J.Crew Woodland jacket fit check - Regular v. Slim cut

I'm relatively short, 5'5 I have a short torso, though i'm average build for my height (125 pounds). The Small was simply too big for me so I bought the woodland jacket in X-Small Regular and X-Small Slim.

I'm having trouble deciding on which jacket I should keep. The slim cut is a bit tight in the chest area, but more flattering of my figure at the midsection, however the regular cut is more comfortable, less tight, but not as flattering.

Front, Regular Cut

Front, Slim Cut

Album link with side view and arms out (Top 3 photos are regular cut. Bottom 3 are slim cut.)

Any input is appreciated.