Why do we use percentages over exact numbers?
I've been reading over this whole thing and I'm struggling to understand how it all works.
In my mind, we want as little variance as possible and for the most skilled player to win. That's why we've introduced the sleep clause, banned OHKO moves and even banned Dynamax.
Keeping this in mind, why don't we want to show exact numbers? What I've seen thus far are two lines of argumentation. One is that we want variance. However we've slowly been removing it from the game. So what is the harm in removing this one step and thus raising the skill floor (with more info available the ceiling doesn't not get lower)? The second is that the games on cartridge don't work that way. However, we've shown we don't care about the cartridge. We don't have Dynamax. We don't have OHKO moves. We don't have sleep clause. Why do we need to show HP in the same antiquated way? Most of us agree that pokemon should evolve with time.
Posted May 18, 2021, 3:44 PM UTC
There are different tiers that do not have dynamax banned, OHKO or sleep clauses. Those rules prevent actions and do not ADD anything new. Those are regulations but an HP change would affect the actual game and not the tier only. Unless there's an entire tier for HP numbers, which would be too extra.
Using exact numbers will reveal EV spreads if HP is displayed before an attack even hits. It also would be an ADDED feature that goes beyond the game rather than to optimize the game.
EV spreads on some pokemon are important and do add variation that add elements of surprise or unknowing. A skilled player still tries to take this variation into account and will not reveal the true stats/move set/item on a party member unless needed. These are player customized variations, that are encouraged and make the game fun.
As someone who does funny ev spreads i second this. Especially when i run stuff like av mamo and blunder policy volcanion