Are you in favor of the existence of prisons (whether punitive or rehabilitative)? And if not, what do we do with people who refuse to pay reparations for damages?

Posted Apr 20, 2021, 6:33 PM UTC

1016
[deleted]•

[removed]

10
[deleted]•

[removed]

8
TheUserU2•

Generally, no. The main problem with prisons is that it imposes a cost on the victim. It should be the other way around, where the criminal has to bear the cost the victim bore. So I think they will be quite rare, if they need to exist at all.

As for the second question, rights enforcement agencies can take the money by force.

7
trufus_for_youfus•

I love to listen to people's thoughts on private rights enforcement. A succinct description of how you envision such an organization operating would be immensely appreciated.

1
TheUserU2•

I think these videos provide a good description:

Private law: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTYkdEU_B4o&ab_channel=bitbutter

What about the poor?: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ewbTfv40vWs&ab_channel=bitbutter

More on conflict resolution: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8kPyrq6SEL0&ab_channel=ManAgainstTheState

These videos mostly talk about how law enforcement and creation would work, but I think these companies will be more concerned about preventing crime (NAP violations) in the first place. The cost of running a rights enforcement agency is dealing with crime, so these companies are going to want to reduce it as much as possible. Of course, I don't know what the most effective methods are. Unfortunately, nobody does due to the government's monopoly on law and law enforcement.

Also, it's good to note that these companies will usually operate like insurance companies. A regular fee is payed for access to the services when needed. Although, I wouldn't be surprised if some companies also had a case by case option, but this would probably be quite expensive.

1

where the criminal has to bear the cost the victim bore

what if the criminal killed an entire family?

As for the second question, rights enforcement agencies can take the money by force.

what if they have no money, and following that up, nothing to repossess?

1
TheUserU2•

what if the criminal killed an entire family?

I assume you mean murder. To answer the question, there are few options for justice when it comes to murder. Obviously, you can't pay up what you owe to the person you murdered, so I can think of two options. One option is execution. Strangely, some people think this is a unusually cruel punishment. For most crimes that's true, but in the case of murder, the murderer would certainly get what he deserves. The other option is some form of "slavery" to family members (or whoever gets to claim the murderer as their slave). The murderer will be forced to work for the family (or perhaps friends or whatever). He would be in debt for the rest of his life because that's what he took from someone else.

Some unusual options include mercy (the victims let the murderer go free for whatever reason), or if the murderer is insane, perhaps an organization of some sort volunteers to take care of him. Perhaps a prison would exist for certain, exceptional cases, assuming people are willing to pay for them.

what if they have no money, and following that up, nothing to repossess?

The criminal would be in debt to the victim. He would be forced to pay it off, but the exact arrangement by which this would occur would be decided in the court. Perhaps he would owe a certain fraction of his income each year until it's payed off.

1

I see what you're saying, but I have a question. Do you believe in rehabilitation? Sorry for the short response. Trying to see your ideals

1
TheUserU2•

Don't worry about the short response. I think trying to help criminals recover from their poor life decisions is a kind and loving thing to do, but I think it's obvious now that prisons are a terrible way to do this. In fact, I think if you support rehabilitation, you should be fighting against the prison system, which has been counterproductive (big understatement) for rehabilitating criminals.

And of course, this rehabilitation would have to be voluntary. Perhaps the market will provide in this case as well. I can imagine some companies using this as an opportunity to hire cheap labor (I'm not sure how often this happens in countries today).

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
trufus_for_youfus•

Incarceration should be voluntary (and look completely different than what we are “used to”.).

Exile should be the alternative. Exile is a powerful tool in legal frameworks. It’s falling away as an acceptable solution over the last couple of hundred years is curious.

1
ConTheCoderOP•

If there is no state, where do they get exiled to? If I get exiled from the private property I committed a crime on, I could just go to the neighboring property and live there.

1
trufus_for_youfus•

You ever heard of walls or security? In a stateless society there would no doubt be much more of both.

1
ConTheCoderOP•

Drop the snide, dickhead.

The point is, if someone breaks NAP and damages another individual, exiling the person off the property and leaving them free to hurt others elsewhere doesn't seem like a sensible solution. I would prefer an Outlaw system over that.

If I murder someone on their property, now I'm exiled from their property and am free to go murder people elsewhere.

1
trufus_for_youfus•

Calm down my friend. We are on the same side here. If a person steals my stereo and we agree (whether arbitrated externally or not) that to settle this I want my radio back, $10.00 in restitution and a written apology and these terms are satisfied, that person is technically free to steal someone else’s radio. Has anyone’s else’s rights been violated in this case? We can get to heinous crimes later. Should that person be punished outside of this arrangement?

I find it useful to establish baselines on less inflammatory terms. The concept of outlaw rules is a fascinating one but just because someone harmed me specifically does not in any way guarantee that they will hurt someone else.

Edit: added a word and removed a word for clarity

1