r/whoop•
modrn

Super low HRV and bad recovery? Any clue how to improve it?

Hi all,

I'm newer to Whoop, but I've been pretty alarmed with some of the numbers I'm seeing. I'm 33 yr old Male, with a AVG HR of like 65 - 70 and a RHR of 60 (been out of shape for a while), weight about 150 and I'm 5'8". My physical from my doctor says I'm healthy, no issues, but yet Whoop is showing my HRV as like, 25 - 33(30 Avg) which seems INSANELY low and really has me concerned.

No matter what I do, I don't see it improve and every single night I rarely get past 30% on my recovery, even though I get great nights of sleep? Under 6 disturbances, close to 8 hours of consistent sleep and an average 15 Respitory rate.

So I'm just so confused thinking I'm about to die of heart failure or something even though I feel great and my physicals is healthy?

Posted May 19, 2021, 5:23 PM UTC

317
scriggities•

Drink more water. Like, way more.

5
recycledairplane1•

I drink about as much water as my bladder can hold and my HRV won’t budge past 45.

3
pilch55•

The search function and Whoops blogs/articles will be a great resource for improving those metrics.

Take your doctors blessing of “good” health with a grain of salt. Doctors, for the most part, screen in a very narrow window of “is my patient on their death bed or on their way to their death bed” and if your metrics fall above the already ill on the their health spectrum they treat it as a win. But this can lead to average Joe’s thinking they are in picture perfect health because their doctor said so when in reality the lack of activity, sugar, alcohol, stress, sleep habits, smoking hasn’t caught up to them ...yet.

2
max_rey•

Do you exercise rigorously exercise?

2
modrnOP•

Yeah pretty rigorous, at least as much as I can handle just getting back in shape. I've been getting up to about a 10 each day for strain, sometimes a little lower, but most days it's at least a 10 which for me is a lot right now.

What are your thoughts?

1
max_rey•

Then you need to check out t podcast and blog on the whoop site about HRV. A lot will have to do with good sleep and supplements like magnesium and what helped me the most was melatonin /5mg from NOW Products.

2
Halfwaydead425•

Also 10 is not considered rigorous at all

1
sprusk•

If 30 is your HRV then that is the baseline. No right or wrong number. From that baseline you can tell when it goes up or down on a daily basis. Mine is 35 average

2
I_Gotthis•

I have found a few thing that are effective in boosting HRV and recovery-

Deep breathing is probably the easiest way to boost it, I do it all day long when I feel stress or anxiety, I do it before I go to bed and when I wake up. Having a lot of stress is one of best ways to kill your HRV along with alcohol.

Blue blocker glasses seem to help me sleep better and relax at the end of the day, the longer you wear them the better, I usually put them on after dinner.

I couldn't find any correlation between what I was eating and good or bad HRV, I did however find that my HRV went down when I used any kind of supplement, especially magnesium, but also a multi. Not sure why, but I made the connection. I eat a carb centric diet, but it is pretty clean and do 10-15 hours of endurance training a week. Alcohol destroys my HRV, beer seems to be worse than wine. Not eating enough food during the day and eating a lot of food before bed also seems to hurt my HRV. Hydration is a given.

1
recycledairplane1•

What do you exactly do when you say ‘deep breathing’? I’ve been doing it before bed with a breathing app (breathwrk) for 8-10 mins and it helps me go to bed faster, but no improvement over my recovery or HRV at all. My hrv is similarly very low.

1
I_Gotthis•

I do not really do anything specific in terms of count or time, I just breath in and out and focus on the breathing. I will do anywhere from 30 seconds to five minutes a few times a day, but I try to get some in first thing in the morning. I do a mix between nose and mouth inhaling.

1
recycledairplane1•

Your recoveries will even out as you use whoop. HRV is normal though. I’m in good shape and my metrics are very similar to yours. No real reasons, unfortunately - a doctor won’t be concerned if you ask them. I’ve looked everywhere for answers and it really does seem to just be genetic.

1
snoopy7979•

Regular rigorous cardio with easy recovery workouts sprinkled in, drink water, go to bed early. HRV also seems to be something that takes months to improve and a short amount time of bad behaviors to reverse it. Also, once it’s gets you baseline, your recoveries will start to improve.

Your HRV and RHR is a product of your physiology and 33 years of living. Your baseline isn’t something you can change on a dime but you can definitely improve it with lifestyle changes

1
kaizenkaizen20•

I got my whoop 2 weeks ago. First day was in the green then I dropped to red for 2 days then was in yellow for 10 days. I was feeling awful but not sure why. I never tested HRV before so was freaked out to see how low my HRV was. I was in 22-24 range. I read up on it and found all these articles about how low HRV leads to chronic disease and early death. I read some articles on whoop blog and elite HRV and saw some recommendations for increasing water intake, meditation and box breathing. A few days ago I made a spreadsheet to start tracking my how to increase my HRV. I’ve started taking an epsom salt bath for the magnesium. Increased water intake to 100 oz daily and starting to meditate. Haven’t done box breathing yet. I’m currently on a 5 day fast for cancer prevention. Yesterday on day 4 and today, day 5, my recovery somehow jumped to green after 12 days in red and yellow and I was shocked to see my HRV jumped up to 36. This may be fasting related. This afternoon I end my fast and will see in next days whether my HRV drops or stays up. I read that low HRV means you’re in sympathetic mode a lot so you are in chronic stress mode. There’s a book called The Polyvagal Theory that I am going to read. Hopefully I’ll learn how to get into parasympathetic mode more often. I’ve had a lot of trauma in life so I’m wondering whether that’s why my HRV is so low. I’m going to wait a month to collect more data. I have stopped drinking alcohol over 6 months ago and stopped sugar and refined flour a month ago. I’m eating healthy so I think I need to focus more on hydration, exercise and meditation/box breathing. Good luck on your journey.

1
kaizenkaizen20•

Check out Whoop article titled “Ways to activate the Vagus Nerve and boost HRV and immunity”.

1
r3joe•

Most of the things that Whoop recommends will result in a higher baseline HRV for most people.

1
collegehockeyguy28•

Try a keto / low carb diet for a week and see what happens. I find diet and nutrition has a dramatic impact on my HRV

1