[Days Gone] The pacing in this game...
(sorry for this long post, I understand few people will get to the end. TLDR is that I think Days Gone is pretty great, but not without its share of issues. And I was a little miffed by the John Garvin/Dave Jaffe interview on top of that)
Hi everyone
I rarely post my thoughts on a game on here, this has to be the first time. For reference, I'm 3/4 done with the game - midway through 'crater lake' part - I'm running errands for the witch on the mountain.
I'm usually a fan of open-world games, and while I'm enjoying Days Gone, I'm also a little baffled at times. Something is just.. off, but I can't quite put my finger on it. So please don't downvote me blindly, but I would appreciate if someone has the clarity to put in words what I'm trying to explain below.
My thoughts so far
So first off, I think this game is a truly outstanding "time waster" meaning that if you have a lot of time on your hands, it's a great game. Truly beautiful world, good combat gameplay, etc.
But I feel myself log every day in this game, for 4-5 hours or more, and at this point I don't know if I'm playing it wrong, or what. Forget about getting "wowed" at every turn like God of War, my bar is not as high as that. But here it feels like story-wise, there is about 20 minutes of meaningful cutscenes so far in the 40 hours I've played. One major reviewer described it as 'a good B movie"
I don't know, the best way to describe it would be that if you took a good-but-not-great movie, with some drama, and you spread it over 50 hours with good-but-somewhat-samey gameplay in between. I feel like its just a little too much "work" to finish this game. Don't get me wrong. It doesn't really get old to shoot a shotgun in the zombie's faces. It just feels a little repetitive, while the story is not the most gripping.
Running out of missions (small annoyance)
Something else that irks me is that I am sometimes completely running out of missions. I mean my "questlines" screen is completely blank. I mean for an open world game, that's so odd. I sleep, I drive my bike around, and then one quest will popup. Then maybe another. But I find that the game drip-feeds quests is somehow too slow. (the way I play is that I clear the map of everything to do first (camps, markers, NERO outposts, etc. and THEN focus more on the quests. does that have anything to do with it?). There are other small bugs, but it's not too bad. You might have to restart the game a few times, to fix a quest, but nothing game-breaking.
"open world" but very directed quests
Another thing that I miss, is that in Fallout and several other games, you could complete a quest without necessarily having the game "allowing" you to complete it. You would find a thingamajig in a cave, and then the quest giver would ask you to find it, and you could immediately give it.
Here in days Gone, I am so often going back to the exact same house that I thoroughly looted 10 minutes ago, this time to grab yeast or polystyrene or some other thing. those times when you clear a camp, and then get a call that there are now outlaws in that very same camp. So I drive right back.. you get the point. I'd rather stumble around in the world, and be able to complete at least SOME missions without waiting for the game to "graciously" allow me to complete them. This might not work for ALL quests, but at least it would be nice if it worked for a few (especially in an 'open world' game.
"The interview"
This would have been all well and good, but I also got a little irked by the interview John Garvin (Days' Gone writer and creator gave on David Jaffe's podcast. Here are some random notes:
- first off, I was put off by how John 'playfully' teased David about not playing the full 50 hour campaign. Heck, I am taking a sabbatical these days, I have no obligations, no kids. Yet, I have to make sure I dutifully login every day into this game to make some progress, or I feel like I'll never see the ending. I feel like its just a little too much 'work' to get to the end. John seemed extremely pleased about the number '50 hours' of gameplay, but that's not how it works. The quality of the gameplay is not really the issue, I think my problem is the lack of meaningful plot twists.
- then, I feel like David tried to prod John on 'what could have been done better', hinting specifically at pacing. Instead, after talking about the bugs for a bit (which probably didn't help either). John went back to the previous conversation about 'SJWs' and all that bullcrap. Sure, it MIGHT have hurt the game some, but having playing the game myself I think its delusional to think that the game has no issues beyond that, which John's reply seemed to indicate. Not only that, but how can I trust John to improve this aspect in his next games if I can't be sure that he understood what could be improved in the first place?
- lastly, I wasn't too offended with the "buy at launch to get a sequel" remark. Mainly because I probably agree. But at the same time I'm thinking that I'm not sure I want to play 50 more hours of this in Days Gone 2. Especially, and this links to the point above, if I don't have the confidence that the developers truly understood where this game could be improved instead of blaming the SJW or external factors.
So I guess that's my reason for writing this post. When John says "buy the game at launch" I want to respond "then make a better game". I know its f*cking harsh, but that's the first thought that went to my head. Days Gone gets SO MUCH right, and it obviously managed to capture many people's hearts. But it looks like it wasn't enough for Sony.
In conclusion
I don't know where things went 'wrong', but in my opinion, I'd much rather a 15-hour game with a story that SLAPS, than 50 hours that drip-feeds me mild plot twists. Maybe the ending is incredible, but then again, the gamer have to get there in the first place (i.e.not give up before it gets good). Maybe the roles of writer and game director should've been separated. Maybe one of the regions should've been cutout and the budget/time used to iron out the bugs.
Those things are easy to diagnose after the fact though. I think Bend Studios did amazing work on Days Gone. Ultimately I hope a sequel gets made, and I hope John gets to do more games. I like his style overall and I think he's a good person and game designer.
Thank you for reading my disjointed essay. Will update in a few days after I finish the game.
Posted Apr 23, 2021, 10:41 PM UTC · edited
I feel like those first 20hs focusing mostly on Deacon and Boozer make them grow out of their surface appearence of generic biker dudes and make later moments like Boozer's suicidal stint hit harder than if the game was just 20hs long, and also the slow reveal of Deacon's relationship with his wife really makes a god job of getting slowly to emphatize with him.
I could get why the slow burn story isn't for everyone though. And yeah the first 20hs of gameplay are rough, you can't even safely take on even small hordes.
Is there a way to see how much time Ive played? It feels a lot closer to 40 but I don't want to start throwing out accusations.