How does Legion healing actually work?

Discussion

Edit: Tried to copy someone's name and lost my original edit. So I'm not going to try that again for now. The comments have several people who suggested/stated what I am about to say, so all credit to them. All I did was test this again.

​

So, from what we can tell Legionaire's passive as written is innacurate.

​

"On spell cast, the next attack heals for 50% of damage dealt"

​

This is proveably inaccurate, as many have pointed out, Aatrox and Kallista trigger this on their abilities. Why might this be?

​

They are the only legionaire's with physical abilities. The rest are hybrid or do not have damaging abilities. Yasou is magical/true damage, Riven is magical into a damage steriod, Mord is onhit magical, Draven is a auto modifier, Kayle doesn't have an active abilitity and even if she did, is mostly magic/true damage.

So, why is it more noticeable on Aatrox, Draven and Kallista? Because they have the only physical abilities in the group. I tested this and yasou and Riven heal small amounts on cast after autoing. Mord I couldn't confirm but I never noticed it before so I assume its the same. Not sure how I missed it if it is true the first time. And it isn't healing based on the attack but instead, it should be written:

"After casting their spell, heal for 50% of the next physical damage dealt by the champion"

​

Or something to that effect.

​

This brings up several problems however, due to the mix damage nature of the units. Most of them get no value off this, and according to a commenter(look below), mort confirmed it doesn't work for Kayle at all.

​

So the legionaires are not balanced around half of the text, but just around the aspd portion.

​

Two things I want:

​

  1. fix the wording to actually match the effect(same for BT)

​

  1. Rework the trait/characters to actually synergize with their own trait outside of the aspd.

​

----------------------------------------------------------

So I've been trying to figure this out for a while to no avail. So I hope someone can clarify

​

Legionaire has two parts to my understanding, the aspd, then this effect:

" their first attack after casting a spell heals them for 50% of the damage dealt. "

Now, my understanding is that attack was dubbed down to mean basic/auto attack at this point. So the way this reads "After mordekaiser uses his ability, his next auto heals him for 50% of the damage it dealt". This would be like a sheen proc in league.

​

Now, for my test case, I gave mord ionic dark spark, redeemer trait, and I think it was archangels staff. So he was one shotting most characters with his ability empowered auto attacks at level 2. Legionaire bonus was at a 4 stack

Now, I've tested this and watched mord, and he never heals like that, or at all from what I can tell.

​

Similarly, how would this even work with Kayle, or riven? For Riven this effect would be kinda awful since she can't use her ability more then once every 8 seconds(being generous, more like 11 with mana regen).

​

I get the aspd is a massive, arguably larger part of this trait. But as far as I can tell, this healing chunk -doesn't even work- except on one case which is Kallista. I think it may also work on draven but I almost always have him with BT so that one is a bit harder to confirm. She is the only one I've noticed this healing on, but its not on her basic attack, but the ability itself. Aatrox may also be getting that but I haven't tried to do the math of if he is healing more then just from the ability affect itself. When I give someone the legionaire trait I also do not notice any healing mechanic granted.

​

So, can anyone explain the actual mechanics of this passive for legionaires, and how it even interacts with Kayle who doesn't have an active ability(I assume its everytime she upgrades, but if that is the case she would just stop getting it after the final one which is weird).

Posted May 3, 2021, 5:13 PM UTC · edited

8627
KryptonianThanos•

Upvoted just in hopes more people see this post. I've noticed this happening as well and haven't been able to pinpoint what's happening. However, like you, I've only seen the heal proc off of kalistas ability, not the next attack :/

35
wwwwwwhitey:Runespirit:•

Not 100 % sure on this but like 95 % : Legionnaires only heal from the physical damage they deal, because all physical damage is treated as an auto attack. So Morde doesn’t heal on the on hit from his spell, and Kalista heals from her spell because it is treated like an auto. In the same way if you put BT on Sett he’s gonna heal when he casts

7
KryptonianThanos•

This makes a lot of sense overall, with a few curious exceptions (unless I'm tired and am blanking on an obvious answer). Does the heal overlap with the Aatrox heal? Shouldn't mordekaiser still heal from his basic after his spell even if not healing from the hit with the spell (example once his shield drops, the next basic should heal, no?) And then there's kayle... Her abilities are also more auto attacks likr kalista, so when would hers proc??

Just thinking out loud here, not expecting you to have all the answers :D (if you DO have all the answers.... Ma boii)

3
wirebearOP•

I hadn't considered the "sheen proc" might be after Mord's shield wore off, I'll have to check that. Good idea there. I was thinking it would be after the cast since Aatrox and Kallista seem to proc there's with the ability itself, so I'll have to take a look at that to see.

​

Thanks for an interesting angle.

2
wirebearOP•

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought BT heals for all damage on an auto, where as dark BT heals for all physical damage. Least that is the wording it uses. BT says "heals for % of attack" dark bt says "heals % for physical damage dealt".

​

I also tested this and mord didn't heal "a small amount" but wasn't healing at all. Possible I missed it but I was just staring at his lifebar during the matches.

​

Edit, it also doesn't make sense to balance it like that when most late game legionares all are not built around physical damage other then Riven. draven. Kayle, mord, and yasou all deal magic/true damage more then physical.

​

This isn't saying you are wrong, but its a very bizarre balancing choice if it is

-1
Andreiyutzzzz:Molediver:•

It's true bt doesn't specify physical while riskthirster does but Im not sure if that's just a wording problem

1
wirebearOP•

I thought that was suppose to be the difference between the two but I could be wrong. It does feel like a lot of these are a bit more unclear then they should be.

1
wirebearOP•

May be a bug honestly but I can't imagine we are the only ones who noticed this if so. It's a fairly important part of the trait description afterall. And honestly if it worked as described I would imagine Legion being busted af with Mord healing his healthbar with one auto after his ability trigger.

2
KryptonianThanos•

Agreed. This needs to be addressed, because even if the reason behind it is all technical (such as the answer below my initial comment) it's still an entire aspect of a traits function that is then exclusively for 1 of the members of said trait. Would definitely need some sort of adjustment

1
azarice•

I believe it heals on the attack damage part, and not the spell part. In morde's case, he shouls be healing a tiny amount off of the AD part of his attack after he casts, but not off of his onhit ability damage, which is AP.

This means if you put BT on him, he wouldn't be healing much, but if you put a gunblade on him, he would.

I have absolutely no idea what the healing is on kayle, I would assume non-existent since she doesn't cast.

8
Carryusdarius:Furyhorn:•

I believe you are accurate re: Mordekaiser.

Kayle as well, but at least in her case - I believe Mort said on his weekend stream (Saturday?) that it’s true Kayle does not use Legionnaire very well, and they agree it’s a problem.

Another legionnaire thing is that he acknowledged that you cannot make Riven carry, and they are aware of this and presumably will adjust her or the trait to fix it.

2
wirebearOP•

So, I looked for this cause I had this theory too. (like it was based on temporary dark BT logic), but mord doesn't heal small amounts, he just doesn't heal at all. I was just sitting there watching him for the entire match multiple times and never saw his health bar go up.

​

Is it possible I missed it? Sure, I plan to test more. But I noticed this behavior on both him and Yasou. And I want to also point out, having it heal on just physical damage, while more balanced, doesn't make sense when half of Kayle is true, and a third of yasou is magic, a third is true and almost all of mord is magic.

​

Edit: Also of note. This would not match the wording of the effect whatsoever. So even if it is true, the wording needs to be completely changed to something like "After casting a spell, the next time the character would deal physical damage, heal for 50% of it"

1
azarice•

watch the mordekaiser: https://youtu.be/tTCCpXwcDao?t=470 It shows him healing +78.

In TFT, all physical damage is considered attacks, and all magic damage is considered spells. Physical damage abilities will heal off of lifesteal, magic damage "attacks" will heal off of spellvamp.

For example, tryndameres SPIN ability last set dealt physical damage, and healed off of slayers lifesteal. If you build a BT on kalista without legionnaire this set, she would still heal off of her spear.

For Kayle and mordekaiser, if their onhit was considered an attack, then it would heal off of BT only, and not gunblade, which I would argue does not make sense.

The wording of legionnaire essentially says +50% lifesteal for 1 attack after casting. All interactions fall inline with that.

1
TheSentinelsSorrow•

Thanks this actually cleared it up pretty well for me

1
IAmBanEvading•

Since BT and IE got changed to work for all physical damage, I'd guess that the "attack" part of the Legionnaire trait is just the next instance of physical damage they deal after the cast, so Kalista casts her skill, throws the spear and heals on the first enemy it hits.

That's my guess.

Edit: nevermind just got into a match and checked with an Aatrox, he heals for 300 when he does the stab, then heals on the next autoattack after that, idfk anymore, considering that BT reads "autoattack" instead of just "attack"

Edit edit: alright I made a Jax into a Legionnaire and he just... healed from the damage of the Leap Strike, I seriously have no idea how this thing works.

2
wirebearOP•

So testing it using Riven and Yasou as test cases(Mord got stun locked when I checked him so I couldn't confirm for him) it looks like Legionaire is not "next attack"

but

"Next time the character would deal physical damage". So this portion of the Legionaire passive is somewhat useless for mord/Yasou/Kayle. I found small instances of very minor heals on riven and yasou after they used their abilities.

But Kallista definitely heals on her ability. If Aatrox is healing at both points I don't know what is causing that.

1
azarice•

Interactions are split by physical and magic damage, not by autoattack and ability.

Ex riven and kalista with a BT will heal off their cast even without legionnaire.

So both you and the wording are correct. In TFT, the legionnaire text "first attack after casting a spell" means the same thing as "Next time the character would deal physical damage".

1
wirebearOP•

This is disengious and not respecting the wording of the items at all.

​

BT explicitly says "Basic attacks". Hextech explicitly says "magic or true damage from ability". To argue that it is correct that BT heals off of Kallista's/Aatrox's ability with an item that explicitly says "basic attack" or Riven's (which is magic and there is no way this is accurate unless you mean the bonus damage from the steroid portion), is a clear fallacy.

​

guinsoo's and dark static shiv(but normal static shiv has basic in it. Same scenario for Ruinanns) effect also just says "Attacks..." So does this mean all abilities stack guinsoos? Is it just the ones that are pure physical damage like Aatrox/Kallista? What goes under this category? I would assume that physical abilities don't trigger auto attack focused items like Ruinnans and static shiv personally cause that is logical. Yet they only say attack, not basic attack. Dark Titanic Hydra also just has "attack" but that one isn't as noteable to me.

​

I would give you legionaire even if that wording would imply auto attack(technically doesn't say basic attack), considering that lifesteal(slayer from last set) just said lifesteal and interacted the way way you described(not equivalent to the current items as none of them use lifesteal as a keyword, to reference your other post since I don't want to respond to both).

​

Dark BT says "physical damage" which is what you are describing.

​

Hextech(both, versions say "magical and true damage from abilities") and DBT(physical damage) are clear on what they do. Legionaire and BT are not. (The way BT is worded I would assume on hit applies BT heal because that is how it works in league which this game is based off of and a lot of their player base comes from there.

​

Because a game should be readable without google or an wiki to know the most basic of interactions that are contrary to its own writing.

1
azarice•

"So, can anyone explain the actual mechanics of this passive for legionaires, and how it even interacts with Kayle who doesn't have an active ability(I assume its everytime she upgrades, but if that is the case she would just stop getting it after the final one which is weird)."

I believe my response that legionnaire functions as 50% healing on next instance of physical damage answers this fully. This is likely how it is coded, and is what riot intended to refer to by "attack". There is no bug.

That being said, I agree with you the wording is misleading and unintuitive. The single term "Attack" is used for two different meanings: a shorthand term for basic attack (compare the description of regular shiv to shadow shiv), and physical damage. This is obviously incorrect. Furthermore, BT specifically says healing on basic attack (while I'm fairly sure its all physical damage), while Shadow BT says all physical damage.

1
wirebearOP•

edited original post with second round of testing at the top based on discussion in this thread. I had issues linking people's names and lost the post the first time so apologies for not giving direct credit to people.

1
azarice•

TFT treats all instances of physical damage as attacks, and all instances of magic damage as spells. This means physical damage abilities apply lifesteal, and magic damage onhits apply spellvamp.

The wording of Legionnaire, saying next attack, has the same meaning as next instance of physical damage. So Legionnaire's interaction is +50% lifesteal for the first instance of physical damage after casting. It is not bugged. This is why riven heals off of the stun, kalista heals off of her spear, and tryndamere healed off of his spin with slayers last set.

The wording is definitely not clear, but it is not bugged. Physical damage abilities have counted as "attacks" for multiple sets now.

1
Dr_Mr_G•

It only heals for kalista, aatrox, and because their ulty is onhit, so its counts as basis attack, its the same mechanic since set 1. What you even complain about?

0
52-75-73-74-79•

Aatrox’ ability heals him, if you look closely, you will see an additional heal on his next auto

Kalistas “spell” heals her because her spell is treated as an auto attack

0
Mael_Jade•

Would you like some Carbonara to your Spaghetti, fine Sir?

​

Seriously nobody know and it probs work different for every single unit

-2
wirebearOP•

I mean, it has a fairly literal wording so it would be really odd if it had different rules for each. More so since I've never seen mord proc it.

​

But overall I agree with your sentiment. This is very blatantly a bug it feels like that could not have been missed with proper QA testing if it is mean to work as written.

3