to Adams, which needs to be able to play both outside and in the slot.

2