ELI5: Why has someone came up with cheaper jetfuel ?

R6 (Loaded/False Premise)

[removed]

Posted May 16, 2021, 6:41 PM UTC

018
WeDriftEternal•

Electric airplanes have long been a great idea and people have tried to make work, but unfortunately, outside of experimental craft, its just not viable yet.

Airplane engines, both prop and jet engines, need a ton of power and a lot of fuel. Electric batteries simply aren't powerful enough compared to fuel at the same weight. You'd have so many batteries that they would weigh too much, fuel on other hand, provide a lot more energy for the weight. An electric plane wouldn't get too far, it would be too heavy. Fuel is a great compromise as its quite powerful for the weight.

If we ever get batteries down an absolute ton in weight, we might see ideas for some smaller planes to operate on electric power. But the big planes would need even more reductions in battery weight or wild increases in battery efficiency and storage

9
Sm00gz•

Couldn't they be used to maintain flight though? Obviously reaching altitude has to require a lot of energy, could they be phased in like they are with cars, mot as a replacement. But to reduce consumption in certain areas. Where would one go about attempting to calculate something like this.

1
mmmmmmBacon12345•

Most of the fuel is used during the cruising stage. Even though the engines are most efficient at cruise, you need a lot of power to keep a big plane going Mach 0.8 even at 35,000 feet.

Wikipedia has a surprisingly complete list of fuel burn rates by planes and distances. If you scoot down to medium haul flights and pick something like the A321 Neo Long Range (second down) its going through about 3 kg/km.

Flip over to [Energy Density](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#In_chemical_reactions_(oxidation\)) and you'll see that Jet Fuel/Kerosene has a density of 43 MJ/kg so it takes about 120 MJ per km traveled by an A321 Neo.

Even if you picked a super ambitious Lithium Metal Battery at 1.8 MJ/kg you're still looking at needing 24 kg of batteries to replace each kg of fuel so instead of 1000 km requiring 3000 kg of kerosene it requires 24,000 kg of batteries in a plane that has a max takeoff weight of just 97,000 kg that's a good percentage of the overall mass just as batteries, it greatly drops the cargo capacity and max range to make the plane useless.

Batteries simply don't have the energy density of chemical fuels, they fundamentally can't either.

4
Sm00gz•

This was the response I was looking for. lol

3
WeDriftEternal•

They're too heavy. We are way not there yet. We need to massively reduce battery weight to make it viable. Fuel is just so efficient that its hard to compete.

People try all sorts of stuff with electric planes, but run into the same problem. If you want a plane to have batteries, but stay a reasonable weight, then you can't have many batteries. This means the plane lacks enough energy to go any reasonable distance. But there's a solution! Fuel. Tons of energy for the weight.

If we would have started out with electric planes, we'd have quickly shifted to fuel, because batteries are too heavy. Maybe sometime in the future our battery tech will grow tremendously, but we're nowhere close to competing with aircraft fuel

2
SupersonicScrub•

Some small scale regional aircraft are experimenting with hybrid engines for precisely this reason. Engines are designed for the thrust/climb-out phase, and are therefore overpowered for cruise and less efficient than they could if if they could just start at cruise. A hybrid engine allows the fuel powered component to be optimized for cruise rather than overpowered. It's still in the early stages though, and would only be viable for aircraft of the size of a Dash-8. It's simply not going to work for larger aircraft though

https://runwaygirlnetwork.com/2019/04/23/will-dash-8-hybrid-electric-x-plane-hit-the-spot-for-green-aviation/

2
Sm00gz•

Thank you for that, it's something.

1

altitude is not exactly a problem. Maintaining speed vs air density is a problem. Maintaining cruise speeds gobbles fuel even for a subsonic aircraft (i.e. your standard passenger liner aircraft, which goes like mach 0.9 or thereabouts). And goes up through the roof for anything supersonic. Aircraft are FAST, I mean really FAST.

​

And combustion driven engines have way more energy density in their fuel, than batteries.

​

Another problem is mass. The more mass the aircraft has, the more fuel needed. Thus the more cost. More engines / dual engine type setup equals LOTS more mass. And way less reliability. And more complex design, thus more complex and costly maitenance.

2
A_Garbage_Truck•

Weight remains a problem.Expended fuwel is no longer weighing the plane down.

a Dead Battery does and a disposable battery that is powerful enough to drive a aircraft seems like both a safety and environmental disaster waiting to happen.

unless power and weight go down to the point its comparable with carrying the same load in fuel, the tech isn't there yet.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
ArchitecktonMOD•

Your submission has been removed for the following reason(s):

Top level comments (i.e. comments that are direct replies to the main thread) are reserved for explanations to the OP or follow up on topic questions.

Short answers, while allowed elsewhere in the thread, may not exist at the top level.

Full explanations typically have 3 components: context, mechanism, impact. Short answers generally have 1-2 and leave the rest to be inferred by the reader

If you would like this removal reviewed, please read the detailed rules first. If you believe this was removed erroneously, please use this form and we will review your submission.

1
WRSaunders•

The US Navy has experimented with biofuel for fighter jets, in a program called Green Hornet. It's definitely a thing you can do, but it's still quite a bit more expensive than petroleum. It's everything you want, except cheaper.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
data15cool•

Jet fuel prices are more determined by taxation and legislation. The energy density of fuel is far greater than batteries. The power output too I think. Either way when weight is a key aspect in your transport method you want the fuel to contribute as little as possible.

1
A_Garbage_Truck•

a battery powered plane has only been done on experimental craft so far, hanst panned into anything YET,

issue is twofold:

1: Batteries aren't quite there yet in power output to be able to maintain any prop or Jet engine for any significant amount of time

2:Much like Fuel, Batteries have Weight but unlike with Fuel you aren't burning this extra weight away as your Craft flies so the system has to have the same output at all stages, this is easier on a craft that is getting progressively lighter(burning jet fuel away), but impossible atm if you need to carry dead batteries that only drag the aircraft down.

1
BillWoods6•

The energy density of hydrocarbon fuels is extraordinary. It may be easier to create a cheap source of electricity to make synthetic fuel, rather than to create equivalent batteries.

1
chrome-spokes•

why has someone not came up with cheaper aviation fuel

A quick googly shows that in April, 2021 jet fuel cost was $1.67 a gallon!

This is cheap, comparatively. And one reason is with its major component being kerosene, which takes lots less in refining to produce than say with gasoline.

1
Flair_HelperMOD•

Please read this entire message

Your submission has been removed for the following reason(s):

Loaded questions, or ones based on a false premise, are not allowed on ELI5. A loaded question is one that posits a specific view of reality and asks for explanations that confirm it. These usually include the poster's own opinion and bias, but do not always - there is overlap between this and parts of Rule 2. Note that this specifically includes false premises.

If you would like this removal reviewed, please read the detailed rules first. If you believe this submission was removed erroneously, please use this form and we will review your submission.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3