First Impressions - Generally happy but could do with some work
Hey there, I figured this might be the best way to reach the author of the course.
I've just purchased the course today and completed the first few tutorials. The information is excellent and I'm happy with the results so far, the content/organization could do with a little work though.
- The tutorials in the Workshop aren't in the correct order. I'd suggest re-organizing them and labeling their progression clearly (e.g. tutorial 1.1, 1.2, 1.3)
- After completing the "Basic Stylized Smart Material (Free download)" tutorial, the next obvious tutorial to start is "BEGINNERS START HERE: ..." which teaches a completely different way to do it. Is this just old content?
- The next tutorial seems to be "Level 1: Beginner's Guide for Wood Textures...". This video is completely silent. I think this would be fine as additional content, but not so near the start of the course.
- Your narration misses out lots of steps (e.g. toggling parameters). This makes it hard to follow along the video. I think the official Substance tutorials are a great reference on how to do a good video tutorial/course.
- The narration is often out of sink with your actions, again this makes it kind of hard to follow.
- I think there should be more explanation of the *why* and not the *what*.
- As this is aimed at beginners, you could probably do with some intro videos explaining the key elements of stylized textures so we know what we should be incorporating/aiming for.
- There's some level of prerequisite knowledge required to complete this course. It might be nice to have a quick video/tutorial pointing out what is required and where you can learn about it.
Anyway, I hope this helps, and I can only encourage you to keep making more content like this.
Posted May 14, 2021, 9:46 AM UTC
22
Thanks for the critiques!! I agree with most of the points you made, I definitely need to hop back into the content and update/reorganize a big chunk of it, a lot of it is out of date.
I'm currently working on releasing a UE4 course, so once that's done I'll be making a free add-on to the coloring book that teaches the basics to absolute beginners, and I'm going to try to update a lot of the content as well. Hopefully that really improves the experience for everyone.
I really appreciate the feedback!
Thanks! As I'm progressing through the course I can see a big improvement. Good luck with your UE4 course.