The McSweeney Sisters

New York City

Leah’s preoccupation with how she is perceived seems to extend to her sister. Sarah is not married to Russell Steinberg, yet Leah refers to Russell as her “brother-in-law” and neither Leah nor Sarah correct people when they refer to Russell as “Sarah’s husband.” Russell is the father of their two-year-old daughter, they have been together nearly five years, and they are most definitely a couple and a family, but why bother with the subterfuge?

I think Russell is an interesting character. He’s 50-ish and is more or less a performance artist—as a lounge-lizard character named Johnny Fayva. He was a fringe part of this Los Angeles/GenX music environment that peaked in the ‘90s. I’ve listened to a few podcasts he has been on and he never refers to Sarah as his wife, rather his “girlfriend.”

I also find it refreshing that he was married to Tatiana von Fürstenberg for more than ten years and has a 21-year-old daughter with her—and Tatiana, Russell, and their daughter all seem to have a very healthy, post-divorce relationship. (I also think that being Diana von Fürstenberg’s son-in-law and Barry Diller’s step-son-in-law must have been a very rarefied existence while he was married to Tatiana. Barry Diller is a legit billionaires). Russell met Sarah McSweeney the summer of 2016—about two years after his divorce—at Burning Man...he was 47 and she was 27...and he was clearly smitten. As far as why they are not married, I have no idea. Maybe he’s hesitant since he is divorced.

But ultimately, I find it to be absolutely obvious that you’re incredibly concerned about what people think of you when you do stuff like let people assume you’re married when you’re not: in other words, it’s the antithesis of the coolness you are trying to convey.

Posted May 12, 2021, 5:26 AM UTC

1920
generally_here•

I don’t really think Leah and her sister are a good fit for RHONY, but I don’t think calling Russel husband/brother in law is that weird. After so many years of a relationship, it’s pretty common IMO. I know plenty of people who just say “brother in law” because it’s easier than saying “my sister’s long term serious boyfriend who she has a kid with”. I don’t think it’s that deep.

56
BecauseMJCOP•

I don't think it's weird and I think a lot of people do it, because as you say it is easier...and it is shorthand, but to me it's another grey area with them where they try to subtly steer perception...towards what they want the narrative to be and away from where they don't want it to be...just like Leah says she's a native New Yorker...which is technically correct if you consider where you were born and spent your pre-teen years where you are from...but to me, she is from Newtown, CT. Her family moved to Western Connecticut to stretch a dollar before their oldest started high school and they had to deal with the "private versus parochial versus public school" conundrum that is having children in NYC...not uncommon and nothing to be ashamed of, yet Leah attempts to take something incredibly banal and create a much more compelling origin story: "bad girl gets shipped off to school in Connecticut" has more dramatic potential than "social worker mom and city worker dad move their 3 kids to a two-family house in almost-rural Connecticut when their oldest is 13."

As far as the Sarah/husband thing...I think the devil is in the details and hearing Sarah as a guest on a podcast where she refers to Russell as her husband then hearing Russell on the same podcast a few months later refer to Sarah as his "girlfriend" and "baby mama" is the real story to me. Does Sarah want to be married? Probably. I'd like to know more about that. I think people are much more interesting if they are authentic instead of trying to come across as how they want to be perceived.

1†
generally_here•

I think you are looking into it all way too much. Leah feels like her truth is that she’s a native New Yorker because that’s where she was born and spent a lot of her formative years. Who are you to say that’s not valid? And if Sarah and Russell aren’t on the same page with their relationship language at all times, that’s pretty normal too.

I’m not denying they’re curating their image- they’re on TV and want to be famous so obviously they are. But I don’t think they’re totally phony or lying about where they’re from, their relationships, etc. They’re a little obnoxious and self involved, sure, but they don’t stretch their back story any more than Sonja “I partied with John John on a yacht” Morgan.

12
thatgirlinny•

Right?? Who on reality TV isn’t “curating an image?” Please.

2
kelp____•

This! I don’t see Leah as being intentionally phony, she really sees herself that way. The way people see themselves is often very different than the way the world sees them.

Thanks for your comment, I enjoyed that podcast info!

5
DorindasLiverI'll tell you how I'm doing, not well Bitch•

Leah and Sarah are so bland. Not rhony material. Eboni outshines Leah even when she taps out early like a wuss

21
thatgirlinny•

Eboni tapped out like a wuss? Okay.

1
DorindasLiverI'll tell you how I'm doing, not well Bitch•

Bless her heart and her razorsharp tongue, but yes.

1
arlobarlow•

It blows my mind that Andy Cohen vacations with DVF and Barry on their yacht, I just can’t imagine what they have in common

14

Averice. And rampant narcissism.

14
thatgirlinny•

A voracious appetite to stockpile luxury real estate here, put their names on public edifices. Those are just two.

1
Rope-Fuzzy•

I have been with my partner 22 years, we are not married. Sometimes I call him my boyfriend, or partner, or occasionally husband, usually husband to people who I don‘t know because it’s just easier and quicker. Boyfriend feels a bit childish sometimes and partner can be ambiguous and be interpreted as same sex couple so if I just say husband it readily defines what I’m talking about. It’s really no big deal.

13
tergesa•

I'd argue that's totally different though because 22 years is obviously much different than 5 years.

2
thatgirlinny•

Not really. When a couple is committed, they’re committed. I called my husband a husband and he called me wife long before we married. It’s a reference point for nitpickers who think someone else’s relationship is somehow their business. 🤷‍♀️

2
BecauseMJCOP•

Try saying that to probate court and see how that goes. It can be a big deal if, say, your long term partner is in the hospital with a serious illness and only legal family is allowed to visit—so you’re not, or your “not-husband’s” brother gets to make life support decisions...or if one of you dies, you have no will, and your not-legal “mother-in-law” inherits your husband’s assets. Being married and having a husband/wife is a legal arrangement, so no matter how much Leahsister says Russell is her husband, he is not in the ways that count.

1
thatgirlinny•

Who’s to say they don’t have a legal domestic partnership? You have intimate knowledge of their affairs?

Why is anyone who isn’t a beneficiary in or party to said partnership so concerned with this? So daft.

2
RLTizE•

It’s common in my husband’s side of the family to refer to long term partners as husband/wife. I do not think it’s a big deal or them trying to alter perceptions or anything like that but who knows?

9
Plotatochep•

I have no thoughts on Sarah's relationship with her boyfriend/child's father, but upvoting for this info! I had no idea! It kind of makes Leah's casting more sense.

5
BecauseMJCOP•

Yes...the connection to DVF & Diller. Meanwhile, it may have been mentioned in casting but never on the show, which I suspect is due to Russell being very private when it comes to TVF and their daughter, Antonia.

2
thatgirlinny•

Reality TV cast members preoccupied with how they’re perceived? Unfathomable!

1