Is anyone using the 'Color Table' feature a lot? Looking for tips to reduce the number of colors as efficiently as possible
For one of my workflows, I have a requirement to minimize the number of colors by as much as possible, while keeping as much as character as possible in the image.
Using the Cutout filter and then swapping to 'indexed colors' gets me 70% of the way there. I can often reduce the colors to about 40 with no major loss in my image. After that, the degradation is just too great.
But often, a LOT of the colors remaining are extremely close to each other (e.g. 255/255/255 vs 255/255/254). So with a lot of manual work, I'm often able to get done to 10 colors. However, it takes a LONG time to get there, using mostly the Color Table. Hence I was curious if anyone had tips to speed up my workflow.
Random quality of life improvements:
- in the Color Table screen, is it possible to drag and drop the swatches to reorder them? It would be so much easier to group similar color together so analyze the differences
- is it possible to make the color table larger? the swatches are minuscule and its hard to gauge colors from there
- is it possible to 'merge' two colors together? AS I said, sometimes two colors are virtually identical. I'd like to replace one color by another in the Color Table, but I don't see an option for that.
- is it possible to quickly see where a color in the color table is used in the picture? Or just how many pixels are of that color in the picture? (its always possible to change a particular color to bright green, but it gets old after the first few hundred times when processing a few pictures per day)
Maybe photoshop is not the right tool for this. Does anyone knows an editor that's specializing in indexed color work? Or a good filter maybe?
Thank you!
Posted May 9, 2021, 10:12 PM UTC · edited
Some interesting questions and ideas you might want to at least suggest to Feedback.
PS isn't really geared for indexed color work these days, but so far appears to be keeping all of its relevant features. Parts of the interface haven't changed in decades.
Image > Mode > Color Table allows you to edit the individual colors, but not much else. The Save for Web dialog allows you to sort the color table, but still doesn't allow drag/drop. It also allows you to merge colors, albeit by setting the color count to a lower number, without giving you control over which colors are affected.
While you can't merge specific colors together, you can set one of the instances to the same color values as the other. Changes can be previewed, so you could temporarily switch to something like #FF00FF magenta, see which pixels respond, and cancel to get back to normal.
Belated thank you for this lone answer to my post. You're the real MVP :)
Thanks for suggesting that I send my improvements to Adobe. Made me feel a little less 'crazy' to be frustrated about the features I was found to be (IMO) missing.
That's exactly my process. Then I switch to RGB and back to indexed colors to 'merge' the colors I've set to the same value into one 'box' in the Color Table. Rinse and repeat.