Will we ever see a new Infinity Engine game?

I was thinking that given the lasting popularity of the IE games it would be exciting to have a new game in the engine. I'm sure it's outdated and clunky to work with, but given its low requirements in graphical assets and its ease to mod it, it could become a popular game in the niche with low financial risk.

Now, I don't know who holds the rights on the IE anymore or how feasible would it be to license the engine, but games like Solasta prove that you can build a deep and interesting game based upon the D&D SRD rules without having to license the IP from Wizards of the Coast.

What are your thoughts about it? Would it be worth it, or would devs do better with their own modern engines?

Posted May 15, 2021, 2:28 PM UTC

1028
ShredHeadEdd•

It is played out, dated as hell and wouldn't sell very well. Isometric RPGs are pretty niche and it seems the people who love them really love them, but most people get turned off by the complexity.

It isnt the infinity engine that has the magic, its the writing and characters, its the world building and side plots. But most of all its a connection to a time in many of our childhoods when we first picked it up, in an era where you played games to death because there wasnt another one just a steam download away.

Just look at pillars of eternity and how that panned, even though it was a good game. And that wasn't even old graphics

15
kore_nametooshort•

I'd argue that POE was more complex and had worse writing and quests than the IE games.

I agree with you that it's unlikely that we'll see specifically a new IE game unless Beamdog somehow gets permission to make IWD3 or their own forgotten realms IP in the engine, but I think / hope we'll continue see more CRPGs in the genre.

9
ShredHeadEdd•

It definitely wasnt more complex. The first one didnt even have multi classing and the second had a whole skill tree to work with. Both are far less complicated than trying to figure out when to dual class!

I think we will see more games in the genre like you say, but I'm not so sure we will see as many RTWP games. It seems to be less successful than turn based.

6
kore_nametooshort•

Point taken, but I'd argue that dual classing in BG adds depth whereas POE had complexity that made it less accessible.

The reason I said POE was more complex was because I had no idea what was happening in combat and I couldn't be bothered to read through all of the 400 spells I had thrown at me immediately to decide which to cast at which point. Plus all of the armour and what not had 10% reduction of 1 thing for a 10% gain of another. It made me feel like I needed a spreadsheet to work out what was optimal.

At least in BG you generally only need to read a few spell descriptions at a time as you come across spells and generally things are more intuitive about whether it's an upgrade or not.

Edit: I'm probably immune to part of the complexity of BG because I've played it so often but I suppose my real point is that I could imagine a RTWP game without the stupid complexity of either Poe or BG but with just as much interesting depth.

You might be right about no new RTWP games but I'll remain in hope.

3
TwiceTested•

Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous is coming out in september! Its another aventure path from Kingmaker in the same world, Golarian. Earn godlike powers while fighting the forces of the Abyss, just be careful you don't fall to corruption along the way....

5
Peter_OfTheNorth•

Here's my prediction... The Infinity Engine will eventually become open source... free to use for any programmer who is interested in using old gaming software. At that point, the Baldur's Gate fans (who will always be around) will use it to build new things. Some of it will be utter rubbish, possibly most of it... but I am confident that someone will do something wonderful with the Infinity Engine one day in the future. It may not be related to Baldur's Gate at all... but many people have a great affection for the Infinity Engine experience, that kind of game... whether it is Icewind Dale, or Planescape Torment, or Baldur's Gate... I don't think this way of enjoying a roleplaying game will disappear. To this day, people enjoy Infinity Engine games, and it would not surprise me if new fans were discovering Baldur's Gate in 2040... so I think, I hope, the Infinity Engine is here to stay. It will never again be the base for a new AAA game, but it will have a fanbase for as long as great games like BG are remembered.

12
TDStrange•

Bioware is owned by EA and still owns the Infinity Engine, Beamdog only holds a license to it. EA would have to decide to open source it and that seems like a longshot.

4
disperso•

Do we have a clear source on this? I've seen conversations on the Beamdog forums sometimes, but it's a very unstructured place to have this discussion and see any authoritative source gave an answer. On the Copyright notices, Beamdog also has copyright on it, but I don't know if it would apply to the source code or just the artistic content they added in the EEs. So I don't know exactly the terms, which are probably very complex due to the nature of the product and the crazy history of different parties involved.

I also hope it can be made public, even if under restrictive terms (OSI approved license would be better of course), but I have little hope.

1
GraionDilachNovice EE modder•

I don't think IE ends up open-source. GemRB however is a thing already and I give a bigger chance to that getting EE (format) support and other games written on it.

4
shadowsofmindOP•

I'm not sure of what's GemRB even after having read their website. Can people make a game with it?

1
TDStrange•

It's an open source IE engine clone, you can download that and run BG1/2 on it instead of the Bioware engine. And theoretically yes, but it'd be a massive amount of work, mainly because every bit of art would have to be created from scratch. Nothing could be reused from BG because none of it is open source. Hard to get people to do that for free...

3
disperso•

Making a game is something that some companies have approached the GemRB about, but it's all been vaporware. They are preparing a game demo which is all done on open source assets that can go with the open source engine.

I don't have any hopes of a real game being done on either the Infinity Engine (Beamdog said an explicit "no" not so long ago) or on GemRB. There is just not good enough tooling to create any kind of asset. All the file formats are pretty terrible and outdated for today's standards. Backgrounds, animations, scripting, creature files, spells, etc.

It would be a thousand times better to use any modern game engine or custom code, and create something from scratch nowadays.

Also, it would be a legal mine field, given that WotC doesn't like old editions rule sets cannibalizing the newer products. One would have to say that the game is based on For Gold and Glory (an AD&D 2nd edition retroclone).

1
ScarsUnseen•

It would be a thousand times better to use any modern game engine or custom code, and create something from scratch nowadays.

Pretty much this. Frankly, other than familiarity for people who are deep in the modding community, I don't think there's anything special about the Infinity Engine itself. You could make a game with the exact same style both in terms of gameplay and graphics in the Godot engine, and once you got the basic framework up it would be much easier to create content for.

3
GraionDilachNovice EE modder•

Only the ruleset concern is a valid issue, the format issues can be fixed. OpenRA is a great example. It started with handling Westwood formats but in the last 4-5 years, the engine was prepared to be used as a generic RTS engine and as part of that, generic graphic options were added and projects from scratch are suggested to build on metadatad PNG sprite sheets (the PNG spec allows tEXT blocks in any PNG which can hold any text, OpenRA chose to hold frame sizes and count for the engine to know how to cut the sheet up internally as one of such blocks).

There is an ongoing commercial project on OpenRA as well as an OS IP - https://openhv.itch.io/openhv (although this latter does resurrect an abandoned RTS from the mid '90s whose author just threw the artwork out in the open). I know, I am involved in the latter and we literally covered everything by now but music and map pool for the most part. Although I acknowledge, RTS development can be simpler than RPG development.

2
shadowsofmindOP•

One downside of using third-party engines like Unity is the devs can't give the community free access to their tools to create new content, which would revitalize the niche.

1
gldnbear2008•

A future we can all look forward to.

3
difalins•

I don't think it will happen, but I would REALLY LOVE a dragonlance and a darksun campaign of epic proportions in the engine.

A man's dreams will never die! Zee-ha-ha-ha

7
bobbyOrrMan•

Nope. They had 20 years and made bupkis.

I really would have loved a new game every other year, set in a new area of Faerun. They never tried it. Shame.

Now we got slowly degrading quality in Elder Scrolls games.

5
elsmallo85•

I mean, the 'Siege of Dragonspear' was technically new when it came out. I didn't mind it at all. I'm a bit of a luddite and very prone to nostalgia so I'd be happier if the new BG were infinity based, although I'm sure the new one will do fine.

For me the painted art backgrounds make it; if the level design is nice and the plots and dialogues good enough... although the avatars and their lack of variety had me bored in 2001, tbh.

4
macbalance•

Unlikely.

SoD ‘snuck in’ because it was supposed to be DLC (but made a separate game on iOS at least) but there’s been rumors WotC doesn’t approve games that are based on old rules if nothing else.

I feel like an ‘Infinity-Engine-like’ game could work though.

3
DaMac1980•

As much as I love the IE games I don't really hold much loyalty to that engine. Unity isn't great either for various reasons, but the added functionality and visuals of something like Pillars of Eternity are quite nice. I definitely want more of these kinds of games, but do I want them in the Infinity Engine? Meh, not really.

That said if Beamdog still have the license and make something else like SoD, I would absolutely buy it.

3
pharmacist10•

Say what you want about Pillars of Eternity or Tyranny, but the modern isometric graphics, animations and art design is awesome. The full BG trilogy remade in that engine would be sublime (and never happen).

3

Open source it.

1
disperso•

but games like Solasta prove that you can build a deep and interesting
game based upon the D&D SRD rules without having to license the IP
from Wizards of the Coast

Can you elaborate on that? Because after a quick check, that seems the content published under the Open Gaming License, which applies in this case for 5th edition. I don't know if WotC retroactively relicensed some AD&D 2nd edition under the OGL. I think it all started with the 3rd.

1
shadowsofmindOP•

Game mechanics can't protected by copyright. That's why there are tabletop retroclones of OD&D and AD&D. Now, the SRD allow devs to use actual rules text, monsters, spells, and so on. A 3.5 clone would be easier because there's more material available, but nothing prevents a developer to file off the numbers from AD&D and make a game 90% similar.

3
disperso•

Thank you, that's good to know. I've heard of game mechanics not being bound to copyright, and certainly I know that plenty of retroclones exist (For Gold & Glory specifically for AD&D 2nd edition). I still would be very uncomfortable in doing a project based on this without a good reassurance from some lawyers, as this companies often have an easy trigger with Cease and Desist letters. :-/

1