r/livesound•
kelcema

Insurance - Are You Covered? (A re-post with some new material added!)

I'm doing a re-post of my previous insurance post because now that things (here in the US, at least) are starting to look optimistic about "getting back to work," it's a great time to review your coverages! You want to always make sure that you are properly covered in case of an incident. :)

For the sake of this post, "business use" is any activity you do for which you are compensated. This is important, as will be covered further on.

If you're a casual user, with no legal business structure, you should start with your personal homeowner's insurance company. You want to make sure that your "Business Personal Property" ("BPP," Items you personally own that are used in connection with business use) is scheduled and covered. Many personal homeowner's insurance policies either explicitly exclude BPP or limit to, say, $2,500 in coverage. The advantage, though, is that they will often cover your BPP anywhere in the world. You don't want to have your car stolen with $8,000 in DJ and sound gear in it, just to find that since you're using this gear in connection with business they're limiting your coverage or denying your claim altogether! [Source: Had gear stolen from my car, parked in my condo's parking garage. I wasn't working under a valid business insurance policy at the time, as my business structure had lapsed. Personal insurance denied coverage beyond $2,500 because that was their limit for BPP. Had I scheduled out that I was keeping BPP in my residence at the time, I could have been afforded coverage by my personal insurance policy that would have made me whole after this theft.]

If you're in a more formal business structure (doing this as a "weekend warrior" or even a couple-three nights a week) then now's the time to start looking at a full business insurance policy. Keep in mind that in the event of an incident, the people involved are going to lawyer up and sue anyone and everyone involved with the event- the venue, the promoter, the artists, and the production company. This can even include the manufacturer of your equipment, if the loss is a result of perceived equipment failure.

As such, you're going to want at least two things and maybe the third:

  • General Liability ("G/L") coverage (covers the risk of personal injuries or death caused to others by your equipment, your negligence or other actions by you or your associates),

  • Inland Marine (covers your equipment, both owned and rented), and

  • "Business Personal Property," which I have recently learned is a separate coverage for business items that aren't taken to shows (which is covered by I/M) but still needs to be protected. So, retail inventory, your office computer, maybe the old speakers that hang out in the shop to play music on. I USED to think that this coverage could cover mobile items (used for show) when it's back at your shop, and I/M then cover while out at a show... but when renewing our insurance coverage last year, I learned that the insurance companies want ANYTHING that could be used for shows be covered under I/M (which, of course, costs more than BPP!). Because of this discovery, and our I/M coverage increasing, we get to find a new carrier this year. Yay...

(If you have employees, you'll also want to (or be required to) set up an industrial insurance account with your state's Department of Labor & Industries. This "Workman's Comp" insurance protects your employees in the case of an accident while at work. FunFact: we all know it's super common in our industry for companies to use "freelancers," instead of "real employees" -- and if a "Freelancer" were to be injured on your show, if they don't have their own insurance company, they're going to be in a world of hurt!)

Many venues are now asking that incoming production providers not only provide proof of G/L coverage, but also have you issue them a Certificate of Insurance ("COI") naming them as an "Additionally Insured." This affords them (the venue) a secondary level of coverage in the case of an incident. A good insurance agency will issue COIs on request and for no charge, but even if they charge a few dollars for it, that's worth making sure that everyone is covered. You can also ask for a COI from the client, naming YOU as an "additionally insured." This dual coverage means that should something happen, there's multiple coverages that can pay out.

"Inland Marine" is the term for the coverage for your equipment, both what you own and what you might rent from another company. If you've not already done so, start an Excel spreadsheet with dates of purchase, item description, purchase price, and serial number or other identifying marks. I've been tracking mine for nearly 15 years, including listing a sequential asset number. These asset numbers were helpful lately as we migrated our way into a barcode inventory control system- instead of having to go back and develop these asset numbers, I'd already been doing that (even if an item wasn't being labeled with that number at the time, I still knew what it was!). Having the ability to provide a list of gear, with purchase dates and prices, and serial numbers, to your insurance carrier will also make them happy. :)

Contracts: Whether you are doing dry rentals (either customer pickup and return or you deliver-setup-and-return-later-to-strike) or full production services, make sure you are covered by a contract. More importantly for the dry rentals, make sure that your contract verbiage specifies that the customer is responsible for the safekeeping of the rental equipment while it is in their possession. Then, run this contract verbiage past your insurance carrier, to make sure it meets their requirements. If the contract isn't specific enough in stipulating that the client is responsible for the safety of the rental equipment during the rental period, or if you don't have a contract at all (or it's not specifically signed by the client) you may find insurance coverage denied in the case of an incident as they will state that without a legal contract with the client, it was just a "loan" or something similar. [Source: Again, had this happen to us. Client rented a DJ equipment package. We delivered/setup/returned to strike. Returned, and everything was gone. Client stole it. Because we didn't have a signature on a contract (even though we had email agreement and a payment made), insurance deemed this insufficient to place responsibility on the client and denied our claim. $6500 in DJ gear, gone. Lesson: ALWAYS GET A SIGNATURE.]

Now, your insurance company may also ask that you get proof of insurance from anyone renting your equipment, even if it's something small like a party or wedding renting $250 in PA. Like the contract and its verbiage, make sure you have this conversation with your insurance carrier to make sure that you are carrying out the duties they require you to to ensure that you have insurance coverage in the case of an incident.

Vehicles: If you are driving your personal vehicle (loaded with your BPP) to an event, you may be considered "driving commercially." You may want to have a conversation with your automobile insurance carrier to make sure you are afforded coverage in the case of an accident while driving to or from a show. Making certain that you have this coverage as well as commercial G/L insurance will give an added layer of coverage should something happen.

Here's something new I learned this past year! So our commercial vehicle policy? It actually (for like $35 a year or something stupidly low) also covers our employees while traveling to the job site! If your tech is driving to a show, and gets in an accident, this will "pile on" to their personal insurance to help make sure they're totally taken care of. If you have employees, talk to your insurance agent about having that coverage in place. In our case, it was referred to as "Non-Ownership Liability Coverage," and the premium was based on the number of employees.

Finally, if you are finding yourself working more than just the occasional event, I would suggest setting up a basic LLC with your state. In most states, they are cheap or even free to organize, but even if they're not, it's worth it. As a "Limited Liability Company," you will be shielding your personal assets from the happenings of your business. If something catastrophic occurs, the limit of your liability would be everything the business owns, which means your house, your personal belongings, your life savings, etc, would be protected. Having an LLC structure is even more important if you're not working under the protection of a commercial general liability policy.

Bottom Line: It's much better to take these sorts of things into consideration, and have conversations with your various insurers, and fully explain your activities, before something happens. You don't want to find yourself dealing with a theft, speaker-falling-over or vehicle accident and realise that you don't have the protections you thought you had!

-Ray

[Please note that I am not a lawyer, a tax accountant, insurance agent, nor otherwise professionally trained in these fields. I am sharing these thoughts for the benefit of the readers, and as such, this content should not be misconstrued as legal or other professional advice. The suggestions herein may not be applicable to all situations. For specific advice regarding your situation, please consult a professional]

Posted Apr 15, 2021, 7:42 PM UTC

586
EviltechieBroadcast Engineer•

Bonus question mostly for my own curiosity: What type of policy is needed to cover items when being shipped? For example, sometimes at work I have to ship very expensive lenses back for service, and shipping fees with FedEx/UPS can quickly reach stupid numbers when you declare the value of your shipment as $50k. Is there a policy that would cover shipping losses/damage without us having to pay for coverage on an individual basis, or do companies that do this sort of thing regularly work out different arrangements with their preferred shipping companies?

7
kelcemaOP•

I would check with your insurance agent. I could imagine the Inland Marine covering an item rented while it's "under your control and possession" (since while en-route back to the supplier, it hasn't been 'returned to them' yet), but one would need to speak to their agent and carrier to clarify coverage.

... yeah, asking Fedex/UPS to insure for $50k will sure get expensive and fast! I would assume that companies who are shipping things often by common carrier have some sort of blanket agreement with the carrier, though, so they don't have to indicate the value (and pay for coverage) on every single shipment. Especially when they also then provide a prepaid return label.

Still all things that are good to have worked out before a loss occurs. :)

2
rqx82•

Having dealt with the exact situation you’re describing (expensive lens from a subrental vendor being damaged in shipping), in my case the lens was covered by the vendor’s insurance policy, as they were also responsible for shipping costs. Those costs were rolled into our rental price, but they arranged the shipping and it was on their account. This will probably vary from vendor to vendor, but in this case, I was glad that shipping was on their account even if we were paying for it indirectly. In your case of shipping lenses for service (to the manufacturer or repair service company I assume), I would ask for an RMA and shipping label from them. If they won’t do that, it’s worth looking into mitigating risk at that point. If insurance from FedEx is going to be $500, I would look into buying a custom fitted flight case that will protect against all but the most catastrophic damage (i.e., a truck literally drives over it). If you’re really concerned, call subrental vendors and see what they do.

2
EviltechieBroadcast Engineer•

In this situation we actually got a loaner case from Canon because our normal cases are not suitable for shipping box lenses. (We have since purchased a suitable case of our own too.)

It just gets messy in general when you start to declare high value shipments with UPS. After a few grand they make you have the driver countersign the pickup (or you have to drop it off at an actual UPS location). Once you get to about $30k then they make you ship next day air, and they won't take anything past $50k. That makes it hard for me to ship a $200k lens, and I don't do this enough to start to mess with a company like SOS.

I'm going to have to ask my boss to look into this for the future. If our current insurance covers our gear no matter where it is then I can save a lot of money and hassle on shipping this stuff in the future.

1
rqx82•

Fantastic post. For freelancers needing liability insurance, I would suggest looking into the Event Safety Alliance’s “crew cover” insurance policies geared for exactly those people. There are multiple insurance vendors aligned with the ESA that offer that and other appropriate products. Also, shameless plug for the Event Safety Alliance - I’m only a member, not on the board or anything, but it’s well worth the small cost to join. They offer a huge wealth of information, education, and best practices on everything from PPE to rigging to insurance to crowd control and everything else you can think of that’s event safety related. ESA is also a great networking group of event professionals that take safety as seriously as their chosen specialty, and like to share and work together to improve the quality and safety of events for everyone.

5
AlaskanOCProducer•

Any sample rental or booking contract language you'd be willing to share?

2