Ask netsec: what are you experiences reporting vulnerabilities to software companies?
I've reported a handful of vulnerabilities over the years, but they've been mostly one off experiences. I was hoping other people could share their experiences in order to provide a better picture of what it's like dealing with different companies. I guess I'll start.
-
Various open source software: Mixed bag. Usually the more active the project, the better the response. Worst case if I get no response I'm able to create a ticket in their bug tracker or sometimes submit a patch, and if nothing happens...so be it, the information is out there.
-
Microsoft: Only worked with them a couple of times. I understand they want to thoroughly test fixes before releasing them, look for other similar vulnerabilities, etc., but I was still pretty irked that it took over a year (both times) to fix a relatively garden variety vulnerability. Other than that, didn't mind working with them.
-
HP: Worked with them a few times. The experience has always been horrible. Very poor communication, it makes me want to never report anything to them again.
-
Adobe: Worked with them once, communication was very good, but again, a little upset that it took about a year to fix a garden variety vulnerability.
-
Cisco: Worked with them once. Very good communication. A couple times they contacted me proactively to give updates. And the vulnerability was fixed relatively quickly. Out of all the companies I've worked with, they're the only ones that I'd share my research with in the future without any hesitation.
-
Symantec: Tried reporting a vulnerability to them once. Absolutely no response. Tried contacting them multiple times. Still no response. The only company that I'm sure to go the full disclosure route with in the future. Though HP is pretty darn close to falling in that category too.
I guess another thing I should add - all of these companies have [email protected] addresses and PGP keys, so they at least have the appearance of wanting to work with researchers.
Posted Dec 6, 2011, 8:08 PM UTC · edited