Thoughts on Two Party Consent for recording?

Discussion

from recordinglaw(dot)com:

In Two party (or all party) consent states it is required by state law that all parties that partake in a conversation must have given consent for that conversation to be recorded when there is an expectation of privacy. This law covers private as well as public places, if there is an expectation of privacy, consent must be given.

What are your thoughts on the necessity of such a law?

Posted Apr 19, 2021, 9:32 PM UTC

127
Cali_AnCap🚩💰Ancap💰🚩•

I would absolutely demand my consent to the recording of any meetings I'm a part of, but I'd never request that the state be made aware of any of my conversations.

9
ahackercalled4chan🎻Classical Liberal🎻•

i agree. it's none of the state's business and my ignorance/unawareness to the existence of the recording violates my right to privacy.

7
emmettcito⚔️Minarchist⚔️•

I disagree with this law. If you go into a meeting and have the right to tell other people what happened in it, then you should also be able to record it and tell what happened in it by showing a recording. Also this law makes it easier for people in power (government and large corporations) to keep secrets from the public.

7
IpickThingsUp11B⚔️Minarchist⚔️•

if you don't want something disclosed then either Don't tell anybody, or have them agree to non disclosure.

6
GreatCCPmember🎻Classical Liberal🎻•

This is just a tool for government officials to hide secrets, fuck off.

5
auxiliary-character🎻Classical Liberal🎻•

This is a complicated one. On one hand, you have a reasonable expectation of privacy, which should be protected. On the other hand, there is journalistic utility in being able to covertly record conversations with, say, customer service or government officials. Furthermore, it has to be considered that even if it is declared to be illegal, that doesn't fully prevent someone from doing it illegally and publishing it anonymously. Not exactly sure which way I lean on this one, to be honest.

3
Apptubrutae⚔️Minarchist⚔️•

Good question.

I’m fine either way, honestly. I don’t have any issue with single party recording in a public place.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1