r/stunfisk•
siamond

Why do we use percentages over exact numbers?

Discussion

I've been reading over this whole thing and I'm struggling to understand how it all works.

In my mind, we want as little variance as possible and for the most skilled player to win. That's why we've introduced the sleep clause, banned OHKO moves and even banned Dynamax.

Keeping this in mind, why don't we want to show exact numbers? What I've seen thus far are two lines of argumentation. One is that we want variance. However we've slowly been removing it from the game. So what is the harm in removing this one step and thus raising the skill floor (with more info available the ceiling doesn't not get lower)? The second is that the games on cartridge don't work that way. However, we've shown we don't care about the cartridge. We don't have Dynamax. We don't have OHKO moves. We don't have sleep clause. Why do we need to show HP in the same antiquated way? Most of us agree that pokemon should evolve with time.

Posted May 18, 2021, 3:44 PM UTC

7041
Flappersnapper•

There are different tiers that do not have dynamax banned, OHKO or sleep clauses. Those rules prevent actions and do not ADD anything new. Those are regulations but an HP change would affect the actual game and not the tier only. Unless there's an entire tier for HP numbers, which would be too extra.

Using exact numbers will reveal EV spreads if HP is displayed before an attack even hits. It also would be an ADDED feature that goes beyond the game rather than to optimize the game.

EV spreads on some pokemon are important and do add variation that add elements of surprise or unknowing. A skilled player still tries to take this variation into account and will not reveal the true stats/move set/item on a party member unless needed. These are player customized variations, that are encouraged and make the game fun.

150

As someone who does funny ev spreads i second this. Especially when i run stuff like av mamo and blunder policy volcanion

6
beyardo•

Showing the opponents exact HP value gives you additional information on them that you wouldn’t have otherwise. If I see minimum or maximum HP investment values, that tells me a lot about the set that another Pokémon is running.

120
Shock3600•

It’s also a quality of life thing. If you tell me an attack does 40% to a Pokémon, I know exactly how much that is doing. If you tell me it’s doing 200 damage- fuck if I know. 200 hp is wildly dependent on the Pokémon and requires much more knowledge to figure out what it means relatively

37
Cowboy_Dan1•

The cart accuracy vs enhanced game experience debate has been around as long as simulators have been around. Banning certain moves/mons/options doesn't break cart accuracy but there definitely are standard clauses that do, the most notorious examples being sleep and freeze clause which at least do have precedent on pokemon stadium but not on the vast majority of the tiers they are currently implemented on in showdown. Ultimately I think most competitive players care more about upholding the precedents of simulator history rather than cart mechanics (even if they don't realize it) but there are "extremists" (lol) on both sides who either want pure cart accuracy including the removal of sleep clause and similar mods and there are also people who just want to say fuck it let's remove crits and accuracy and make our own game off of this. Ultimately I think the answer to your question is that it wasn't one of the mods implemented in the early days of simulator history so it isn't traditionally accepted and since most of these arguments tend to err on the side of cart purism it will likely never change. Personally I also don't love the idea of my opponents knowing my hp investment since it can reveal a lot of info about the set I'm running.

24
hinode85•

For the record, the use of percentages is not about cartridge accuracy. Actual carts display opposing Pokemon's HP as a 48 pixel length bar, so a truly cartridge-accurate simulator would give info as /48, not /100. The reason behind percentages is that every previous simulator has worked that way, going back all the way to PBS, I believe, and that is what the playerbase wants and prefers.

Early on in Pokemon Showdown's lifetime, there was an attempt to change PS to a cartridge-accurate format like this. It caused a riot among the userbase, who threatened to stick to Pokemon Online instead for tournament play unless it was reverted.

14
FatFingerHelperBot•

It seems that your comment contains 1 or more links that are hard to tap for mobile users. I will extend those so they're easier for our sausage fingers to click!

Here is link number 1 - Previous text "It"


^Please ^PM ^/u/eganwall ^with ^issues ^or ^feedback! ^| ^Delete

7
postsonlyjiyoung100% winrate vs Ojama•

This has been a debate for a while, it's just standard with sims to display exact percentages

7
Cheery_Tree•

I assume you are talking about damage rolls.

Agreeing not to use certain moves or abilities is not the same thing as completely changing how the game works.

5

But having tiers literally changes how the game works. Nothing in the game prevents you from using 6 legendaries to smash your opponent’s 6 Caterpies.

The sleep clause also changes how the game works.

-22
Cheery_Tree•

No, tiers do not change how the game works. There's nothing in the game preventing players from agreeing not to use certain pokemon.

Also legendaries shouldn't be considered different from any other pokemon for the purposes of competitive. Regice is a legendary, but no one would argue that it's better than a Tyranitar.

22
Mawilemawie•

Maybe against a dragon fairy it might be...

-9

Knowing for a fact your opponent doesn’t have a certain Pokémon is no different than knowing for a fact how much HP your opponent’s Pokémon have.

Both give you an information advantage you would not have if you were actually playing Pokémon.

-16
Cheery_Tree•

Team preview has been a thing since generation 5. Also knowing the exact EVs of your opponent is very different from knowing that they won't have a Kyogre on their team.

11
maharg79•

No its not. The amount of HP you have essentially tells me what set you are running generally.

3
Cowboy_Dan1•

It changes how the game works from a game play standpoint but you can create these rule sets without having to go in and alter the fundamental code of the game which is what "changing how the game works" means in this context. Sleep clause is an exception though and there is definitely some debate as to whether we should scrap it in favor of cartridge purity.

2
jonag0•

The answer is pretty simple. Showdown is a "Battle simulator". And since it wants to be that, they want it to be possible to reproduce the game in both ways. Letting the player see the exact numbers of HP wouldn't be a perfect reproduction of the game, since it just isn't shown. While the opponent's exact HP can't be reproduced on Cartridge, clauses very well can. You can follow these rules on both systems without a problem. They use percantages on Showdown because that's what you can even read (via detours) on cartridge.

2
gergnotnef90•

The issue is that, if you knew the exact HP (what im assuming you're saying by exact number v percentage) the opponent could easily tell what build you are running on a lot of pokemon and at that point, thaat pokemon it's now 50% useless.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
WonderfulBug7•

I mean as far as accuracy goes the sims do more than that. I started battling in dppt and the thing that wigs me out most is that the various simulators keep track of revealed information that the cartridges just expect you to remember, Like ops team, their status conditions, hazards, that kind of thing. So it does cut both ways.

Also if you play Pokemon, you start thinking in terms of percent also. I can take maybe one more of those it will be close, then recover or something like that. It can standardize damage calcs

1