Thoughts ok DK changes PTR 5/11..
My Frost take away:
I was going to go through every proposed change, but looking at them, I can summarize more easily with this:
You're still a support, you're still really annoying, your damage will still be pathetic outside of pillar, and your viability is still 100% based on how much you'll disrupt the other team. I personally hate this. I dislike the idea of being so dedicated to a supporting roll, and just being a nuisance rather than an actual threat.
My UH takeaway:
Necrotic wounds: I do not like seeing iconic abilities removed, they could've easily changed the functionality of Necrotic Strike to suite, especially since its still talented. 5% is still too weak when you consider how powerful healing is, and when directly compared to the MS they've handed out to most other melee.
Nerfing Abom in a cooldown driven meta is a kick in the teeth. Would you even bother taking it on a 2min CD when half the healers in the game can CC it with minimal effort? That said, it lost a lot of utility whenever rogues where given a stealth shield. So perhaps this is for the best.
Life and Death: Arguably the squishiest melee in the game with the longest major defensive CD will have to take this to have any increased survivability in a word where certain other melee counters failed to get nerfed. EDIT: Had this confused with the healing component of Necrotic wounds. Nerfing this talent is a bit of a joke because i'm not sure anyone has ever taken it.
Doomburst: A promising talent, but i suspect will be highly limited by festering wound generation. Still, this might make for an interesting choice with Death's Certainty legendary, especially at the higher end where teams know to CC your pet during DT.
Strangulate: Its now a pvp talent that competes with 4-6 other seemingly mandatory pvp talents.
Death's Echo: 2x grip, useful against casters but at the expense of an extremely valuable pvp talent.
Image is tooltips and pvp talent selection.
Posted May 12, 2021, 3:00 AM UTC · edited
I think the Unholy changes are really good. I think you might have missed the part for Necrotic wounds that says it stacks. It will be upwards of a 30% MS, and unless there is some ICD attached to the ability, I think it has potential to be one of the strongest MS effects in the game. There is so much synergy with the new Unholy honor talents that I'm reluctant to give a full opinion until I play with them myself. At a bare minimum Unholy is going to be extremely fun rotationally. As for the Abom nerf, I think it's good. Even though it's feels kind of lazy for a fix, Abom was so clunky I that I'm happy we likely won't be running it.
Frost on the other hand feels like it's going to be stuck with the same style of play, where you're just supporting. However, instead of being good againt melee it looks like they're going to be the anti-caster. Running double grip, big zone, and the 12% haste reduction sound like it will make double caster so much easier. It might still be unfun for people to fight, but it seems like this is blizzard's wanted design for Frost.
Overall, I think the biggest issue, even for a lot of other specs, is that we still only have three honor talents. Stuff like big zone is taken in most games, meaning a lot of these talents won't ever be picked up. I genuinely hope that we see a fourth honor talent added. Even though there could be really fun synergy with these new talents, you probably won't see them with how many talents can't not be taken. Against double melee it might be different, but at least against any team with more than one caster, stuff like big zone and strangulate/double grip will probably be autolocked, which leaves only a single optional talent choice.
Obviously i know necrotic wounds will stack, but its a max of 30% of total hp and in current gear, even taking every available haste piece, you're not achieving that outside of unholy assault. Necrotic today, on live, is 6% and none of the remaining UHDKs even take it.
I could be wrong, but i believe in 8.3 it came out to be something like 8% and was actually scary to people. I believe it could also crit and double the effect, making the crit essence pretty decent for UH. As it stands now, at 5% per stack, I don't even think you slot it over life & death, doomburst, and necromancer's bargain. I agree a 4th talent might actually make UH viable, but all we're seeing is pvp talent changes to try and bandaid a fundamentally broken spec in pvp.
I could be wrong, but based off everything I have heard so far, Necrotic Wounds is an MS effect. That means it should be reducing healing done by 5% per stack, not like how Necrotic Strike works. I personally can't 100% confirm it since I'm very far away from my computer. Either way, it's definitely worded strangely.
Though, I personally think Unholy will be really good whichever way it turns out.
Edit: Seemingly it is weird. It isn't MS, but it also doesn't work like Necrotic Strike. It's classified as an absorb, which means it stacks with stuff like Sharpen Blade. It currently has no absorb cap, so it won't fall off after absorbing 5% of their health. It can absorb a limitless amount of healing for the 12 seconds it is applied.
Mes went over it with a dev on stream and it’s separate from MS it just absorbs healing
It's not a standard mortal strike - it's a separate healing absorb mechanic and it can't be healed off like old Necrotic could. UH DK will be even stronger now with classes that do bring MS, because the effects will stack together for oppressive amounts of healing reduction during a go.
Playing Necromancer's Bargain will even let you get stacks up instantly every 20 ish seconds. UH is going to have a lot of incredibly good options.
Perhaps I am reading it wrong, but I think it is not a 5% max health absorb like necrotic strike was but 5% of all healing.
Necrotic strike text says: A vicious strike that deals (30% of Attack power) Plague damage, and converts 1 Festering Wound into a Necrotic Wound, absorbing up to 6% of the target's maximum health in healing received.
This new text says: Bursting a Festering Wound converts it into a Necrotic Wound, absorbing 5% of all healing received for 12 sec and healing you for the amount absorbed when the effect ends. Max 6 stacks. Adding a stack does not refresh the duration..
So rather than just limited to 30% of max health which currently is around 12k, it would be 30% of all healing done over 12 seconds, though yeah keeping it at max stacks would probably be done in a burst window. One thing is, the bursting sores talent in the 2nd row makes the 6% healing absorb into a 7.5% with the old necrotic strike so I wonder if it would make the 30% MS form the new pvp talent into a 37.5% MS as it can go beyond the max health if thats the healing they receive which would put the maximum healing reduction somewhere between Mortal Strike/Sharpen blade (25%/50%) when you poped all 6 wounds (maybe an apocalypse +sudden doom proc death coil on someone who had 6 festering wounds)
That is correct, however according to the tooltip, adding a necrotic wound stack does not refresh the duration. I'd test this further on the PTR but the pvp dummy isn't showing the necrotic wounds and none of the pvp queues are popping.
During normal rotations, the absorb might not be significant. But if you take Necrotic Wounds, Strangulate, and Necromancer's, that means every minute you can get a huge go with a stun/silence on the healer, Dark Trans, and Unholy Frenzy/Apoc to quickly stack things. If you pair yourself with a class that has a normal MS debuff that stacks with your healing absorb, that is a scary amount of pressure every minute.
Also don't forget that you're healed equal to the amount absorbed. If the healer is bombing heals on his teammate, that's a nice plus.
On mes’ stream he got the heal to pop for 31k the other night with healer healing into it
multiple GCDs and resources spent to get what amounts to a crappy MS that can't be refreshed.
Thats what we like