UC Davis Pepper Spray Indecent, Now with more footage
Posted Dec 3, 2011, 1:23 PM UTC
Posted Dec 3, 2011, 1:23 PM UTC
File under "apologist arguments for a repressive authoritarian society".
Miranda Rights? Didn't hear those in the warning. I'm not saying either side is right either. And such close proximity to use that strength of pepper spray is still excessive. The cop car is also being driven on a sidewalk, were they planning on running the students over? Didn't the cops think, "Man, I could easily just... You know, step over the protestor, or walk through the grass... Guess I should just use force to use the sidewalk." The cops may have been fearing for their lives, or that may be the excuse... But what about the students that are now not even 10 ft away from a recently approaching cop car, and have armed cops at their back. Who's to say if the students decided to break up the line, the cops wouldn't panic thinking the students would then attack the cops? There are too many factors to consider. Both sides were wrong.
One was doing their jobs, their sworn duty. The other were impeding them from doing their jobs, and acting "illegally".
I do wanna know what peoples thoughts on this are. I still doubt the cops had any reason to feel they were in any real danger. No need to use force like that on them.
I for one, find it amazing how much different this scene looks when seeing more of the footage. While I still do not fully endorse the use of pepper spray, it seems like they were left with very few other options.
The way I see it, at the point where the pepper spray was used they have a few options
They likely should have tried just moving the people and saying that if they didn't cooperate when moving they would be arrested. However due to the number of students versus the number of police, and students acting as if they had control of the situation, I believe that pepper spray was at least needed on the scene in case things got out of hand and the students started acting physically violent towards the police officers.
With the amount of warnings given out though, I believe the better thing to have done would have been for the students to disperse with the warnings and come back or go somewhere where they would be legally permitted to assemble.
[deleted]
[deleted]
The whole idea of an "unlawful assembly" when peacefully protesting is ridiculous. It's the law and those officers enforcing it that is unjust. But we all know that the law isn't really about justice anyway.
With the protesters linking arms though, it makes your first two options, either exceptionally difficult and dangerous. Leaving, means there is no law, so that leaves the spray. or more aggressive actions.
As an aside, isn't this a fantastic example of how the lie has made its way around the world, before the truth has gotten out of bed?
You didn't see Sgt. Pepper joking with them, patting them on the back and stepping over them? Yeah, a lie that went around the world; that sounds legit. How can you type through the socks?
I think it's good to see both sides of a story. People often preach no censorship only when it suits them.
Too bad reddit isn't going to let people see this
Showing the whole scenario with biased captions, presenting it in the most favorable light possible for the campus cops -- turns out to even more compellingly demonstrate the campus cops mishandled their departure repeatedly, at multiple decision points, and that the pepper spray was even less warranted than thought.
I was struck with a sense of the students' courage and bravery standing up peaceably for what they believe in, on their own home turf, in the face of overwhelming authority swaggeringly exhibiting its symbols of violence.
And as has been pointed out before, the cops repeatedly escalated where uncalled for, appealing to bullying brute force of physical or legal threat; instead of just leaving when they could, waiting peacefully, de-escalating into non-threatening stances, or even just stepping over the line as the pepper spraying cop easily did once he wanted to (in order to spray instead of leave). Driving the car onto the walk was a particularly stupid escalation.
They were campus police. They work for the students.
The people are the authority. Keep that in perspective.
I think it's good to see a 12 day redditor lecture this often trolled sub on "both" sides of the story that narrates continued chanting by protesters as "attempting to shout the police down" apparently aggression justifying the spraying. The only question left after this slimy excuse is whether the Kochs pay medical benefits?
Hey look, a three-year redditor babbling about something incoherent.
Oh boy, an 8 day redditor with a proformed opinion, how quaint. Vote each other up boys. Have fun, hope you get paid by the snark.
True, but for clarification, doesn't this footage demonstrate that it was those people posting the cropped video in order to mislead and anger people - it was them, that is/was doing the censoring.