Top surgery for femme-presenting folk?

Hi!!

I'm about to get cleared for breast reduction surgery, and I'm super excited. Before starting the process and going to consultations and everything I'd had it set in my mind that if I still feel dysphoric (I'm non-binary) after the end result, I'll get top surgery a few years after when I've saved up enough.

The problem is, although I'm very much Not A Woman, I'm comfy in my gender expression, which tends to be very femme, despite binding.

Will surgeons look negatively on this? Can I get denied top surgery because I present as a cis woman most of the time?

I'm from the UK if that makes a difference.

Any advice/thoughts welcome!!

Posted May 18, 2021, 9:03 PM UTC

43
outtoexist•

Heya! While some surgeons might frown on that, certainly not all!! I don't know anything about UK based surgeons, so I can't give you advice on specific people, but what I do know is that anybody can have top surgery/breast reductions! Literally cis women can have top surgery if that best suits them. If you experience discrimination from a surgeon, my suggestion would just be to find another one - you deserve a surgeon who wants to uplift & validate your identity. And surgeons who will do so ARE out there :) Dr. Mosser is a great example and has some amazing FTN resources out there. He is located in the US, so going to him likely wouldn't be feasible, but you could always share his resources with your surgeon or just use them for your own knowledge!

2
Bike_Butch•

Hello mate. I'm in the UK and my experience with looking into top surgery here as a non-binary person has been quite disheartening.

Firstly, as I'm sure you know, getting any kind of gender affirming surgery on the NHS takes years and years of waiting. You can ask your GP for a referral to a Gender Identify Clinic - my GP was pretty floored by the idea of a non binary person wanting top surgery but still sent the referral. However the timelines involved in NHS care are outrageously long which is obviously a bloody nightmare.

Secondly, if you have the option of going privately in the UK then there are a handful of surgeons who provide top surgeries. As far as I'm aware you need to provide a psychiatric referral for all of these surgeons in order for them to operate on you. This referral could be from an NHS GIC or you can pay to go privately for the referrals too. For non-binary folks, surgeons seem to want 2 opinions - with each referral costing around £300 a pop. There seems to be more emphasis on "proving" your gender dysphoria in order to get a psychiatric thumbs up in the UK.

I've decided to go to the US for mine and see a surgeon operating according to informed consent. I don't like the fact that in the UK I have to put my future happiness in the hands of some doctors who have met me for 30 mins. I trust myself more (although don't get me wrong I'm definitely talking to my therapist about all this stuff in the sidelines anyway). So that's a potential option too. Clearly I'm in a privileged position to be able to pay for top surgery but I was surprised to note that the difference in price between the UK and US is pretty negligible.

2
lm2227•

I don’t have any particular insight on how surgeons/healthcare providers in the UK would respond to your seeking out top surgery as a femme presenting person, but imo, if you know top surgery is what you want for yourself, I think it’s OK to present yourself to surgeons as more androgynous/masc than you actually are if you need to in order to get it. (If you’re personally comfortable doing that, that is!) Gatekeeping can be a thing, and I think that in any system that tries to police a individuals’ transness, trans individuals are well within their right to withhold information to get the healthcare they need. If a potential surgeon would deny you top surgery because you’re femme presenting, and you want to get top surgery with them, then that person doesn’t need to know you’re femme.

1