CMV: American democracy will come to an end in 2024
Before I start, I want everyone to know I desperately want to be wrong. As overused the word ‘patriot’ has become, I do consider myself one. Furthermore, I am honestly worried I am part of the ever-growing list of problems America has to face, and as someone who wants to see this country and everyone in it prosper, I absolutely do not want to be an additional complication.
Ok, now I can start. Right off the bat, I am a Democrat. I was able to vote for the first time in the 2020 election and happily voted for Joe Biden. However, this election, as well as the trend of the past few decades has now caused me to believe that we are soon going to be under control from an anti-democratic government run by Republicans. I see the Republican party as having gone completely off the cliff. They elected multiple violent conspiracy theorists into Congress, inspired and currently defend a terrorist attack on the capital to overturn a free election, promote political and race-related violence, and are focused only on obstructing anything the Democrats do. Obviously, the Democrats are nowhere near perfect, but they are not actively working to dismantle democratic institutions and are nowhere near as extreme as the current Republican party is. But years of low-quality public education, right-wing ‘news’ media propaganda, and political polarization have led up to where we are today. I honestly think Republicans are going to sweep into Congress in 2022 and then easily take back the White House in 2024 and subsequently pass laws to ensure they never lose power again. This can already be seen at the state level with Republican majority states passing extreme voter suppression laws to make it near impossible for Democrats to win again. Of course, it is too early to theorize how the election is going to go, but using historical fact, the incumbent party loses seats in the midterm; and if Democrats can barely take back power after Trump, I fail to see how they can muster up enough support to maintain power under Biden.
I recently read a book, How Democracies Die, and it stated that one of the attributes that lead to the death of democracy is when people see the opposing political party as a threat to their livelihood. Again, I do not want to be part of the many problems this country faces so I want to be wrong, but I cannot see where I am mistaken.
Edit: When I say the end of democracy, I do not mean the installation of some sort of dictatorship. I mean that voter suppression laws go into effect at a federal level and Democrats have no chance of winning the majority of elections to maintain or gain power.
Posted Apr 21, 2021, 1:19 AM UTC · edited
But trump lost. With the full power of the federal government (including Barr as his lapdog), the GOP wasn’t able to cheat the election.
I think gerrymandering and voter suppression is real and 100% my #1 priority politically, but it seems pretty hyperbolic to say that democracy will end in 2024 after we just beat back the most authoritarian president in generations
Integrity of the elections is secondary to the perceived integrity.
2016 about half of Democrats thought the election was rigged. 2020 about half of republicans did.
The issue is that our faith in each other is declining and as such it reflects in the faith in the integrity of the elections. I don't know if it will be gone by 2024 but it is degrading rapidly.
Could you link that poll, please? I am interested if the Democrats thought the election was rigged because the popular vote winner doesn't win the presidency, not so much because of fraudulent votes.
https://www.politico.com/story/2016/10/poll-41-percent-of-voters-say-the-election-could-be-stolen-from-trump-229871
That's an article of democrat opinion on the 2016 election as requested. Do you want me to get you one on the republicans? Or are the events of January 6th enough to just move forward with the assumption that they atleast mirror the democrat ones from 2016?
Woahwoahwoah wait a second. You've severely misrepresented the article you've posted:
Your "half of Democrats believed in fraud" still shows that it's the Republicans who are the issue.
And that's even ignoring the part where the poll you linked was conducted before the election, which means it talks about hypotheticals. Meanwhile, Republicans in 2020 screamed fraud about an actual election that happened, and was fully investigated and proven not to be fraudulent.
This poll said 22% of Americans thought the election was rigged. Assuming about a 50/50 split around 40-45% of democrats thought it was rigged. Hard to find polls from 4 years on that specific topic broke down by party
https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2016/11/16/poll-results-rigged-election
That's not how percents work! If you assume a proportional 50/50 split, then the number of Democrats believing in the election being rigged is still 22%.
Huh, interesting. Thanks for the link! I guess this is just more reasoning to improve education
But we didint win back legislative control at the state level of key states which saw their ability to win federally was shrinking. These states (TX GA AZ FL) then immediately took to using their state level legislative control to implement voter suppression laws to ensure their continued control at the state level and making federal democratic victories more difficult. 2020 was not proof of the ability to push back authoritarians it showed republican led states their weakness and they are taking corrective action.
Look all it takes in 2022 for the right mix of people to get into power (republican majority in house and senate) and Donald Trump to demand they have some type of vote that proves he won or something to kick of a crisis. 2024 they get a trifecta and it’s game over
Trump just was not a likable person. But someone like Hawley or Graham that just repeats Trumpist talking points to pick up some of his base I think could absolutely sweep into higher power. Plus, now they see how motivated people are to vote when giving the ability that they are going to pass those state voter suppression laws at a federal level. I think I should have been more clear when I said end of democracy, I don't mean some sort of dictatorship. I just mean that Democrats have no real chance of winning elections.
I think you underestimate trumps base. Yes, a ton of people hated trump, but his appeal really seems to be a cult of personality that isn’t transferrable to anyone else
Also polling indicates that the trump-supporter favorite for 2024 is desantis, while the non-trump-supporter gop favorite is actually pence
Finally, voter suppression is absolutely nothing new. While we should absolutely be worried about it, none of the voter suppression laws come anything close to the jim crow era laws
Furthermore, we have demographic change on our side
Yeah, DeSantis is who I am worried about running. He has this sort of aura to him that makes him stomachable to moderates, while also catering to the extremists. I truly believe that if he were to get into power, with a Republican congress, they would pass some insane voter suppression laws. I understand they are nothing new, but something as extreme as we are seeing now at a federal level would be another level.
I feel you, but in my try-hardness in trying to get the delta, i want to make the point that this is nothing new. None of these voter suppression laws compare to poll taxes/literacy tests or even lynching.
We’ve faced worse before, and while people are absolutely going to face unnecessary hardship and pain and violence, we will get through this. This isn’t the end of democracy