r/PhD•
Note4forever

YSK How to ensure papers you are citing have not been retracted

Dissertation

In certain fields citing retracted papers can make you look bad assuming you are not citing on purpose of course.

While often not fatal, it might be a good idea to avoid doing so particularly when submitting to journals given that some journals are starting to deploy systems to automatically check for this and more.

To reduce the chance of this happening you can do any of the following

  1. Use Zotero as a reference manager - Zotero provides two levels of warning, firstly when you first import a paper into your library it will warn you if the paper has been retracted using data from the Retraction Watch database. Secondly it will warn you also when you try to cite a retracted paper using the word plugin. (Other reference managers might do this as well)
  2. Run your manuscript prior to submission to either the scite reference checker or Scholarcy preprint healthcheck API - In particular the first one might be worth using because they are deploying scite technology on popular manuscript systems like ScholarOne, Manuscript Manager.
  3. Other things you can try doing is to use extensions to query Pubpeer (mostly STEM), particularly the Zotero one to see what comments others have left about the paper you are thinking of citing.

There are other tools and systems that are starting to do such autochecks and journals are starting to employ them, so it might be a good idea to do them on your end as well.

Good Luck!

​

Articles for more background

Checking for retractions & other quality checks on your manuscript before journal submissions — some free tools scite , Zotero, Pubpeer, Scholarcy and more

Understanding the current state of retractions & what you can do about it as an author to avoid citing them in papers

Posted Apr 24, 2021, 4:29 PM UTC

80

No comments yet

Nobody commented on this post, or the comments weren't captured.