Flying Thunder God Kunai in PF2

Homebrew Item

Hello hivemind,

I created three versions of throwing knives to replicate Minato Naimake's signature technique for PF2.

Enjoy!

Version 1: Item Level 5

Version 2: Item Level 12

Version 3: Item Level 19

(Edit) takeway: less is more!

Posted May 17, 2021, 10:17 AM UTC · edited

56
HeroicVanguard•

Once per minute to negate an attack entirely, in addition to burning their move action to then get to you, combined with Dex to Damage, which is very specifically relegated to the Thief Rogue, make this feel incredibly overtuned to me.

10
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Thanks! I initially thought bumping the weapon die to a d6 would be too op and changed it to dex mod. I wanted the item to mostly be used as a throwing knife as well as for mobility/positioning, and the increased damage should only apply to melee Strikes.

2
DavidoMcG•

Cool idea but too OP. Here are my pointers:

  • Remove Dex to damage. This is too powerful for any weapon that isnt a legendary artifact.
  • Teleportation doesnt come around until spellcasters hit 4th level spells so the item level should start at 9 or maybe 8 as its a weaker teleport.
  • Flying thunder I's ability should be once a day. I would also weaken it so you must throw it to a location so that you can teleport away. Being able to throw it and teleport as a reaction is just too much.
  • Flying Thunder II should be knocked up to level 14. Give the first ability an hour timer and i would just make the second ability a single action throw and teleport while also making the creature flatfooted against your next attack. I would also give this an hour timer.
  • Flying Thunder III can knock all the previous ability timers to a minute and keep the new ability as is.
6
kneymoOPGM in Training•

Glad that you like it. You're probably right that anime special should be reserved for lategame :D

  • The earliest access to teleportation effects I could find was for Monks at level 6.
  • The first draft for level Flying Thunder was what you suggested. It required to have a Flying Thunder within range in order to be able to teleport away from an attack. It's probably the more tactical and more interesting approach, but I wanted it to be usable at least once per combat. I can see how that would be too much at this level.
  • Flying Thunder II is based on Twin Takedown, a level 1 ability. I added movement for an extra action and conditional flat footed, at level 12. Why would you bump it to 14?
3
DavidoMcG•

Well there's plenty of anime in 2e and to be fair he was the hokage and his abilities were high level.

  • I forgot about the monk ability but i did cover this by making it a level 8 item for being a weaker teleport than dimension door. The general rule should be if the item has a magical effect 1/day, it should be 2 levels higher and 4 levels if its multiple times.
  • I think the first draft is definitely more tactically engaging as it promotes actually throwing or dropping the weapon. Teleporting in 2e is very restricted at lower to mid levels as to stop people easily bypassing obstacles or getting out of positional mistakes easily which is rife in 5e and older editions. Having that kind of teleportation easily accessible at that level would have the GM pulling his hair out.
  • I just felt having it be a 1 action thrown attack then teleport with flatfooted added made it a stronger ability overall. Having it as 1 action makes it more tactically engaging and gives you more actions to pull off something crazy.
5
kneymoOPGM in Training•

The general rule should be if the item has a magical effect 1/day, it should be 2 levels higher

... good catch!

Having it as 1 action makes it more tactically engaging and gives you more actions to pull off something crazy.

... like a 2-action Rasengan from behind :P

​

Thank you again, I think I got it now.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1