Student-led group sells NFTs of Trump tweets for charity
thehill.com/policy/technology/551003-student-...Posted Apr 29, 2021, 8:21 PM UTC
Posted Apr 29, 2021, 8:21 PM UTC
Are people still talking about Trump?
He’s still living rent free.
It's luckily the first time I've heard of him in at least a month, and the context is acceptable
Unfortunately, this looks like an entirely meaningless use of NFTs.
Ah, the irony
Whats the fe in here?
I don’t understand what gives these particular people the right to sell someone else’s tweets? Like why don’t I go sell Lebron’s tweets if I feel like it?
Generally, works by the US Government aren't subject to copyright. The former administration considered his tweets to be official US government statements. The guy who made a lot of money firing people on TV, for example, also fired US government officials on twitter, and thus his tweets aren't given copyright protection.
I love that
So wait, anyone can sell anyone’s tweets now?
[deleted]
My only question is that how they can have ANY kind of copyright, aka right to copy, to copy and sell those tweets?
..use trupmps photo in the tweet image
and use twitter gui elements in the screenshot
They owe nothing of those, so how they can sell it ?
Ew, taking tweets from someone else and selling them "for charity". Pathetic. "Hate" Trump as much as the next person but honestly this is a blatant attempt at cash grab
Thank you for your submission on r/NFT, join us on Discord for live discussion on everything NFTs, and to share & buy/sell your NFTs!
#[Join r/NFT Discord](https://discord.gg/CYKH7UXFFE)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
This link has been shared 1 time.
First Seen Here on 2021-04-29.
Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot -
Scope: Reddit | Check Title: False | Max Age: 99999 | Searched Links: 99,697,493 | Search Time: 0.0s
This makes no sense... They're worthless. It's like selling a copy of a picture of the Mona Lisa... I don't get it.
Does no one remember the man who made a gallery of other people’s instagram posts where he added a comment below to make it his? They each legally sold for hundreds of thousands of dollars. A workaround isn’t very difficult to figure out to make someone else’s intellectual property yours.
Where can i read that article?
I guess you can sell Trumpers anything...
That’s some badass sh*t
Horrible. Do not give the asshole anymore unnecessary attention.
Does the fact that anyone can tokenize them not undermine the whole thing? I'd pay good money if trump minted them himself but this is dumb
That's one of the problems I still have with NFTs, they would probably lose a lawsuit if such was filed...
Taking ownership of someone else’s social media activity and monetizing it seems like it would cost someone more than it would initially pay for them. Who wants to feel this possibility looming over them anyways?
Anything a president says or is filmed saying is considered in the public domain, so wouldn't be copywritten. But i'm not a lawyer, so not sure if this is true with what they are doing.
Is there an argument that it's posted on Twitter and so they own the content (evidenced by the fact they have rights to delete it)? I mean especially if they're marketing it as "tweets" rather than purely the text copy.
Well, Twitter doesn't have the right to remove "tweets" from other platforms (screenshots, for example) so i wonder how any of that would be enforced
It's not that difficult to enforce especially since the creators are tied to the NFT. Centralised NFT platforms have already been deleting IP infringement NFT from their front ends and chain analysis would mean lawyers know exactly how much they sold (if it's an issue using Twitter related branding / trademark in an NFT).
Generally speaking, you give platforms a non-revocable, royalty-free right to display your content but they do not have a copyright to it. For example, the Reddit User Agreement says:
The Trump Administration, however, claimed that his tweets were official proclamations of the POTUS, meaning they weren't subject to copyright (at least while he was POTUS). His account was shut down before his term ended for inciting a mob to overthrow the government, but everything from Jan 20, 2017 (if not since his election) until twitter shut it down would be fair game.
Then what stops multiple NFTs for the same tweet? Creation date of the first? Doesn’t that just create a race to generate as many NFTs as possible and saturate any possible market?
Is it even legal to mint another person's tweet? I've never really understood this part
Sauce