r/wow•
HatynSec

M+ Routes, is this fun?

Question

Looking to get in to PvE again, as i've completely ignored it in favor of PvP so far. That said.. From what I remember of 8.3, and doing up to 17s, no one mentioned routes. Granted I am a zugzug, but I genuinely cannot recall it being mentioned at that level.

Do people considering optimal routes fun? At what point are routes necessary? Do you, as a tank, like looking at a website and plotting pulls, and additionally having them change somewhat drastically based on affixes? Is this exclusively a tank issue?

If i intend to do these as a dps, i should feel obligated to also know the routes right? Does it give you a sense of joy when a tank says they're going route C, and you know what exactly that entails? What would you say the cut-off is between casual M+ and... not casual M+?

Posted May 4, 2021, 4:36 PM UTC · edited

017
DaenerysMomODragons:alliance::deathknight: •

Routes were absolutely a thing in 8.3, it was just less obvious when a route was messed up. In 8.3 a messed up route may mean you ended up at 105% trash instead of 100%, and the key took slightly longer. In 9.0 a messed up route will mean pridefull spawning one trash pack earlier, not having it available on the boss, or even worse spawning mid trash and resulting in a wipe.

13
cybishop3•

The higher the key you're doing, the more it matters to follow an exact route. Hard to put a number on where the cutoff is, it depends on gear, affixes, etc. IMO 17s are high enough that the tank should know about it, though.

I don't tank myself and don't know the routes, I just follow their lead. Even if I felt like routes weren't required, I'd still want to have these cutoffs memorized or be capable of looking them up easily during the run.

8
Snowpoint_wow:druid: •

There is a good weakaura that tracks trash % in those dungeons in terms of how much you have left to the cutoff. I can't recall the exact name at the moment (not at my gaming PC).

2
MoG_Varos:alliance::warrior: •

I would say past a +12 you should know the routes for dungeons. It’s only going to be better for you as a dps to know when big pulls are coming, when you need in is pots, when prideful is coming.

Running an optimized route feels great tbh, prideful comes out smooth and dps don’t waste cooldowns.

I would say they’ve always been a thing but as a dps most people don’t expect you to know them, only follow the tank. But as I said it is better if you know them since everyone in the group should be helping.

2
PPKAP•

It's really not so bad. Usually if the tank is doing an atypical route they'll post it using MDT, note any skips and then people spend 20 seconds looking at it so they don't get caught unaware.

Beyond that, the group has to figure out how to correct for errors during the run and adjust. Most of it is, as other people said, pride timing.

Below 10 and routes basically dont matter, though some folks like to practice them so they're ready for higher keys. Past that and routes basically only matter so your prides aren't totally fucked. Eventually you'll need pretty optimized routes if you want to progress.

2
Geodude07:alliance::monk: •

Is it fun?

I don't think so. I would say it's awful gameplay for one main reason. It's meta nonsense to memorize and not a display of pve skill.

This is from someone who has loved tanking since MoP. I feel like they have diluted the meaning of being a tank for a long while, slowly giving our power to survive away. Which I get to an extent, but it means our pve skill feels like it barely matters.

I felt awesome doing Challenge mode gold in MoP. The mage tower was incredible and I did it the second time it was available in Legion as a brewmaster. I never felt sick of Legion M+, though the last few dungeons were a bit 'eh'. I say this all to say that I have tanked difficult content and generally enjoy it.

The extreme focus on overtuned bosses (evident by numerous nerfs so it's) the way keys are dead on certain affixes and the gross focus on our gameplay just being "learn some route and hope no one messes it up" just sucks.

I never feel cool for doing a route. I never feel like I can show off my skill. I just feel like i'm a caterer who lets the dps have fun. I wish they would give us more power to manage mobs or to show some skill.

2
bobbis91:alliance::druid: •

As a tank, I do actually enjoy playing with MDT to look at different routes and plans to pull things, just to spice it up a little whilst getting things in the right place.

Actually running those routes though in pugs is impossible since you take 1 step wrong and they moan or ass pull something (or intentionally). This is in 14/15's which is gradually getting harder imo as a non pusher.

2
Scribblord•

We really only have one route for tyrannical and one for the other

Tho you can use one for all

It’s so you kill as few mobs as possible and to spawn pride where it needs to be

It’s really just so the tank knows what gets killed bc if he doesn’t the run is fucked most of the time

Id say you always need some idea of what route one would take

And specific routes are really great for 12 and higher

1
IssaMightyRoach:horde: •

Not only man, in higher keys routes are especially important so you know how to manage your cooldowns. While it is especially true for the tank it is for everyone. For exemple a mage won’t use combust because on the very next pack tank will pull a massive pack you wanna make sure to melt it.

1
Alive_Assumption_657:horde::druid: •

Tanks should know the routes. It becomes good to know what mobs to pull so you arnt wasting time pulling things you dont need to pull.

It is also important because of Prideful timing. You typically want it right before a boss so pulling too much and getting prideful too early can really hurt during Tyrannical weeks

1
mael0004:horde::druid: •

At higher level everyone need to know the route so they can plan ahead which packs they'll use which cooldowns. I'd say ~20 is the level where this starts to be relevant. The higher you go, more you need to coordinate on everything. It's not just you personally choosing what to use, but know that everybody's dmg cooldowns aren't stacked on same packs. You know the circumstance in HOA where the first lust pack dies in 30s, but next pack that is smaller takes 4x the time? That's what you can't have happen in a timed +22.

Tank always knows route but he doesn't always mention it. I do remember in bfa doing up to +22 keys and linking route was something that was asked occasionally. It's mostly key holder wanting to check the tank isn't clueless as they have the most to lose if shit goes sideways.

1
Stemms123•

Because of prideful the need for routes and sticking to a route 100% became the major factor for success. The mechanics and affixes are all pretty easy as well as a very forgiving timer in terms of dps requirements up until extremely high keys.

Is it fun? No it’s miserable. Especially if you try to pug with people.

Do tanks like it? None of my friends who tank do. One of which has exclusively tanked and played every tank classes every xpac since BC. This is a guy who was born to tank timed content. We achieved multiple realm best times previously in other xpacs when the game was more fun.

As a dps it helps to learn them so you know the best time for your cds, defensive and offensive. Also when you need to invis skip.

Unfortunately a large percentage of runs end quickly because someone butt pulls a mob or a minor disagreement over route lead to half the group raging and leaving almost immediately. Not the kind of mistakes or issues that should lead to a failed run. Pulling extra mobs is it’s own punishment via the timer. This just breeds a toxic environment.

1
xMagnusx42•

Id say 10+ since you have all the affixes which requires pride timing an more skill/teamwork. Is it fun no not in the current affixes that hate anyone in melee when you don't have the ideal group for it making it harder to the point its not fun a chore you suffer through for vault. Speaking as a casual mythic plus runner prot pally.

1
Archeonn•

It's pretty exhausting as a tank. You're expected to know all the routes, when/what to pull, how to fix the route if someone butt pulls, how to adjust the pulls for the different affixes (inspiring, bursting, etc). Constant pressure that if you pull too small then it might not time, pull too big and it's a wipe.

On top of that, the optimum routes change based on the key level. 10-15 you have a route (less skips, less complication for pugs). 15-18 have routes easier packs or skips, pull two packs together in certain places. Then beyond that I haven't done, but from my understanding you start to pull multiple packs together consistently.

Doing 17s now and getting real sick of tanking without a full 5 man group willing to practice routes and deal with mistakes. When a DPS screws up, usually they'll just die and it's still salvageable. When a tank screws up, it's a wipe and key is done.

As a DPS , it will help your tank so much if you even roughly know the routes. When to save your slows, roots, stuns to help kite and interrupt. When to earth elemental or treants. When to not use your potions so you can invis. If all you do is zug zug DPS then it's not performing your role to full ability.

1
Toasteb•

Routes are somewhat pointless until the timer is a factor. Can you use quicker route, of course but until you’re pushing past KSM they’re not needed just optimized for a run is all.

-4
mackpackowes pixelprophet a beer•

Any and all optimization is pointless in that sense unless the timer is a factor.

1
Toasteb•

No it means no matter which pack of mobs you opt to encounter until KSM shouldnt require an optimal route. Thinking is difficult try harder next time.

0