Inspired by other GMs I created custom relics for my players PCs

Arts & Crafts

I saw another post here a few weeks back where a GM showed off the awesome relics he created for his PCs. Inspired by this I went ahead and started drafting custom items for my buddy cop duo. I want to give you a little context and then I'll show you the gear.

  1. I'm running Agents of Edgewatch for two players. Everything may seem a little bit overpowered, but they still struggle with some of the combat encounters, even when I tone it down for them.
  2. I didn't want to rebalance everything so I started them with 15 ability score increases over the usual 10. They are both playing a martial class with a free sorcerer archetype. They are now close to level 4, we're about to head into the final chapter of book 1 and so far it has worked out pretty great.
  3. The relics represent different aspects of their characters, based around their class, background or playstyle. I picked an item that suited their needs, slapped a rune and some magic on it and then developed 3 possible upgrade paths for future iteration. I also checked the various pantheons and deities for some lore ideas and potential plot hooks.

With that out of the way, let's go ahead and take a closer look at the characters and their relics:

​

Shifting Gauntlet of Light This level 5 item was designed for Rubí Baya, NG Redeemer Champion of Iomedae. She originally studied to become a veterinarian when she found her true calling and the Earth Elemental Bloodline is running strong in her clan. The three aspects I found in her character and playstyle were pretty straightforward: protect, heal, smash.

The gauntlet is originally a gift from Sairazul (The Crystalline Queen), but reflects the ideas of Torag (The Forge Father) and Korada (The Open Hand of Harmony) just as much. Their Edicts and Anathema more or less reflect Rubí, her values and actions, and I'm excited to see in which direction she's going to take the relic.

​

Fearsome Cloak of Discretion This level 5 item was designed for Dragon Malt, CN Thief Rogue of no god. They are a criminal, were always a criminal and how they ended up as Edgewatch is a mystery in its own right. Somewhere down the line a Gold Dragon Bloodline manifested for them. The three aspects here are: steal/hide, hunt, burn.

The cloak actually belongs to Sivanah (The Seventh Veil), but is refined by the magic of no other than Ra (King of the Heavens) and Apsu (The Waybringer). Some of their Edicts and Anathema present a genuine challenge for Dragon, but they are there and just waiting to be explored.

Here are the full upgrade paths we have planned for the cloak and gauntlet (Edit: The links now reference the updated versions of the relics). We incorporated feats, focus spells and items they wouldn't necessarily have access to, but fit with the theme of the characters.

​

What are your thoughts? What would you change? What do you like? What confuses you the most?

TIA! :)

Posted Apr 16, 2021, 4:19 PM UTC · edited

510
RaidRoverGM in Training•

Gauntlet of Light: Shifting isn't actually a a rune that can be applied to shields. Currently there are no runes that apply to shields actually. But the Phalanx ability makes it clear enough what's supposed to happen. Concern though, can it only change into base shields or can it turn into specific shields; if so, what are the limitation on that? If the shield is broken, or worse destroyed, how does it get repaired? Usual crafting skill, automatically with time, every long rest, etc? The Blossom effect should probably upgrade to the heightened version of Light at some point. Or maybe just a note that it increases automatically when you can cast 4th level spells. You mention the Endurer, Sustainer, and Breaker aspects and that they get increased by some abilities but I don't see details on what they do exactly baseline. - The rest goes beyond the time I have to check this out at work. I'll check back later if you don't get more feedback.

Fearsome Cloak: Its baseline ability is quite a bit stronger than the relic abilities we currently have in book. The Shadow gifts have a minor gif that gives a +4 bonus to Stealth checks to conceal object vs this giving invisibility on objects. You only have 2 people so maybe you want that extra strength, it would be understandable but I thought it worth pointing this out. Same problem with Aspects here. Needs clarification on what exactly the item bonus is. - The rest goes beyond the time I have to check this out at work. I'll check back later if you don't get more feedback.

In general for both, do they get all of the new Abilities at each upgrade or do they have to choose one?

3
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Thank you for taking the time! I really appreciate it.

I'm aware there's no runes for shields, but carrying a tower shield really limits the impact of the Sorcerer Archetype for Rubí. You could also look at it as having a gauntlet weapon that can shift into shields only. Restoring the shield is an excellent question that I didn't put a lot of thought into, yet. Recovery over night or at a cost is a good suggestion. I'll think about it! Heightening the Blossom effect later makes sense. The other abilities can get better versions, too.

The baseline ability of the cloak is the same as Ring of Discretion presented in the AP.

They will have to pick one of the new abilities when they unlock a new upgrade.

The aspects are tied to the abilities they pick. Mechanically they are represented as status or item bonus or increased damage.

Endurer: +1/2/3 to saves

Sustained: +1/2/3 HP to heals

Breaker: +1/2/3 damage with earth spells

Stalker: +1/2/3 to Dex skills

Hunter: +1/2/3 to ranged strikes

Scorcher: +1/2/3 fire damage with spells

1
RaidRoverGM in Training•

I'm aware there's no runes for shields, but carrying a tower shield really limits the impact of the Sorcerer Archetype for Rubí. You could also look at it as having a gauntlet weapon that can shift into shields only. Restoring the shield is an excellent question that I didn't put a lot of thought into, yet.

Obviously its all homebrewing so if you want to homebrew that its cool. I have been looking at Homebrewing some shield stuff myself but haven't laid it out yet. Shield unfortunately fall off really quickly unless you open up magical or precious materials as options for shifting to the shield. You'll need to lay out those options. As far as restoring it I would consider a 10 minute activity the wearer can take to force it to heal similar to the repair action but without the crafting check; it feels more thematic than pulling out a hammer and whacking it. Maybe an hour long one to reform it at half-health if it gets destroyed or full restoration overnight.

edit: I see you gave shield increases in the Endurer line of Aspects. That should probably be moved to baseline progression or it will force the player to either choose these or have them fall into uselessness.

The baseline ability of the cloak is the same as Ring of Discretion presented in the AP.

Ah I haven't played the AP yet so I didn't know about that ring. Seems strong at level 1 but if that is an option in the game then I guess its inline.

They will have to pick one of the new abilities when they unlock a new upgrade. The aspects are tied to the abilities they pick. Mechanically they are represented as status or item bonus or increased damage.

That makes more sense. I will look all the options back over with that in mind and make a fresh comment on those. When presenting these options to your players I would probably break it up in a different way. Present the base item with its natural progressions. Then make a separate progression list for just the 3 paths so they can focus in on each one. Right now, its very dense and hard to compare vertically.

Endurer: +1/2/3 to saves

Sustained: +1/2/3 HP to heals

Breaker: +1/2/3 damage with earth spells

Stalker: +1/2/3 to Dex skills

Hunter: +1/2/3 to ranged strikes

Scorcher: +1/2/3 fire damage with spells

The bonus to saves and Dex skills are good at those rates. But the +1/2/3 on damage and heal will weaken significantly in time. +1/2/3 per dice would be more inline with feats like Dangerous Sorcery and Healing Hands. This progression would be really slow on the ranged strikes though so more like +2/+4/+6 on ranged strikes. Nevermind, that would be too strong. Arrows are unlimited and single action, stick to the +1/2/3 you had. But you should specify that this is for physical strikes because a bunch of spells are ranged and it would technically apply to those too. And you should probably specify the Scorcher aspect does not apply to persistent damage or it would be too strong.

2
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Thanks a lot for all your time, I will post the new versions once I've got everything reworked :)

1
kneymoOPGM in Training•

I tried to present a choice of offense, defense and utility at each upgrade tier.

To clarify further, once they have selected the same aspect twice it automatically improves the tier 3&4 abilities when they reach the next upgrade.

1
RaidRoverGM in Training•

Gauntlet of Light:

  • Endurer:
    • Harden: At level 5 there isn't any reason to use this Focus ability instead of Lay on Hands which the champion already gets. At level 5 LoH will heal 18 hp and give +2 AC for a round vs 5 temp HP. Physical DR for 1 minute would be a much more worthwhile buff while being on theme. Maybe 1/2 level in DR, then full level in DR. The decrease on dying DCs wouldn't stack with Toughness which you player might want; check out Defy Death for better wording. The drop to 6 is a pretty huge plummet in DC and its a little boring tbh. Maybe a once per day shrugoff of the dying condition like Orc Ferocity.
    • Bubble: Oh you have DR here. Probably something different on harden then. I would probably start with 10 feet aura from the start to allow it to work while flanking. Then increased to 15 feet to let it work while flanking Large enemies.
    • Fortify: Simple enough ability. I feel like its a little on the non-flashy side for level 17 but its definitely useful
  • Sustainer:
    • Solarium: A bit better than Fast Recovery is useful. On the upgrade it could use a bit of a boost, maybe a bonus against poison/disease.
    • Harvest: Goodberry is Good
    • Saturate: Reducing the drained condition here is really strong when combined with that reaction. Shrugging off spells + healing + an extra Focus Point (basically with the drained removal) make this strongest final tier ability even if it isn't as "cool" as a earthquake.
  • Breaker:
    • Grounded: This one is good, same with its upgrade
    • Seismic: Because spell levels scale faster than weapon dice it is much stronger to use this on spells than weapons. Maybe tie it to character level, +1 per 4 character levels makes it slightly stronger for weapons and bring down the spell boost.
    • Quake: A bit more damage than the Earthquake spell but shorter range and smaller area makes it seem fair enough. If that part about the fortitude save is about negative effects to the Player I would remove it. It would be the only drawback on any of these at this tier. It would feel unfair if I was the player.
2
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Endurer Aspect:

  • Harden: I took inspiration from Mountain's Stoutness for this, but I honestly didn't consider Defy Death. I understand that the Focus ability is weak, I wanted to make up for it with the passives.
  • Bubble: Inspired by Protector's Sphere but traded range for higher DR. Starting with 10 feet is probably smarter and the upgraded version would be on par with the heightened cleric version.
  • Fortify: Basically Greater Fortification without the DC, but at a cost.

Sustainer Aspect:

  • Solarium: Almost identical to Solar Rejuvenation except that it also helps mitigate the drained condition.
  • Harvest: It's actually Nature's Bounty ;)
  • Saturate: Consume Spell usually requires a successful Counterspell. Instead of matching the bloodline I made it only work against negative spells to better match the theme of the aspect.

Breaker Aspect:

  • Grounded: Stole this one from Earthsense, made sense to look into elemental ancestries.
  • Seismis: Another Dwarf Feat hiding behind this one. Telluric Power is originally only for weapon attacks. I added the spell damage to make it more versatile - without considering how well it scales (especially when it's combined with the extra damage from the aspect and blood magic). Thanks for this one!
  • Quake: Since they have access to Earthquake anyways I wanted to give them an option and found Localized Quake. I'm uncertain whether or not the caster would be affected by the emanation-version of it, allowing a Fortitude save at 1 degree better is my attempt at giving the PC a better shot at avoiding the negative effects. Might discuss this with the player directly.

That was really helpful feedback, we'll make these relics even better now (:

2
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Regarding Quake:

If that part about the fortitude save is about negative effects to the Player I would remove it.

Wasn't sure if the caster's square was affected, but checked the rules again and you're right:

Unless the text states otherwise, the creature creating an emanation effect chooses whether the creature at its center is affected.

Core Rulebook 2.0 pg. 457

2
RaidRoverGM in Training•

Fearsome Cloak

  • Stalker: Everything here is fine balance wise its just sorta boring for a relic in my opinion. As is, Invisibility Cloak is the only ability I would be really excited by. Shadow Storage is basically just gold savings (though undeniably quite useful) and Night Stalker is just some number boosts.
    • Shadow Storage: There isn't anything wrong with this per say, its just a money saver though.
    • Invisibility Cloak: Focus spell from the Illusion Wizard is good.
    • Night Stalker: +6 on stealth checks is pretty big and will make them pretty hard to find without special sense. But its also kinda boring at this level. Something like Shadow Master from the Shadowdancer archetype could be more exciting. Or something like Dark Roads which lets you teleport between shadows.
  • Hunter:
    • Shadow Sight: Darkvision is useful if they don't have it and Greater Darkvision is a serious boost. Nice one.
    • Penetrating Shot: I really really enjoy this ability. I would love to be playing with this all the time. The upgrade is certainly a good action economy boost and works well with spell casting but I almost wish for a stronger shot instead that can penetrate higher grade covers like walls.
    • Hunter's Vision: Great ability, its useful but the range is quite short. If this character uses a bow a lot (which Penetrating Shot suggests) then a longer range like 60 feet would be a nice touch.
  • Scorcher:
    • Charred Remains: Strong thematic ability with a dope effect. Damage is pretty low though and will not scale well. Check out this spell for some possible guidance. Matching it would be too strong but 1 and 3 on the upgrade might be more appropriate.
    • Flame Barrier: Good reaction, could definitely save the players skin once or twice.
    • Hellfire Cloak: Not too crazy about this one. It feels really similar to Charred Remains tbh. More damage and mobility but it puts you in more danger and isn't as convenient for creating terrain on where enemies are right now. Its not bad, it just doesn't feel unique. One suggestion I have is maybe a 1 minute buff that creates a damaging fire aura or a free action metamagic that lets a fire spell ignore fire resistance/immunity?
2
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Stalker

  • Shadow Storage: At first I wanted to match the idea behind Encompassing Darkness or Hefting Shadow, but the player was looking for a Bag of Holding and Sleeves of Storage seemed easy enough to repurpose for the cloak. Maybe Shadow Smith is more interesting, and let the upgrade conjure expert tools.
  • Invisibility Cloak: I'm thinking about adding the 4th-level Invisibility effect for the upgraded version.
  • Night Stalker: Shadow rune for free, basically, but you're right, it feels kind of redundant. They are pretty good at Stealth anyways and the aspect provides the same bonus already. Dark Roads reminds me that I put all this work into making these relics without looking at the RAW gifts even once :D

Hunter

  • Shadow Sight: Thank you, I really like this one too, especially with the flavor description.
  • Penetrating Shot: Actually thought about letting it penetrate cover from the start, but didn't consider it for the upgrade. It probably would make for a decent trade vs. better action economy.
  • Hunter's Vision: I will likely give this the higher range, especially when penetrating shot is able to pierce through cover at this level!

Scorcher

  • Charred Remains: What about leaving it as is and changing it to 1d4 on the upgrade, to better reflect the unpredictable nature of the element?
  • Flame Barrier: If they play well together, they probably won't need this as a defensive option. I agree that having this as a reaction is what makes is worth considering.
  • Hellfire Cloak: Hellfire Boots probably don't translate well here, you make some really valid points here. I'll probably replace this with another effect entirely, the RAW fire gifts for relics are pretty neat, too! Heat Haze works great for a rogue and with Incandescent Sight gives me some ideas as well.

This cleaerly needs some more work. Especially compared to the gauntlet some of the choices here may feel lackluster, but I really like your directions!

1