What are your thoughts on the recent monster field guides in World and Rise?

MH Rise

I got into the series with MH3U on the 3ds back in 2013, and I fondly remember looking up the monsters on Wikipedia before a hunt to see what elements they use, and what they were weakest to. When MHW came out I was pleasantly surprised to see the addition of the monster field guide, as I no longer had to open a webpage to figure out how to best gear up for my next hunt and the fact that the research aspect I enjoyed was now a feature in the game itself. When I started playing I noticed that Rise also has a monster field guide, though they’ve shaken things up a bit with a more statistic oriented style. I’m curious to hear what everyone’s thoughts are on the new field guide, and where they hope future games in the series will go with it.

TLDR; MHW and Rise both contain a monster field guide. What are your thoughts on this relatively new addition to the games?

Posted Apr 22, 2021, 5:09 AM UTC

19
sir_nubby•

My ideal system would be something like Rise's field guide but with something closer to World's unlock system. I like the more specific info we get in Rise, but I feel that simply hunting the monster once is too little to unlock all of it.

7
Scribblord•

The rise one is amazing

I can finally get vital information without using the wiki

For mats and hit zones and all that

The one in mhw was so bad bc like some monsters had a 3* weakness to sth but using element against them was dogshit bc of the values that you only got from wiki

Also im so so glad we do t have to collect myriads of footprints anymore

4
Tiaran149​:Hunting_Horn:Unfortunately not Jack Black•

Especially since Rise offers a loot sheet as well, it made wiki sites almost completely redundant. I personally really like it, since i don't angrily look up again on google if another source proofes the wiki wrong when I didn't get that Rathalos Plate in 30 hunts... The hitzones are also very detailed, which is great.

3
nadalcameron•

It’s good. Anytime the game actually explains information you need instead of you having to use third party sites is good.

3
Reshkrom1153"Friendly" local idiot :Hammer:•

They need a mix of both. World's diagrams for part breaks and what drops where with Rise's percentages.

2
Babo__•

the only thing i dont like about rises system is it doesnt tell you what parts are actually breakable anymore for some reason. other than that tho its great

2
Ashencroix•

Pretty sure if you look into the details on the drops page, it'll tell you which parts to break to have a chance on the "part break" drop.

1
RelingeOP•

True, though I wish they would have built upon the monster diagram concept that world used, I was interested to see how it would translate with Rise’s art style

1
billabong1985​:Switch_Axe:•

I'm a big fan, I never used the field guide in World because I couldn't stand the text contrast of the field guide menus, I found it hard to read, and the layout just wasn't all that intuitive. I was kinda nervous coming to Rise day 1 as I'd gotten so used to having an app on hand to tell me monster weaknesses and knew this would take time to come out, but the new Hunters notes are so easy to use that it's made wiki's/apps almost redundant, I've only ever had to look up online where a few field materials are found that don't come from monsters

1