CMV: American democracy will come to an end in 2024

Delta(s) from OP

Before I start, I want everyone to know I desperately want to be wrong. As overused the word ‘patriot’ has become, I do consider myself one. Furthermore, I am honestly worried I am part of the ever-growing list of problems America has to face, and as someone who wants to see this country and everyone in it prosper, I absolutely do not want to be an additional complication.

Ok, now I can start. Right off the bat, I am a Democrat. I was able to vote for the first time in the 2020 election and happily voted for Joe Biden. However, this election, as well as the trend of the past few decades has now caused me to believe that we are soon going to be under control from an anti-democratic government run by Republicans. I see the Republican party as having gone completely off the cliff. They elected multiple violent conspiracy theorists into Congress, inspired and currently defend a terrorist attack on the capital to overturn a free election, promote political and race-related violence, and are focused only on obstructing anything the Democrats do. Obviously, the Democrats are nowhere near perfect, but they are not actively working to dismantle democratic institutions and are nowhere near as extreme as the current Republican party is. But years of low-quality public education, right-wing ‘news’ media propaganda, and political polarization have led up to where we are today. I honestly think Republicans are going to sweep into Congress in 2022 and then easily take back the White House in 2024 and subsequently pass laws to ensure they never lose power again. This can already be seen at the state level with Republican majority states passing extreme voter suppression laws to make it near impossible for Democrats to win again. Of course, it is too early to theorize how the election is going to go, but using historical fact, the incumbent party loses seats in the midterm; and if Democrats can barely take back power after Trump, I fail to see how they can muster up enough support to maintain power under Biden.

I recently read a book, How Democracies Die, and it stated that one of the attributes that lead to the death of democracy is when people see the opposing political party as a threat to their livelihood. Again, I do not want to be part of the many problems this country faces so I want to be wrong, but I cannot see where I am mistaken.

​

Edit: When I say the end of democracy, I do not mean the installation of some sort of dictatorship. I mean that voter suppression laws go into effect at a federal level and Democrats have no chance of winning the majority of elections to maintain or gain power.

Posted Apr 21, 2021, 1:19 AM UTC · edited

2105
BleuChicken21ƥ

But trump lost. With the full power of the federal government (including Barr as his lapdog), the GOP wasn’t able to cheat the election.

I think gerrymandering and voter suppression is real and 100% my #1 priority politically, but it seems pretty hyperbolic to say that democracy will end in 2024 after we just beat back the most authoritarian president in generations

20
direwolf10625ƥ

Integrity of the elections is secondary to the perceived integrity.

2016 about half of Democrats thought the election was rigged. 2020 about half of republicans did.

The issue is that our faith in each other is declining and as such it reflects in the faith in the integrity of the elections. I don't know if it will be gone by 2024 but it is degrading rapidly.

6
ml78779OP•

Could you link that poll, please? I am interested if the Democrats thought the election was rigged because the popular vote winner doesn't win the presidency, not so much because of fraudulent votes.

0
direwolf10625ƥ

https://www.politico.com/story/2016/10/poll-41-percent-of-voters-say-the-election-could-be-stolen-from-trump-229871

That's an article of democrat opinion on the 2016 election as requested. Do you want me to get you one on the republicans? Or are the events of January 6th enough to just move forward with the assumption that they atleast mirror the democrat ones from 2016?

1
Mront5ƥ

Woahwoahwoah wait a second. You've severely misrepresented the article you've posted:

73 percent of Republicans think the election could be swiped from him. Just 17 percent of Democrats agree with the prospect of massive fraud at the ballot box.

Your "half of Democrats believed in fraud" still shows that it's the Republicans who are the issue.

And that's even ignoring the part where the poll you linked was conducted before the election, which means it talks about hypotheticals. Meanwhile, Republicans in 2020 screamed fraud about an actual election that happened, and was fully investigated and proven not to be fraudulent.

6
h0sti1e1713ƥ

This poll said 22% of Americans thought the election was rigged. Assuming about a 50/50 split around 40-45% of democrats thought it was rigged. Hard to find polls from 4 years on that specific topic broke down by party

https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2016/11/16/poll-results-rigged-election

-1
Mront5ƥ

This poll said 22% of Americans thought the election was rigged. Assuming about a 50/50 split around 40-45% of democrats thought it was rigged.

That's not how percents work! If you assume a proportional 50/50 split, then the number of Democrats believing in the election being rigged is still 22%.

4
ml78779OP•

Huh, interesting. Thanks for the link! I guess this is just more reasoning to improve education

-1

But we didint win back legislative control at the state level of key states which saw their ability to win federally was shrinking. These states (TX GA AZ FL) then immediately took to using their state level legislative control to implement voter suppression laws to ensure their continued control at the state level and making federal democratic victories more difficult. 2020 was not proof of the ability to push back authoritarians it showed republican led states their weakness and they are taking corrective action.

Look all it takes in 2022 for the right mix of people to get into power (republican majority in house and senate) and Donald Trump to demand they have some type of vote that proves he won or something to kick of a crisis. 2024 they get a trifecta and it’s game over

1
ml78779OP•

Trump just was not a likable person. But someone like Hawley or Graham that just repeats Trumpist talking points to pick up some of his base I think could absolutely sweep into higher power. Plus, now they see how motivated people are to vote when giving the ability that they are going to pass those state voter suppression laws at a federal level. I think I should have been more clear when I said end of democracy, I don't mean some sort of dictatorship. I just mean that Democrats have no real chance of winning elections.

0
BleuChicken21ƥ

I think you underestimate trumps base. Yes, a ton of people hated trump, but his appeal really seems to be a cult of personality that isn’t transferrable to anyone else

Also polling indicates that the trump-supporter favorite for 2024 is desantis, while the non-trump-supporter gop favorite is actually pence

Finally, voter suppression is absolutely nothing new. While we should absolutely be worried about it, none of the voter suppression laws come anything close to the jim crow era laws

Furthermore, we have demographic change on our side

8
ml78779OP•

Yeah, DeSantis is who I am worried about running. He has this sort of aura to him that makes him stomachable to moderates, while also catering to the extremists. I truly believe that if he were to get into power, with a Republican congress, they would pass some insane voter suppression laws. I understand they are nothing new, but something as extreme as we are seeing now at a federal level would be another level.

1
BleuChicken21ƥ

I feel you, but in my try-hardness in trying to get the delta, i want to make the point that this is nothing new. None of these voter suppression laws compare to poll taxes/literacy tests or even lynching.

We’ve faced worse before, and while people are absolutely going to face unnecessary hardship and pain and violence, we will get through this. This isn’t the end of democracy

3
iconoclast63•

As a libertarian leaning independent I see a much greater danger coming from your party. The left has engaged in brazen, unapologetic lying on virtually every important story regarding the republicans. Sure, there are some wackos in congress like Greene but there are also outright fraudsters like Schiff and Nadler. They repeatedly lied about both the Sicknick story and the Russian bounty story and, if they acknowledged the lies at all, they were noble lies to get rid of the maniac in the White House.

I am no fan of either party and I think joining the two party system and helping it survive poses a greater threat to our REPUBLIC than either poses on it's own.

8
cherrycokeicee42ƥ

They repeatedly lied about both the Sicknick story

why are you pinning what the capitol police said on random politicians who repeated the police's statements?

"Capitol Police announced Jan. 7 – the day after the riot – that Sicknick responded to the attack and “was injured while physically engaging with protesters.”"

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2021/04/19/capitol-officer-brian-sicknick-died-strokes-autopsy/7291796002/

6
iconoclast63•

The report from the medical examiner found NO INJURIES on Sicknick's body but evidence of two blood clots near his brain stem indicating that he died from a very poorly timed pair of strokes. The ONLY victim from the Jan 6th event that wasn't a Trump supporter died of natural causes. Two heart attacks, one drug overdose and a woman shot to death by a still unnamed, but also unCHARGED, police officer.

Even card carrying liberals should be demanding more from their so-called journalists.

And I am not going to spend the 10 seconds it would take you to find the fire extinguisher story being repeated by virtually every media outlet in the wake of Jan 6th.

3†
ml78779OP•

So do you think that what happened on January 6th was peaceful? That no one got hurt? That the people there didn't try to hurt anyone? Also can you please link a story about the medical examiner, because there are plenty of videos of the people there attacking and very apparently hurting police officers, including officer Sicknick?

8
iconoclast63•

Nope. I think they were trespassing and making illegal entry into the building and should be charged with the crimes they committed but I also don't think that it was anything close to an "armed insurrection", especially considering that almost none of them were even armed.

And the damage done that day, while more symbolic because it took place at the Capitol, is FAR, FAR less than the riots in cities all over the country since last May.

4
androidbear04•

I think what happened in Portland/chop/chaz was worse than what happened in DC.

1†
ml78779OP•

I agree that a two-party system has also been a catalyst that has moved us to where we are today. But I haven't heard of Schiff and Nadler lying about officer Sicknick, what happened there? But do you honestly believe that Republicans are more honest and more pro-democratic than the Democrats are right now? Even after what they are doing at the state level?

​

Also please do not say were a republic, not a democracy.

4
androidbear04•

But we are a constitutional republic. This country is too big for a democracy to be anything but a disaster, anyway. Too many disparate populations clustering in various parts of the country. If we were one homogenous population it might be different, but we aren't.

4
iconoclast63•

We are a constitutional republic. Legally that's the government we have. If it were a democracy then 50.1% could rule over the other 49.9% with no limits or accountability. That's why the founding fathers never intended for this country to be a democracy.

2
QuantumCactus11•

You do realise being a democracy and a Republic aren't mutually exclusive. Republic just means the people are represented by a nominated leader rather than a monarch. Democracy must mean people get to elected who they are represented by in fair elections.

Democracy didn't mean that the majority can do anything they want to the minority.

5
ml78779OP•

Oh ok, I see where we go on our separate ways. We are a constitutional republic true, but all that means is we elect officials to represent us. Instead of everyone voting for every law proposed, we elect people we think will do what is best for us. That doesn't mean we arent a democracy, it just means we arent a direct democracy. But we are absolutely still a democracy.

3
iconoclast63•

When Ben Franklin was asked, after the constitutional convention, by a woman what kind of government he had given us he famously replied,

"A republic madam, if you can keep it."

The difference in the words is important. A government doesn't need to be called a democracy to be representative of the people's wishes and allow for voting on representatives or individual issues. The primary difference in the U.S. is that the constitution is the law of the land and can only be amended by a super (66.01%) majority among both the members of congress and the separate states.

1
PlayingTheWrongGame51ƥ

??? Republics are a type of democracy where you elect representatives rather than voting directly on issues. Republics certainly could allow gross changes to the laws to pass with bare majorities--the US doesn't do that, but that's because of how its constitution is structured, not simply because it's a republic.

2
DraupnerWelle•

There are many labels that may be used to characterise a state. Many of them are not mutually exclusive!

Some labels are: direct democracy, representative democracy, constitutional democracy, constitutional republic, parliamentary republic, presidential republic, federal republic and theocratic republic.

The USA is a representative, constitutional democracy. But it is also a federal and constitutional republic. One does not exclude the other. Just like a fruit may be both sweet and yellow.

And by the way, saying its legally defined as one or the other is just dumb. Characteristics and labels aren't always distinct and clear cut defined.

1
TheWretched1•

And therein lies the rub. People have chosen to forget the facts in service to their emotions. We are a republic first and foremost and this republic is the only reason why our country had stood the test of time. We have reached an impasse in which the left believes they can do a better job than our forefathers and right will absolutely not compromise.

We have had generations after generations fight and die for the core tenants that built this country. You are simply kidding yourselves if you believe we are not willing to lay down our lives in an instant to defend it. If you need proof then look no further than the fact that the majority of ALL currently enlisted and historical veteran soldiers are republican.

This is who you are spitting on, this is who you are fighting.

-2
gagmaggot•

Libertarianism is a worthless joke of an ideology and if you still have the audacity to call yourself one in the modern era i suggest seeking therapy

1
iconoclast63•

I'm an independent with libertarian leanings. English isn't your first language?

5
gagmaggot•

People who have "libertarian leanings" are really just conservatives who hate gay people slightly less.

2
iconoclast63•

LMAO

Thanks for that.

2
TheDeathReaper97•

Libertarians believe in:

-Economic Freedom

-Pro-Gun and self-defense

-Right to privacy

-Free Speech

-Usually pro-Capitalism to varying degrees

-Non interventionism so no wars other than self-defense

-Free trade with everyone

-Pro immigration as long as the people prove they're there to work and will benefit the society

-Pro Nuclear energy but anti nuclear weaponry

-Lower taxes, as in, much much much lower taxes, and any remaining tax will be used effectively instead how it is now. Many are against Tax altogether

-Pro LGBTQ+, basically you do you as long as you don't hurt others, freedom includes freedom of sexuality

-Pro weed as it isn't harmful but decriminalization of harder drugs so users don't go to jail, they instead get help. Some are fine with all drugs being legal.

Very famously is the idea of "If it doesn't hurt anyone, then it's fine" which is expressed by many as the NAP or Non-aggression Principle. Where you should never initiate aggression against someone or their property, but if you are on the receiving end of violence or aggression, you can retaliate accordingly without going overboard.

So how the fuck is that similar at all to conservatives????

2
Hero17•

Left libertarian is good. Right wing libertarianism is a bad meme since it has a total blindspot towards business hierarchy.

2

What’s the tweet? “Libertarians are the kids who wanted to get rid of their parents so that they wouldn’t have to clean their room”

1
shotgun-wedding•

I think the entire political atmosphere is messed up and polarized these days, but you’re obviously watching too much CNN

8
ml78779OP•

Haha, yeah I primarily watch CNN, but not only. I do get my news from a wide array of news sources, granted mostly left-leaning, but I cannot find a center-right news source. Fox is far too extreme, and anything after that is just literal fake news.

2
shotgun-wedding•

I wouldn’t worry about the left losing power, they’ve created the narrative that all conservatives are racist, anti human rights, fascist etc. Biden and harris are making sure to let in plenty of illegal immigrants (blue voters) so secure the next election, if they flip texas its game over for conservatives, and look how much of a border texas shares with Mexico, every major corporation, university, mainstream entertainment network, pro sports league etc. is constantly pledging allegiance to the left, all advertisements are trying extra hard to be “woke”, look at commercials these days they’re like 60% black people

3
ml78779OP•

No, you see this is part of the problem. We are dealing in absolutes. I absolutely do not think all conservatives are racist fascist people. Not every Trump supporter or Republican is a racist, fascist, anti-human rights person, but damn near every racist, fascist, anti-human rights person is a Trump supporter/Republican. Plus there are very very few cases of fraudulent votes. Illegal immigrants arent voting and the elections are secure.

2
shotgun-wedding•

I think there’s plenty of liberals who are racist, in fact I think liberals if anything are more racist than conservatives in that they care way more about race than conservatives do, liberals are trying to get illegal immigrants to get voting rights because they want blue votes, and if anyone disagrees with them they’ll call them “racist”, I don’t understand the connection between conservatism and fascism, if anything it seems like liberals are the real “fascists” because they’re suppressing opposition to their ideas, censoring social media posts, disallowing conservatives from speaking at colleges to protect people against “violent speech” in favor of “human rights”, forcing people to hire a certain number of people of a certain race, trying to take 70% of a corporation’s profits

2†
foot_kisser23ƥ

Before I start, I want everyone to know I desperately want to be wrong.

The good news is that you are wrong (not about everything, but about a lot of things), but the bad news is you're not going to be emotionally happy about the ways in which you're wrong.

I honestly think Republicans are going to sweep into Congress in 2022

This I think you're right about. The Senate is exactly 50/50, and in the House, they only have 6 more people, last I looked. And, as you mentioned, the incumbent party usually loses seats in a midterm.

Additionally, Biden promised unity and is bringing division, Kamala is disliked even on the left, Trump's absence from the news is reducing the MSM's ability to propagandize, and there's a crisis at the border where their choices are basically either to let it fester or else to finish Trump's wall.

and then easily take back the White House in 2024

I certainly hope so, but it's way too early to make a call like that. Who would run is up in the air, who they'd run against is up in the air, the 2022 elections haven't happened yet, etc.

and subsequently pass laws to ensure they never lose power again.

Reading this was startling to me. This is precisely what the Democrats are currently trying to do with their attempts to rig SCOTUS, rig the Senate, rig elections, and take people's guns away.

Meanwhile, Republicans are doing none of these things. We are in favor of the Constitution, which doesn't allow that sort of thing, so it isn't the kind of thing we would want to do either.

They elected multiple violent conspiracy theorists into Congress

This is not true.

The article you link is propaganda. They are trying to use a narrative around "Qanon" to paint people they dislike as bad, much as they used to use the "alt-right".

There is a real Qanon, just like there's a real alt-right, but they are not as described in propaganda hitpieces like this.

Their strategy is two-pronged, just as it was when they were using the alt-right for the same purpose. First, demonize and amplify the group -- whether they're good or bad, make them appear worse than they are, and pretend they're much more common and accepted than they really are. Second, try to attach any politicians they dislike to the group they just demonized.

In the case of this article, they're claiming that Qanon is violent, which is false, and they're claiming more of a connection to the group than really exists. For example, they quote one of the 2 ladies they accuse of being part of Qanon as saying "I don’t follow QAnon", yet they try to get you to believe that she really does by shifting the goalposts from following Qanon (a nutty group of harmless conspiracy theorists) to thinking that the "Deep State" exists (a verifiable fact).

Qanon are right to be patriotic, and to think that the Deep State exists and hated President Trump, but they're wrong about nearly everything else. That they happen to be right about the Deep State doesn't tie her to them.

inspired and currently defend a terrorist attack on the capital to overturn a free election

This is clearly a propaganda narrative as well.

I'm not going to go through this one in detail, but I think that the reason you're worried in the way you're worried about the future of the country is largely because you're allowing this kind of propaganda narrative in, and you're treating it like it's true.

It might help to try to look at the details of this particular conspiracy theory being passed off as fact by the "news", but I would recommend even more strongly simply trying to exit your echo chamber. Maybe you're on twitter too much, or you listen to too much MSNBC or CNN. Maybe you need to take a break from news entirely (this can be very refreshing), or find people who disagree with you to talk to, so you aren't hearing only one side amplified in an echo chamber.

right-wing ‘news’ media propaganda,

You're not seeing the even more common and prevalent left-wing "news" propaganda. I'm not saying the right gets it right all the time, since we're subject to the same trends towards clickbait and echo chambers and doomsaying as everybody else. I'm saying that you need to look more critically at the "news" that caters to your particular biases.

It's not as easy to see through lies in "news" that coddles your preconceptions.

Republican majority states passing extreme voter suppression laws

That's just plain not true.

I would go over it in detail, but it's behind a paywall, so I can't see it. However, it was written by the NYT, which is almost enough to prove it's a pack of lies without looking at it.

promote political and race-related violence,

This one surprised me similarly to the way the "pass laws to ensure they never lose power again" one did.

This is a description of precisely what the left is doing right now, but it doesn't describe the right at all.

and are focused only on obstructing anything the Democrats do.

This is normal politics. Imagine Democrats had exactly half of the Senate, were only a few seats shy of holding the House, and there was a Republican President. Would they be obstructing to the maximum extent they could manage? Yep.

This is plain old-fashioned ordinary politics, not anything new or scary.

6

Your whole comment needs a big [citation needed]

2
foot_kisser23ƥ

This is not wikipedia.

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
herrsatanMOD5ƥ

u/AtenderhistoryinrusT – your comment has been removed for breaking Rule 2:

Don't be rude or hostile to other users. Your comment will be removed even if most of it is solid, another user was rude to you first, or you feel your remark was justified. Report other violations; do not retaliate. See the wiki page for more information.

If you would like to appeal, review our appeals process here, then message the moderators by clicking this link within one week of this notice being posted. Please note that multiple violations will lead to a ban, as explained in our moderation standards.

1
ml78779OP•

I respect your opinion. I understand we obviously come from very different sides. And while I wanted to go through where I thought you were wrong, I realized, I don't think either one of us is going to change our minds this way. I view what you see as propaganda and you see what I see as propaganda. So all I will say is that let's hope I am wrong, and let's hope America remains the world leader in all that is good!

0†

Classy

1
Tibaltdidnothinwrong333ƥ

Demographic shifts are in the Democrats favor.

The republican voter base is very strongly white. However, the proportion of the us which is white is steady declining. We will be a "majority-minority" nation in as little as two decades.

While this can be fought with gerrymandering and voter suppression, there is a limit.

4
ml78779OP•

Yeah, that's true. Let's hope we continue to become a more diverse nation.

3
Morthra43ƥ

However, the proportion of the us which is white is steady declining. We will be a "majority-minority" nation in as little as two decades.

The most likely outcome is actually that lighter skinned hispanics get lumped in with white people.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
ml78779OP•

Right, that's what I am hoping to hear lol, but I also would like to know where I am Iwrong? Where did I go wrong?

1
MINK_OIL_PASTE•

You might not be wrong, but as a republican I don't see how, or why this would happen. This is something that seems to be brought up every now and again and it always seems to be the same thing, Republicans wanting to demonize democrats, and democrats demonizing Republicans.

1
ml78779OP•

Yeah, I agree that something like this is definitely brought up, but I am worried that this time there is some merit to this concern. As to why this would happen, I would say because the majority of people in Congress right now don't actually care about seeing this country improve and progress, they only want power. Therefore, they will do everything they can to ensure they stay in power.

1
MINK_OIL_PASTE•

True, but congress is balanced, and it's been like that for as long as it's been around. Nothing to do with one particular party.

3
androidbear04•

I think they just differ on what they think would be improvement.

1
herrsatanMOD5ƥ

Sorry, u/MINK_OIL_PASTE – your comment has been removed for breaking Rule 5:

Comments must contribute meaningfully to the conversation. Comments that are only links, jokes or "written upvotes" will be removed. Humor and affirmations of agreement can be contained within more substantial comments. See the wiki page for more information.

If you would like to appeal, review our appeals process here, then message the moderators by clicking this link within one week of this notice being posted.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DeltaBotMOD∞∆•

u/ml78779 (OP) has awarded 1 delta(s) in this post.

All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in r/DeltaLog.

Please note that a change of view doesn't necessarily mean a reversal, or that the conversation has ended.

^Delta System Explained ^| ^Deltaboards

1
NotVeryCommunist•

I was able to vote for the first time in the 2020 election and happily voted for Joe Biden

I think that’s the issue with our democracy is people voting for two terrible candidates. But to your prediction, I don’t think you will have to worry since the republicans are going to loose eventually, we lost Georgia and while Georgia is not a blue state it will fall into the status of a blue state in a few years if the GOP doesn’t reform and Texas will probably fall as well. Just look at Virginia, it’s solid blue and it used to be solid red.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
ml78779OP•

Huh, I never heard of balkenization before, thanks ill look into that! Idk if I'd go so far to say the east and west coast are moving towards socialism, but definitely further left.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
ml78779OP•

I agree with everything you said about what California and New York are doing, but I wouldn't qualify that as socialism. Its just the state saying there are more things that are too important to leave up to the whims of the market. I'm incredibly lucky I'm from California and love the state. And I am glad as hell i don't live in the south. Without the rich leftist states subsidizing the poor right wing states, republican lead states would have the same quality of life as less developed countries. I also like the term white Christian fascism lol. It accurately describes so much of this country

1