On company time, My Participant opened my car door while parked, and hit another parked car. The company wants me to pay for it out of my pocket. Are they in the right here? (More info inside)

I work with kids with developmental disabilities and I often take them out on activities around the community. I was on company time and I use my car, that is insured, to take them around. Earlier today we were going to the store and after we were parked in a stall, the participant openend the door a little to hard. He dented the door of the car next to us.

The company wants me to pay out of my own pocket to fix it. They haven't explained this is me or any of my other co-workers before. It isn't in the contract we signed when we agreed to the job either. It also doesn't say anywhere that they will pay for it. Is there anything I can do here? Is this how things normally are?

Thanks Reddit!

Posted Dec 2, 2011, 8:42 AM UTC

413
[deleted]•

I would think that his parents or legal guardians are financially responsible for his actions.

2
itzBasicsOP•

That's what I thought as well, but wouldn't the parents feel the same way because they are giving their kids to a organization who is responsible for them? Why should they have to pay when the company is responsible for them?

(Thanks for input, just playing devils advocate here.)

1
[deleted]•

Just because my kid goes to school/daycare/camp/after-school-programs doesn't absolve me of my parental responsibilities.

But that's just my opinion. If my kid did it, I'd pay to get it fixed.

And they're probably legally obligated to. Tell your insurance that you need their help in getting the contact information of his parents from your employer.

3
itzBasicsOP•

IC. Thanks for the reply.

1
youarecaught•

Are you required as part of your job to use your personal vehicle to transport these kids or is it something you do as an "above and beyond" type of thing? if it is a requirement then you have a case for reimbursement. If your company still refuses to pay you could take them to small claims court. You will of course lose your job, but you will save that few hundred dollars for the dent.

Or you could just suck it up, file an insurance claim and stop driving the kids around.

2
itzBasicsOP•

Yes, it is required in order to have the job. This is the answer I was expecting. Thanks for your input!

1
adam_anarchist•

okay...your language is kinda creepy

-3
RobertPaulsen•

stop using the word participant

it makes you sound guilty

-5
itzBasicsOP•

Participant is what they call the people who partake in the Organization's Care programs. It's not as you are interpreting it.

2
RobertPaulsen•

...how are you assuming I interpreted it?

-4
itzBasicsOP•

I don't understand how the word participant makes me sound guilty if its what they call the people who partake in the program. I assumed you meant like my partner in crime.

Thanks for replying btw.

2
RobertPaulsen•

it sounds like you are trying to cast blame onto a sub human creature

-2